iPod Video Scratches

Backtothemac

macrumors 601
Original poster
Jan 3, 2002
4,206
0
San Destin Florida
Damn it! I have had this thing for 2 hours. Really 2 hours. Took it out of the box, put it in the sleeve. Set it on the desk. Took it out of the sleeve connected it to the iMac.

Transfered one song to test sound quality. Looked down. I have hundreds of scratches on the screen!

LITTERALLY HUNDREDS!

WTF. Are the new iPods this easy to scratch that the protective case that they come with will destroy the iPod!

Anyone else have this problem with the 5g iPod?
 

spaceballl

macrumors 68030
Nov 2, 2003
2,856
240
San Francisco, CA
Hmm I can't say i've been able to recreate your problem. I got the iPod, put it in its case, threw it in my backpack, and stuff... I sync'd up the iPod when it was in the case, took it out of the case, listened to it, did a few other things, and still no scratches.

That being said, I realize this thing is gonna scratch easy... So i'm looking for a case asap!

-Kevin
 

balamw

Moderator
Staff member
Aug 16, 2005
19,075
963
New England
hookahco said:
invest in an iskin.. once you get it youll never believe you used an ipod without it.
My 4G scrtached up pretty bad in the first 2 weeks I had it without an iSkin.
iskin doesn't seem to have any 5G product for preview/preorder yet. :(

Personally I'm leaving the plastic on the front of my 5G until either it falls off or I receive my Martin Fields 2.5" screen protectors. They were out of stock of the 5G ones, and I really only want to protect the display area, I don't mind so much if the rest of the front gets scratched a bit.

B
 

whalesalad

macrumors newbie
Oct 18, 2005
28
0
Radtech told me (radtech.us) that they would be releasing a skin for the ipod video made of their famous optex cloth. I love Radtech, they make excellent stuff!!! Make sure to check the site out each week to find out when they are available!

Well for those who do not know what optex is, its a very fine 1000 thread per square inch cloth which really leaves no scratches at all on your ipod. I used their IceCreme M kit to remove scratches from my ipod and that worked perfectly. It includes the optex clothes and they feel as smooth as a babies bottom.

This is THE case that you are going to want. Plus, they are hair-thin so it doesnt make your ipod look like a boat anchor.
 

pdpfilms

macrumors 68020
Jun 29, 2004
2,385
0
Vermontana
I've not had that issue. Its hard to believe there are already hundreds of scratches on your screen if that's truly all you've done with it.

Nevertheless, I've got an invisible shield and a BurningLove case on the way.
 

AdamZ

macrumors regular
Feb 15, 2004
140
0
Now hold on folks!

As we all know the 5 gb and 10 gb scroll wheel ipods were the first to come out back in 2001. Watch this http://live.watchmactv.com/ Anyway, the original design was truly something to see. The buttons were intuitively positioned, something that was reintroduced in the click wheel model, and the thin clear plastic sheet of aparent glass was tottally like looking at some really cool art piece. I am so happy to say, that Apple has comeback full circle to the original design and now I feel completely ready to replace nearly dead original ipod.
The headphone jack is broken and the firewire port is very loose. I have to be careful when charging or attempting to sync as to not disconnect it. Also battery life is a hit or miss, anywhere from 3 hours, to 5 min depending on whether or not I attempt to skip to the next song or let it shuffle on its own no matter the song. Also, I have to really know what I'm about to to since the Menu button no longer works. And I mentioned syncing? Getting files and music on to the iPod is a hassle since it rarely works. I have Restored and used Disk Warrior on this thing at least 10 times to get it to accept data at different points. And finally, the thing is TOTALY SCRATCHED!!!!!!

But, ya know what? I have been using this device daily for nearly 4 YEARS!!!!!!! Yes it scratches!!! The return of the clear plastic, that jewels the front of the newest iPods, is a return to the original design! I remember forums similar to these that discussed this way back then. Ya know what we didn't care, the clear plastic made the product look beautiful. And again, it does it now. Have you seen one yet? Compare that subtle touch on the sides to a 3rd or 4th gen iPod and you'll clearly see that they were wrong with those models. They brought back the button layout in the fourth and now the entire original design here in the 5th. Its the differences in materials that are driving people crazy. They are not familiar with that feeling. Watch this above video and look at Seal's reaction "everyones gonna want one of these" Its the new plastic on the front. It begs the iPod to be thought of as a true jewel again. The new ones do scratch. The Nanos scratch. But not in a way disimilar to the originals, and not what you would consider as not worthy of buying one. These aBut thats what people are complaining about

We decided back then to fall into one of two camps. Those who decided to put theirs in cases and keep them pristine. Or others like me who enjoyed the open beauty of the product and wanted it to shine through. WE KNEW IT WAS GOING TO GET SCRATCHED TO HELL. It was $400 for only 5gb. Hundreds if not thousands of these little scratches live and breath on my iPod. And we accepted it. We chose it. For those who are complaining about scratches, or reading about those that are complaining and getting scared, don't worry about it folks really. Just decide what camp you want to live in.
 

noelister

macrumors 6502
Jan 15, 2005
275
0
Oddly enough, I have not had that problem. I Got mine in last Wednesday. Since then I have listened and watched it. Just typical use. I have one little scratch on the back of the iPod but that was my fault. With that said, I put an invisibleShield on the thing tonight just to be safe.

Furthermore, I don't look at the iPod as a toy. It was 300 buck plus tax. This may not be alot to some but to me it is. So i treat all my goodies I save up for with care.
 

Vanilla

macrumors 6502a
Mar 19, 2002
589
0
Atlanta, GA
Yes EVERYONE is aware that iPod's of all generations scratch, fairly easily.

I do not believe the majority of people complaining expect pristine quality at all times, which would be unreasonable.

However, and it's a big however, the new models DO appear to scratch far more readily and far more extensively than any other previous model.

This could well be simply a bad, initial batch of the new models as Apple claims and as apparently verified by the [inevitable] spate of counter postings from people insisting their new models are fine.

Given the above, there does seem to be an issue here that is worthy of discussion and hopefully resolution.

Vanilla
 

cheekyspanky

macrumors 6502a
Jan 21, 2004
633
1
South Bucks, UK
I just pulled my 5G out of its little protective case for the first time since charging it up and synching it - and yup, mine is scratched to s**t as well.

This 5G seems a lot lower quality than my 3G was.

:mad:
 

nomad01

macrumors 68000
Aug 1, 2005
1,650
7
Birmingham, England
balamw said:
Personally I'm leaving the plastic on the front of my 5G until either it falls off or I receive my Martin Fields 2.5" screen protectors.
Excellent idea! The Martin Field protectors are fantastic. Crystal clear and really tough. The ones for the nano and the 5G pretty much cover the whole front area. They're not overly expensive so I'd rather get my iPod covered and not have to treat it like an egg.

Every iPod I've had since the 2G one has been covered in protection of some variety because they're easy to scratch. The newer ones just look more obvious.
 

ipacmm

macrumors 65816
Jun 17, 2003
1,304
0
Cincinnati, OH
cheekyspanky said:
I just pulled my 5G out of its little protective case for the first time since charging it up and synching it - and yup, mine is scratched to s**t as well.

:mad:
Same with my ipod...the second I got it, it was all scratched up.
 

iDM

macrumors 6502a
hookahco said:
invest in an iskin.. once you get it youll never believe you used an ipod without it.
I realize people love their iskins, but my experience with them is that they greatly increased the size of the ipod, when pulling it in and out of my jeans pocket, the pocket came with it, i then had to stuff it back in. The included screen cover was a JOKE and it turned yellow after a couple months, and the pocket clip was not taut when using it so i had to resort to tucking my 3rd gen ipod into my waist band while working out. I got my new ipod about 45 minutes ago from fedex, and as hard as it was i did not take it out of it's plastic wrap and i refuse to until i get a proper case. Having to do this is quite ridiculous, my roommates although didn't get hundreds of scratches it did get a few and all he did was the same just syncing it.
 

Ferrence

macrumors member
Sep 3, 2005
47
0
Think before listening...

Don't take the plastic off of your iPod until you get Invisible Shield or a case. Geez.
 

RBilRamZ

macrumors member
Sep 17, 2003
61
0
Get an Invisible Shield!

Ok, so I think we have realized the new iPods scratch easily. A few people have said to get an iSkin, but I agree with earlier posts that they are not the best case. I hate the idea of taking my beautiful iPod and hiding it in a big ugly case.
I just saw my buddies nano that he put an invisible shield on. Guess what, it looks perfect. The thing is less than 1 millimeter thick, and since he put it on right when he got his nano, he has no scratches at all.
I just ordered one for my 30g video, which should arrive tomorrow. I guess I'll have to hold out on opening my iPod until my sheild gets here on Friday. If anybody is curious, I'll take pictures before and after the installation.
 

todge

macrumors newbie
Oct 1, 2005
16
0
Vanilla said:
This could well be simply a bad, initial batch of the new models as Apple claims and as apparently verified by the [inevitable] spate of counter postings from people insisting their new models are fine.
Have you got a link for this press release? Are you sure you're not confused with the few nanos that shipped with screen which had dead pixels etc. I've never heard them say anything about them scratching more easily. Although I am often wrong.
 

zakthemack

macrumors member
Sep 15, 2004
35
0
RBilRamZ said:
I just ordered one for my 30g video, which should arrive tomorrow. I guess I'll have to hold out on opening my iPod until my sheild gets here on Friday. If anybody is curious, I'll take pictures before and after the installation.
I just went to the website and didn't see any available for 5g, do you have a link? Thanks.
 

GroundLoop

macrumors 68000
Mar 21, 2003
1,561
35
The 6G iPod should go back to the same form/materials of the iPod mini. It was rugged and not easy to scratch (not to mention beautiful).

Hickman
 

MacTruck

macrumors 65816
Jan 27, 2005
1,242
0
One Endless Loop
ITS A MOBILE DEVICE not fine china. Thing should be indistructable. ipod mini still zero scratches anywhere and I let me 3 yr old son use it.