I'm basically a full time student, and all I need a laptop for is: Videos, Notes, Internet. I've used the Mac OS before and i really enjoy it over windows, but what else am I getting out of it besides the Luxury of having this gorgeous notebook? ** lets say money's not an issue.**
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Is it stupid for me to buy a Macbook Pro?
- Thread starter hazedragon45
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
You'll get something that isn't gonna die on you and get viruses. 
You'll love it. You know you want one. Buy it.
You'll love it. You know you want one. Buy it.
I work in IT and I bought my parents and sister both macs because I was sick of removing viruses, re-imaging the machines, etc.
If you enjoy the Mac OS why make yourself miserable and get a PC? I myself could never go back (even though a PC is my work machine and I make a living fixing windows machines and servers)
If you enjoy the Mac OS why make yourself miserable and get a PC? I myself could never go back (even though a PC is my work machine and I make a living fixing windows machines and servers
)
You're the perfect Apple customer: You want to buy a Porsche 911 Turbo just to do your weekly grocery shopping.
There are certainly advantages to having a Windows machine, but I buy Macs primarily for their longevity these days. I'm pretty comfortable knowing that my current machine will last me 5+ years with minimal need for replacement.
No virus
No virus scan sucking 10% of your cpu and battery life
No long start up / long shut down
Easy backup with timemachine
No virus scan sucking 10% of your cpu and battery life
No long start up / long shut down
Easy backup with timemachine
i think you probably have the same computer requirements as 80% of apple users
the really killer feature is the trackpad imo. it's amazing in internet browsing and i really ache when i use other trackpads. is the trackpad/OSX worth like $500 though? well i shelled out for it.. which makes me feel kind of guilty
if money is no object, then go for it
the really killer feature is the trackpad imo. it's amazing in internet browsing and i really ache when i use other trackpads. is the trackpad/OSX worth like $500 though? well i shelled out for it.. which makes me feel kind of guilty
if money is no object, then go for it
If money is no object, why is the MacBook Pro the wrong idea? For students Mac's are ideal: solid OS, solid construction, great battery life and reliability.
screw the 911 turbo give me the GT3
When you say videos do you mean youtube or editing? imovie or final cut?
Have you considered a macbook?
Wirelessly posted (Nokia 5800 Tube XpressMusic : Mozilla/5.0 (SymbianOS/9.4; U; Series60/5.0 Nokia5800d-1/21.0.101; Profile/MIDP-2.1 Configuration/CLDC-1.1 ) AppleWebKit/413 (KHTML, like Gecko) Safari/413)
The ifference being that Porsches are fast.
It's not a stupid idea to buy a Mac. Personally, I don't think viruses are the biggest benefit of OS X, since OS X isn't completely malware resistant, and it has been shown to be quite easy to hack. Also, Win7 is supposed to be quite different, and most people's experiences are with XP, perhaps Vista.
The benefit of OS X is the extra productivity I get with the OS interface, and features such as Expose and Dashboard. Time Machine is useful, and Apple always seems to be on the ball when it comes to adding cool and useful features so the difference between OSes always seems to be there.
Winni said:
The ifference being that Porsches are fast.
It's not a stupid idea to buy a Mac. Personally, I don't think viruses are the biggest benefit of OS X, since OS X isn't completely malware resistant, and it has been shown to be quite easy to hack. Also, Win7 is supposed to be quite different, and most people's experiences are with XP, perhaps Vista.
The benefit of OS X is the extra productivity I get with the OS interface, and features such as Expose and Dashboard. Time Machine is useful, and Apple always seems to be on the ball when it comes to adding cool and useful features so the difference between OSes always seems to be there.
the answer is really just quality... clean workspace, no viruses, easy to use... in my eyes, a good feng shuai
Macs are great for students, i would recommend them
I am a student and I have been enoying my mac for 4 months and I still love it
Mac OS X Snow Leopard is really a great OS , thats why you should buy the computer. Much much nicer than windows in my oppinion.
I'm not entirely clear on your question. Are you debating whether to buy mac vs. pc or decided on buying a mac and asking if the MBP is overkill for your needs?
If you're debating mac vs. pc then everyone above has pretty much nailed it, especially if cost is not a deciding factor.
If you're debating MBP vs. Macbook for your needs well it pretty much depends on your choice of screen size and portability. I say that because if money is no option and you don't have power user needs then the size and weight pretty much become the deciding factor.
To answer the question directly from a Mac forum perspective, it's never stupid to purchase a Mac product.
If you're debating mac vs. pc then everyone above has pretty much nailed it, especially if cost is not a deciding factor.
If you're debating MBP vs. Macbook for your needs well it pretty much depends on your choice of screen size and portability. I say that because if money is no option and you don't have power user needs then the size and weight pretty much become the deciding factor.
To answer the question directly from a Mac forum perspective, it's never stupid to purchase a Mac product.
OP you match the profile of roughly 90 percent of student Macbook "Pro" owners who
A) Check myspace/facebook
B) Watch Videos
C) write papers
in that order.
Don't know firewire(my wire catches on fire?) from USB except one is a square that doesn't fit the ipod sync cable. Couldn't care less about what panel type it uses, Will never connect it to an external monitor, and will run programs that utilize a fraction of the available processing and graphical horsepower. I.E. the perfect netbook or macbook owner.
A) Check myspace/facebook
B) Watch Videos
C) write papers
in that order.
Don't know firewire(my wire catches on fire?) from USB except one is a square that doesn't fit the ipod sync cable. Couldn't care less about what panel type it uses, Will never connect it to an external monitor, and will run programs that utilize a fraction of the available processing and graphical horsepower. I.E. the perfect netbook or macbook owner.
Then what's stopping you from buying a 17" high-end MacBook Pro? lol I quasi-kid. Actually, depending on your needs, a 17" MIGHT be a beast to carry around if you're getting it for portability. A 15" high-end MacBook Pro would be pretty sweet and the best of all worlds.
That PP about driving the Porche to the supermarket just about sums you up as the perfect Mac customer. Not by any means saying it's a bad thing. Far from it. I guess if you got it, flaunt it. But you're probably doing it for a 50/50 split of the ease of the Mac OS and the prestige factor that sucks in a lot of Mac customers. Let's call a spade a spade here.
Actually, depending on your needs, a 17" MIGHT be a beast to carry around if you're getting it for portability. A 15" high-end MacBook Pro would be pretty sweet and the best of all worlds. That PP about driving the Porche to the supermarket just about sums you up as the perfect Mac customer. Not by any means saying it's a bad thing. Far from it. I guess if you got it, flaunt it.
But you're probably doing it for a 50/50 split of the ease of the Mac OS and the prestige factor that sucks in a lot of Mac customers. Let's call a spade a spade here.Let me tell you a story, OP. Fourth year uni student here.
In my first year I figured I wouldn't be using my laptop for a huge amount, so decided to just go with a comparatively cheap Acer laptop. It lasted about a year and a half before it started having huge issues, so I needed to replace it. So, second year, and I have a new laptop already. Just over a year later, that one starts having issues too, so I have to buy a third, and now that's having issues too.
So, that's 3 laptops in basically as many years, costing about £1700 in total. With that kind of money I could've bought a MBP and 3 year applecare, and still had about £800 left over. If you can afford it, I really don't recommend cheaping out. You could always consider the regular MacBook though - it's cheaper and still more than capable enough for your needs.
In my first year I figured I wouldn't be using my laptop for a huge amount, so decided to just go with a comparatively cheap Acer laptop. It lasted about a year and a half before it started having huge issues, so I needed to replace it. So, second year, and I have a new laptop already. Just over a year later, that one starts having issues too, so I have to buy a third, and now that's having issues too.
So, that's 3 laptops in basically as many years, costing about £1700 in total. With that kind of money I could've bought a MBP and 3 year applecare, and still had about £800 left over. If you can afford it, I really don't recommend cheaping out. You could always consider the regular MacBook though - it's cheaper and still more than capable enough for your needs.
the answer is really just quality... clean workspace, no viruses, easy to use... in my eyes, a good feng shuai
If everyone buys a mac, then programmers will have more reason to create virus, thus there will be viruses on macs. Even more so if macs become more common in the business world. So don't buy a mac because "it cannot get viruses" as that is very untrue. There are plenty of REAL reasons to buy a mac as noted in this thread and there are plenty of reasons NOT to buy one.
Mac's hold their value, so once you pay the premium, upgrading to the next version is easy.
As much as I liked the quality aspect when it worked, my Macbook died after about 20 months, so I'm not completely sure I got the best value for money.
To be fair though, the shop assured me that I had just been very unlucky, but I am now having to switch back for the simple reason of: I can't afford a new one.
To be fair though, the shop assured me that I had just been very unlucky, but I am now having to switch back for the simple reason of: I can't afford a new one.
You're in the UK? Exercise your consumer rights. 20 months for a laptop isn't good enough.
If you get a mac, you won't need to upgrade again in your whole university life. It will definitely meet your requirements for at least a 3 year course, and up to 5 if you can accept not having the latest and greatest.
Im a 2nd year University student and had my macbook since after GCSEs. All I've had to do since then to keep it relatively modern is upgrade ram from 512mb to 2gb when it reached one year old, then got a bigger hard drive the next year.
If you got a windows laptop you'd no doubt want to replace it during your course, not necessarily because of the specs, but because windows laptops generally aren't as robust as macbooks, generally not strong enough to be taken to and from campus every day for 3-5 years. That obviously doesn't include premium laptop brands, but if you're going upmarket, why not get a mac anyway?
Finally, HE student discount is 14% I think, so it's basically removing the 'apple tax' that regular consumers have to pay. And you get discounted apple care!
Im a 2nd year University student and had my macbook since after GCSEs. All I've had to do since then to keep it relatively modern is upgrade ram from 512mb to 2gb when it reached one year old, then got a bigger hard drive the next year.
If you got a windows laptop you'd no doubt want to replace it during your course, not necessarily because of the specs, but because windows laptops generally aren't as robust as macbooks, generally not strong enough to be taken to and from campus every day for 3-5 years. That obviously doesn't include premium laptop brands, but if you're going upmarket, why not get a mac anyway?
Finally, HE student discount is 14% I think, so it's basically removing the 'apple tax' that regular consumers have to pay. And you get discounted apple care!