I agree this is blunt force, and I don’t think it’s meant to stick, I think it’s meant to shock nations into realizing that tariffs that hurt us won’t be tolerated. When it all shakes down I think there will be renegotiations of tariffs on exports and imports.
Would I have done it this way? Nope, but I also think sometimes you have to take a drastic stand to make a point and remind people how much we all need to be working together instead of continuing to bury us in debt and trade deficits.
I agree with you in observing where the real economy has shifted in recent decades, and the fact that conservatives in particular were concerned about this was good.
However, the West (i.e. Europe, Japan, Korea and Taiwan, all of whom recognized the US as the world's policeman) cannot understand that this task has now been cowardly handed over by the Republicans to an unpredictable and confused-looking puppet master.
A world power needs a level-headed tactician to strive for your described goal or this direction, it needs neither nationalistic muddleheads nor unpredictable puffery.
In Germany, during the state and economic crisis at the end of the 1920s, there was the National Socialist movement, which bundled reparations payments that were perceived as unjust (which damaged the economy as a disease and caused unemployment and inflation) and channeled them into a leader. Undoubtedly a wrong person, because he created a war economy miracle, and then immediately covered people and the world with threats and later war.
No era is comparable to another, and yet individuals and social movements always function in a similar way.
The utopia of a sensibly rational economy through self-sufficiency efforts and populist national recollection is actually always a game with fire. Trump is currently celebrating this in orgasmic fashion. The rest of the world (especially Europe) is speechless and horrified, America has never been so uncultivated and crude.
Of course, chaos is also an instrument of strength, it awakens fears of unpredictability. But if you take chaos too far, you lose. It's like laughter. The message gets lost if you laugh too long, and if you don't stop, everyone turns away affected. So Trump appears to the world as somewhat confused, not like Biden, but in his own way. And he has been set free and can no longer be contained.
America now seems loud and self-confident again (like Germany did back then), but has no culture of staging this to its advantage on the world stage.
In the past, economic issues such as tariffs were negotiated by appointed economic experts and politicians in the back room; there was no need for the public stage, which is hardly receptive to them. Today, of course, such structures have been replaced by the Internet, which can freely distribute opinions (including mine) without an editor-in-chief or political affiliation, and can therefore generate much more tension and popular opinion. But from the point of view of growth, the old compromise system and its operational mode of action had never really harmed America as a whole.
Increasing national debt is almost everywhere, and of course it's a problem, but America is not alone in having this problem.
But if you use this problem (like the price of eggs) to sweep the stock market clean, destabilize the entire financial industry, set institutions on fire, sweep “lazy people” out of government agencies, and produce powerful effects, then in earlier decades you were considered a demagogue (Hitler), charlatan, or anti-Christ (as I sometimes read here).
Europe is not speechless because it has been on America's back and is now expected to bear the costs of armaments and war preparations itself. We have long since accepted this and we are actively working to implement it. Also we continue buying expensive equipment in the US. But the fact that billionaires don't care what happens to NATO shows how perversely the Republicans are currently dealing with values, infected by their icons.
As a European, I saw and respected America as a friend and in many ways as a role model, until the recent decline in Republican values.
When I was a child, I remember sitting across from my father one evening as the news hummed softly in the background. With the quiet authority he always carried, he said to me:
"America sets the rules of the world. But the way it is—it's not a disadvantage for the world. In fact, it's probably the best possible compromise."
I was young, but not too young to question things. So I looked up at him and asked,
“And what if one day America becomes like Hitler's Germany? Then who will be the ‘Allies’ who save the world?”
He didn’t answer right away. For a moment, he just looked at me, and the silence felt heavier than any words. Then, in a voice quieter than before, he said:
"Let’s hope it never comes to that."
Now we have to wait and see. Anyone who isn't nervous at the moment is dump and stupid.