zap2 said:We had 4 before ( Photo ,iPod, Mini, Shuffle)
perhaps this si just a why to get rid of the shuffle and replace it with a Flash based ipod with a screen
True, but I thought 4 types of iPods back then was overkill too.
I'm also not sure they'd want to kill the Shuffle since it seems to be selling well. I know in my office there were 5 of us with HDD iPods, but most people thought they were too much. Then the shuffles came out and about 15 people bought them. They liked that they were really small and replace their thumb drives they already had.
Personally, I don't like the shuffle, but apparently a lot of people do... at least the 512MB variety as the 1GB was too expensive. Just spend $50 and get 4x the storage with a screen... seems a no-brainer to me since if price was the issue, you'd just get the 512MB model.
I hope they just stick to 3 styles of iPod and update them across the board.