The iPod touch is an iPhone without the phone. Now that the iPod touch has the 'January Software Upgrade' pre-installed on every model bought after the 15th Jan 08. If not, it's $20 for all that functionality!
Personally, I think, if you have a phone already, don't give Apple the satisfaction of buying the iPhone, providing your happy with your current phone and plan that is tied to that phone. The iPhone has quite a huge price-tag (at the moment) with the contract included into the pirce. Long term your looking at spending well over $800+. With iPod touch it's a one-off charge (excluding future chargeable software updates) which ever model you choose to buy -- and you get to use Wifi, and Safari, free! - without being tied to data plans!
If your intensions are to 'jail-break' the device however, then it's a tie between the two.
Each have Pro's and Con's for example;
The iPhone is slightly thicker than the iPod touch (a wafer-thin 8mm), iPhone has EDGE for internet access everywhere whereas iPod touch doesn't etc etc ..
Each out weigh each other as far as features/aesthetics go.
At the end of the day, it all comes down to personal preference.
- What do you what the device to be able to do, for you?
- How much are you willing to spend on this device?
- What do you prefer the device to look and feel like?
- Do aesthetics come before functionality for you, or is it the other way around?
- Do you wish to be tied to data plans, or not?
- Are you, willing to pay a (possible) fee regarding future software updates, for extra functionality? (iPod touch)
- Do you want to use iTunes to manage my phone?
... these are all questions you have to ask and answer, yourself.
Opinion of a very content iPod touch 16Gb (un-jailbroken) owner.
R-Fly