Hello guys,
Looking into purchasing one, read screen might be crap along other stuff... is it maybe better to wait?
Thanks!
Looking into purchasing one, read screen might be crap along other stuff... is it maybe better to wait?
Thanks!
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Is the 16” MBP a Worthy Buy?
- Thread starter James Cole
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
it is the best macbook pro Apple made in years. If you are absolutely need a new laptop right now, you should get the 16 inch.
Have you checked one out an Apple store, Best Buy etcetera? The screen on my MBP 16 is no worse (nor better) than my 2018 MBP 15.
If you are that influenced by internet postings don't buy it. If you take the time to actually go try one then make up your own mind. If everyone followed the stories on forums nothing from any company would sell except edibles. Use the return period to aggressively use it to be sure.
Like with anything, some buyers are having issues with fan noise, battery, overheating, screen ghosting, wifi etc. No idea what percentage they form. But they have every right to be peeved if they're paying say £2500-£4000 on a device.
Mine is now 3 weeks old and overall it's a brilliant bit of kit. Battery could be better, as could temps and fan noise - still figuring out causes and workflow for those. But £3250 is a shed load of cash for what it is. So is it VFM? IMO no. I use it to run my business so I need a solid performer that gets stuff done and doesn't waste my time. So if it delivers as it has been for the next 3-4 years then I'll be very happy and see it as money well spent. If it doesn't, then I'll be properly pi55ed off.
FTR I've initiated a return but not yet decided.
Mine is now 3 weeks old and overall it's a brilliant bit of kit. Battery could be better, as could temps and fan noise - still figuring out causes and workflow for those. But £3250 is a shed load of cash for what it is. So is it VFM? IMO no. I use it to run my business so I need a solid performer that gets stuff done and doesn't waste my time. So if it delivers as it has been for the next 3-4 years then I'll be very happy and see it as money well spent. If it doesn't, then I'll be properly pi55ed off.
FTR I've initiated a return but not yet decided.
I’m pretty happy with mine. No plans to return and the window is closing quickly. If you need a computer go for it.
I can't wait to buy mine. I think that is probably the best MacBook Pro that Apple has released within the last 4+ years.
My 14 days were up today. I really expected to not keep it after dropping $4000, and the fan noise reallyhit me at first, then i figured out simple mods to my workflow and the performance compared to both my 2018 13” and my new Surface Laptop is just so huge that I am very happy with it.
i do still need to add some new accessories like an updated dock as my Elgato can only provide 60w and I have lots of Usb-c chargers that fall short, but more and more 100w options are appearing daily.
I‘m also finding that while I thought clamshell mode would be a PITA, but necessary to minimize noise and heat, I actually love having a big chunk of my desktop recovered by kicking the laptop to the side and using a tiny Mac keyboard and mouse. My 34” and 27” monitors are on arms so my desk is completely clear now.
i do still need to add some new accessories like an updated dock as my Elgato can only provide 60w and I have lots of Usb-c chargers that fall short, but more and more 100w options are appearing daily.
I‘m also finding that while I thought clamshell mode would be a PITA, but necessary to minimize noise and heat, I actually love having a big chunk of my desktop recovered by kicking the laptop to the side and using a tiny Mac keyboard and mouse. My 34” and 27” monitors are on arms so my desk is completely clear now.
I would recommend that you head out to your apple store and check it out first hand. If you're concerned about a crappy screen and other stuff, then the first place to start imo is seeing up front
I can only add my take. It's my first new Mac since 2011 and I couldn't be happier. I think the screen looks fine, am I blown away by it? No. Does it look better than my classmates computers, both Macs and PC's? Yes. No issue with coil whine nor the fans. Just a perfect computer. I use it mainly for studying (typing, a lot and games on the downtime).
It looks like a great buy. It is not expensive compared to what you get, and it is an amazing computer. It is big and heavy, but if you are OK with it, and if you are into macOS, then I can see no better buy.
I think it's a great machine. 2.3/16/1TB/55004GB.
Keyboard is infinitely better, and physical esc key is a step in the right direction.
Keyboard is infinitely better, and physical esc key is a step in the right direction.
Yeah, as long as no widespread hardware issues surface, all the new models are a better buy than the previous generation, but I agree that the base model is a particularly good value.
Even though the size increase is marginal I definitely feel the difference from the 2018 model I owned. I wouldn't recommend it to someone who's already on the fence about the 15" models being too big. But it looks like the OP currently owns a 17" MacBook Pro, so this shouldn't be a problem.
If your workflow can take advantage of 8 cores, the slightly faster dGPU, or you need 1 TB storage, it's fine. I just think that most workflows that really DO need that power would likely be better served by 32 GB RAM as well.
No I was nearly buying that one too for future proofing the Mac. I also have the 2015 15’’ base model and its still pretty fast today.
The screen is fantastic. If you listen to these forums you’ll never buy an Apple product. I’ve owned a lot of Macs and the 16 inch if my favorite notebook hands down.
I bought the base - my main issue is that Catalina can be a little laggy (nothing big but sometimes it can feel a bit sluggish) and the speaker popping. I've noticed popping in Musescore on external audio as well but I'm not sure if that's the same issue. It's way too OP for me with my workload in terms of CPU.
This forum is not the norm. I have tons of Apple products, iMac’s Macbooks Homepods Apple Watch iPhones Apple TV’s etc...never had an issue with one that they list on here all the time. It’s mostly user error unless it’s some fudged up OS release that usually gets fixed.