Lipstick on a pig. iTunes needs to be completely trashed. Rebuild it into separate apps, do whatever needs to be done to allow people to use services like iCloud, Match, Apple Music, etc. without completely screwing up their music libraries and playlists. Adding a persistent sidebar isn't going to cut it; the problems run to the bone in iTunes.
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
iTunes 12.4 Update to Feature Minor Redesign With New Sidebar, Improved Navigation
- Thread starter MacRumors
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
I completely agree with this. Sometimes it is hard to tell what is what. Especially buttons like the random play button. Is it pressed or not? I can't tell.
The list of things wrong with iTunes is very very long. I hardly know where to start.
1) It is far to complicated. My wife can't even use it.
2) The view options are split into multiple areas that are semi hidden. You really have to hunt around to get iTunes to look the way you want.
3) Creating playlists is stupid complicated.
4) Adding content to iTunes can be unpredictable. Will the video appear in movies? Home movies? or my favorite, in Music?
5) Syncing content to an iPod or iPhone is also stupid complicated and completely unreliable.
I could go on and on. It's just weird.
I hope apple is doing usability testing and what not like most companies should already be doing.
You nailed it. It's crazy complicated to get iTunes to look the way you want. Splitting functions up so they appear in multiple places is not a good way to go.
ok for the redesign
"sidebar" could be miss-interpreted.. "added" sounds more like a new feature.... Rather i would have said "bought back" because that's what Apple are doing throughout. Up Next redesign, i guess Apple got a lot of complains because no one moved the mouse pointer "into" thr play view window to reveal Up Next icon...
"Why the hell would anyone do that. Its a play view... mouse pointer shouldn't be there. it's only there for "viewing" only purposes, not to fiddle with
No one bothers to click and see what things do ? That's how 90% of my work gets done
Nah, they moved it because it really doesn't belong in the play view. And removing the iTunes login at the side and demoting it to just the other menubar button is a business move.
So is the bringing back of the sidebar, because they want to talk you into listening into curated Apple Music playlists, and they're probably going to do something like "Smart" Apple Music playlists and automate all that stuff which will be announced at WWDC.
The demands of an OS is certainly different from early Macintosh days. More complex tasks and feature sets, but Apple needs to break it down and simplify.
The UI needs to strike a balance between delightful discoverability and visual cues. That's what made us love Macintosh in the first place...the ease of use.
The UI needs to strike a balance between delightful discoverability and visual cues. That's what made us love Macintosh in the first place...the ease of use.
True enough. But there's no good to be had from complaining about it. Apple isn't going back, this is most definitely not what I am sure many long-time Apple users expected by a revolution. Apple has become the man on the screen.
its time to kill iTunes software, there must be a new solution to deal with Syncing - media- and the digital stores
It's so - so sad to watch this company slowly lose their innovation. They'll remain huge, but their biggest accomplishments and mind boggling innovation days are over.
Right, a Store Front of anz kind should not interfere with a local Library of content.
Also, syncing a local Library should work regardless of any Store.
I'd like a Store App to buy Movies, Music, etc.
I'd like a Music App, a Movie Player Podcast App.
Look at iBooks, it is already a stand alone App.
All with Bluetooth based Remote Control via the Apple Remote.
There's no reason the Remote could not be shared.
Just select the device you want to control.
Why I would like Apple to do these?
In my experience, third party Apps are either really bad or have a strange opinion about integrating into the system.
I even think that Apple Music and Beats Radio should be separate from a managed Music Collection.
I'm all for the persistant sidebar but to me thats just a start. iTunes seems to get more complicated with each version Apple puts out. I'm the only one in the house that can use it and even that is questionable.
Things I'd like..drag and drop my songs directly to my device, backup that retains song names vs those long number versions that no one can recognize, and Add to my device button since syncing usually ends up deleting music on my device ...Apple needs to quit changing, moving, and hiding functions. iTunes makes no sense to me.
And before anyone says you're using it wrong, I already know this. iTunes is overly complicated now and I hate it. Whenever I managed to figure something out Apple was always quick to change it then I'm lost all over again.
Things I'd like..drag and drop my songs directly to my device, backup that retains song names vs those long number versions that no one can recognize, and Add to my device button since syncing usually ends up deleting music on my device ...Apple needs to quit changing, moving, and hiding functions. iTunes makes no sense to me.
And before anyone says you're using it wrong, I already know this. iTunes is overly complicated now and I hate it. Whenever I managed to figure something out Apple was always quick to change it then I'm lost all over again.
So they took the last remaining easy part of iTunes (media type switcher - aka icons) and made it less obvious? Well done!
Still hoping for 7-10 separate apps in OS X 10.12
Still hoping for 7-10 separate apps in OS X 10.12
You are so right. I run an old version of iTunes on a Snow Leopard box and it has the interface you show. So much easier to use than what we have now. I would use the old version as my primary iTunes library but Apple tied the ability to sync to new iPhones to the new version of iTunes.
Too little too late, iTunes is a UI disaster. They put UI all over the place, navigation, views etc is a game of hide and seek. It's plain ridiculous. Making sidebar persistent and adding back buttons is a good step but still too little.
Horrible iTunes
Horrible Apple Music
Horrible Podcasts app
Not sure who is in charge of music, but someone needs to be fired immediately.
Horrible iTunes
Horrible Apple Music
Horrible Podcasts app
Not sure who is in charge of music, but someone needs to be fired immediately.
That's what I thought also. Why are they making it MORE DIFFICULT to switch between media types? What is the point of that?
iTunes started with tunes and morphed into a device that would connect your iPod to the real world.
That was great then but we have moved on and it has only ever had reconstructive surgery in a bid to keep up.
Apps, movies, stores, radios and social networking have all been introduced and most options are largely redundant for most users.
iTunes in my home is a player again and a server for the Apple TV.
My iPhone works independently of iTunes in all respects.
They have two options as far as I can tell
Change the name to iMess
Or
Split the thing into pieces and make it mirror the iOS apps. Music , Video, Apps, Podcasts and iTunesU. Then write an iSync for those who still need to sync content to their devices. This would get it content from all those apps including Photos and Books.
That was great then but we have moved on and it has only ever had reconstructive surgery in a bid to keep up.
Apps, movies, stores, radios and social networking have all been introduced and most options are largely redundant for most users.
iTunes in my home is a player again and a server for the Apple TV.
My iPhone works independently of iTunes in all respects.
They have two options as far as I can tell
Change the name to iMess
Or
Split the thing into pieces and make it mirror the iOS apps. Music , Video, Apps, Podcasts and iTunesU. Then write an iSync for those who still need to sync content to their devices. This would get it content from all those apps including Photos and Books.