Loads of scratches on the bottom of my bezel from the bumper which it's been in since day 1. I think it's due to dust and other stuff getting in there and rubbing it. Although my friend's iPhone has the same bumper with no scratches, but it feels as though the rubber is stiffer (bought later than me)
I would go for a bumper design so you can show off the back of the phone, but don't go with an Apple one.