The first watch we bought was my wife's Series 7; it's aluminum and has had a good sized gouge in the screen for a long time. The next year, we bought my Series 8 in stainless steel and the display barely has a single blemish; maybe only a few tiny scratches on the far corners but not in the middle or as noticeable as my wife's. Her's is long overdue for a battery replacement and the health on mine is at 81%; my plan is to replace the batteries in both (paid for by Apple Care+, which I would subsequently then finally cancel) and then keep them for another 3 or so years.
Appearance-wise, I like my stainless steel and would go with titanium if I were to upgrade. It looks much sharper, and can be dressed up or down by changing bands depending on what I'm wearing it to. I can use a link bracelet or Milanese loop for formal occasions, leather link for a somewhat more casual but refined look (last I saw Amazon was still carrying them; I bought up a few extras after Apple discontinued them), and a sport band for yard work, exercising, swimming, etc.