-snip-
My plan right now is to file a homeowners claim, which sucks because, as this was a house warming party, I just moved in about 7 weeks ago and to already have a claim is kind of disappointing, but hopefully since it's such a small amount it won't do too much damage to my rates.
I will replace the MBP and just get refunded when my claim check comes back. I'll sell my 20" C2D iMac and just use this MBP as my new desktop.
Here's a question tho, as you all seem quite knowledgeable. Could I go and buy a 15" glossy display, take the functional logic board and the LVDS cable and swap them with the damaged logic board (assuming) and LVDS cable in the matte MBP that I have. THis would make the matte hi res MBP functional, and the useless desktop replacement would be the one with the glossy display. Think that would work? Would just be less out of pocket expense, and still have the same result.
Good idea on the homeowner's claim. My renter's insurance covers up to $5,000 of electronics while I'm travelling and that is a nice piece of mind. Check with the company before buying new though - just to be sure.
As for you idea of replacing the LCD with a new LCD, regardless of quality, seems like a big pain in the ass. Have you tried seeing if Applecare will repair the machine? Just don't mention the beer