Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
You will be asked whether you want this or not. Not the same as buying a thermostats to be spied on/ sold ads to.

How much information do you give to your thermostat, let alone waste time looking at it? I spend a lot more time with my iPhone, and I didn't know how to turn off iBeacon (the non-geek common man doesn't and advertisers are counting on it), I'd literally get spammed by something I have on me every waking hour of the day.
 
And now Nest will be an Ad pushing, spyware PoS and only single man-boys living with their mommies with their Android phones and Raspberry Pi porn machines will be interested in it after Apple releases HomeKit, which Nest will probably not support.
 
What an arse!

Nest is quite possibly the worst idea since the start of time. About as useful as a connected fork that monitors how you eat! Google bought the company for something else because the products smoke detectors and thermostats aren't ideas worth buying and I'm sure you can't patent adding wifi to something.

Most people don't even have their radiators calibrated to produce the same temperature in every room based on temp of where the thermostat is located! It's hardly ideal to be monitoring an already out of wack system?

Smoke detectors is kind of dumb too. I mean if you have a fire you are probably at home cooking or asleep in another room forgetting about the cooking. So you would hear the alarm. If you were out and about what exactly would be the need to know your house is on fire? I'm still at a loss to see the advantage? can anyone tell me at all?

This guy is not a visionary and definitely not smart, steve would have shot down his ideas in a heartbeat and called him a hack. Sorry but this company will go on to nothing. They were acquired for something other than their products for sure. If you disagree please tell me what i'm missing?

Anger much? Wow. Where would one even start with you? If you don't understand the basic concept of the connected appliance, and the future applications that they have there's no point in even trying to explain.

It would be like explaining quantum physics to a parakeet.
 
Alternatives to Nest

Yeah.... Honestly, the Nest thermostat isn't really panning out to be nearly as good of a product as most people thought, originally (myself included!).

I give it props for the physical design/styling, certainly. But a major flaw is surfacing because it eliminates the traditional mechanical relay switches inside for switching transistors on a circuit board. These transistors have been failing occasionally, causing problems like someone's air conditioner "short cycling" on and off repeatedly. If it happens when the owner isn't home to catch the problem -- they can easily wind up with a damaged A/C compressor costing well over $1,000 to repair. (Nest will happily send you a replacement circuit board though at no charge.)

In other cases, the transistors in the Nest fail in the "on" mode, causing the furnace or A/C to run continuously.

There's a lot of blame going around right now around it using "poor quality Asian components". But at least one HVAC guy I read explained the real issue lies with the contactors on the A/C, heat-pump or furnaces themselves. Basically, they start to wear over time and draw more power than they did when they were new. Eventually, they start drawing more than what the specifications claim is needed, which is more than what the switching transistors in the Nest were designed to handle. This never used to matter with the old-fashioned thermostats with mechanical relays because those handled the extra power draw just fine.

For what it's worth, I just bought a couple EcoBee thermostats, after a lot of research. EcoBee is apparently a Canadian firm who only markets its digital thermostats to resellers, not end users. But most HVAC people familiar with them think very highly of them, and recommend them over a Nest.

EcoBee has a web portal to do all of your thermostat programming and monitoring, and has an iOS app just like Nest does. The thermostat itself even shows you the current weather conditions outside on its display and is intelligent enough to make adjustments based on those conditions (humidity levels, etc.).


This is why I recently purchased a Honeywell thermostat. Yeah it doesn't do all of what the Nest does, but it's enough. And Google won't know when I'm home or not. :mad:
 
I'll get excited about these smart home gadgets when my refrigerator can keep itself stocked and the oven will whip up a meal for me, Jetsons-style.
 
Anyone else think he wouldn't care that much..? It's not a computer product nor is it particularly aesthetic.. doesn't really fall into his realm of interest.
 
sorry I didn't realise nest displayed adds ? If it does could you please give me a source :) thanks.

Also this story is a non-story , the guy might of obvously had a relationship with Steve , and would have liked steves opinion on the product he create , there is nothing wrong with that at all so I don't know why people are being all bitchy and fanboying on such a throw away comments.

Like wise the reporter obvously asked him what jobs would think and he gave his opinion , again what do you expect him to say ? No comment ? Steve would think its crap no? Of course not he is obvouslt gonna spin it in a positive way

Yes, because Google bought it with no intention of ultimately monetizing it according to its singular business model.

I will be imminently posting an advertisement for sale of the Brooklyn Bridge. Please respond.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.