SiliconAddict said:
I agree. Never let it be said that I think they are going to die.
Hehe. Dude no offense but you've been sipping too much of the Apple juice.
Quality? You are kidding right?!? OK. Lets look at Apple quality. Note these are just off the top of my head:
Hardware:
-fan issues with first gen G5 PowerMac's
-Rusting on first gen TI Powerbooks in the palm rail.
-Paint flecking on the AL (Or was that the TI? Which one was painted?) PowerBooks?
-White spots on 15" PowerBook screens.
-Bad latches on various AL/TI PowerBooks.
-Bad system boards on a TON of iBooks (I know for a fact I have a VERY irate friend who has had his system board replaced 4 times now since September of last year. Dude is seriously pissed at Apple.)
-Crashing iPod's left and right. (I know 9 people that have ipods. (Of which 5 are 3rd gen, and 3 are 2nd, 1 is 1st.) Of those 4 have had their iPods in for repairs. 1 was unlucky enough to have theirs in 3 or 4 times in the last 2 years. Sorry for the slathering of facts.)
-Battery recall on the 15" PowerBook no more then 2 weeks ago
Software:
-10.2.8 Enough said
-10.3 How many people lost their data because of the filevault issue?
-10.3 Firewire drives. Enough said.
-[insert various update that was available on Mac Update then was mysteriously pulled for no reason because it did "bad things"]
Phone based customer service:
-A complete and total joke. Browse the forums and see how many people are NOT happy with Apple customer support. I know that the above friend who had the system board fry on his iBook got serious cases of the run around on multiple instances. From what he told me it degraded into chaos after a while. (Not the calmest person on the planet.) He ended up taking his iBook to the MoA Apple Store where his experience was drastically better.
Look. I want to like Apple. When I started looking at the Mac Spring of 03 as a viable alternative to the PC I went in thinking well gosh this is going to be a flawless experience. Maybe I had a taste of the Apple juice at some point thinking that because after spending a year on the boards reading, watching, browsing I'm not seeing that rosy paradise. I'm seeing a company just as flawed as MS in some ways and kicks the crap out of them in others and to dismiss that is to bury your head in the sand. I don't do that with MS products and I'll be danged if I'm going to with Apple, or anyone else for that matter.
Ah, a coherent response. Nice to see.
Firstly, sorry im not a mac zealot. I use a PC a PC laptop and a mac laptop. And i dont buy the marketing crap apple sells. My offerings are based purely on experience.
Well you have a point about apples quality control, those mostly are flaws that should have been ironed out WELL before the release.
But you have to compare this with the utter horror stories from DELL, Time, Tiny etc.
Yeah, macs have flaws, design problems. But your looking at glitches that apply to a small percentage of their users. Your not looking at how each and every machine is put together.
If i look at glitches from the PC world i should see roughly the same number:
XP SP1 failing to fix bugs.
XP SP2 failing to increase security, and bug fixes.
Should i bother mentioning windows ME? that was hell.
DELL power supplies
Time PCs socketA motherboards going pop after 13 months use. (conveniently just out of warranty....hmmmmm)
VIA northbridge chipsets not accepting certain radeon, and earlier matrox cards.
Archos 20gb jukebox HDs die.
Samsung Yepps have battery covers that crack and fall off, and circuitry that wants to short out. Oh, and volume control buttons that enjoy doing what they want.
Toshiba 2250XCDS LCD screen problems
....to name but a few. You wont hear about alot of these problems because they just dont get reported, it wud be much easier to report a problem from apple which is a centralised company with a reputation for quality.
But these glitches affect roughly the same proportion of their respective line of computer. Not much difference between mac and PC here.
You have to avoid looking at inevitable glitches, but look at the problems that affect every machine in the line.
Take this as an example, if you open up a Dell box, take off the heatsink and look underneath you wont see thermal paste. Youll see what resembles chewing gum. Now ordinarily this is a minor problem, but as the PC cpu is running at 45 degrees in most cases, it is ever so slightly more than a worry.
Now this isnt a problem affecting some, it will affect every PC in that line DELL makes until the motherboard finally shorts.
You wouldnt find that magnitude of problem affecting every mac in a line of macs. Infact i cant think of one. Apart from the noise of the first dual 2.0Ghz G5. And after hearing it at my local KRCS store i can honestly say my athlon box is louder when its asleep.
So, sorry i have to disagree.
The fact is, for years the publishing industry has used macs despite Quark and indesign being available on faster PCs. Why? because they know that after intensive work their macs wont crash, wont have design flaws that they have to replace an entire office, and wont have the driver problems windows PCs are plagued with.
Same could be said for most in graphics design, and a large percentage of 3D design.
In my experience anyway; macs offer quality, PCs offer better price/performance. Thats why i use both.
nice to see another opinion though
