I traded my first I4 for a new one due to the fact that it was crashing all the time, even after several software restorations and new device set up. However, the battery life on that unit was amazing, when it didn't crash. I could use it for nearly two days of moderate to heavy use before recharging.
The replacement unit I received did the same until I updated to 4.0.1... Now I am getting similar results. I don't think it's altogether bad. I just think I had better, and I don't know why it's worse now... To me, it barely does better than the 3gs. I haven't restored the software on this one since the update, and when I did that I restored from back up. I guess I will restore and set up as a new device. Maybe that will help. If I experience similar battery drain, I think I will make an apple appointment and see what they say.
I did the same thing. I traded my first IP4 for a new one because I had one of those NOW stupid ghost shield's on it that apparently when put on, after they sprayed it down, eventually ruined a battery sensor. Not the point. Point is, with my new phone, I too, don't feel like the battery life is as good as my first. Standby is great. I can take it to work and leave it on standby for 8 straight hours, not checking it once, and I'll maybe have a voicemail, and a few txts and new emails, all unread/unheard, and my battery will be 100% after 8, almost 9 hours. But as soon as I start getting into all of that, I can watch my percentage drop at an alarming rate, at least to me. I will watch it drop a percent or two while responding to a txt. All of that being said, however, I've gone to bed without charging it overnight, and after a 14 hour day between work and home, it will usually sit between 87-90% approximately, and overnight, again, with a few new unread emails and txts, it will drop maybe 2% tops. Last night was one of those instances. I went to bed with it at say, 89%, and I woke up with 2 txts and it was at 87%. So from last night leaving around 630 at 100% to this morning around 9, with moderate txting last night, I dropped 13%. Idk. I think what someone else said is absolutely correct. I think the OCD is getting the better of us, me for sure. With all of these reports of battery issues and whatnot, and I'm still debating on if I take my IP4 into Apple again and see what they have to say, if anything. But after reading through different threads and posts, I think this is just normal use. For the most part. Some are defective, yes, but overall, I think turning off the % is the best thing to do, that way we will hopefully stop watching it obsessively. I know that I'm going to do that. I never gave much thought to my battery life before you could have the % notification. Now I can't even enjoy my phone like I should because I'm watching my battery more than what's on my actual screen. So IDK.