Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
And say you and I are close friends:
  • Could you sell me even one of your iTunes-purchased movies?
  • Could you loan it to me?
Actually, I can do better with iTunes or Vudu: I can include you in my family sharing, which would give you full access to my entire library.
I'm yet to see a BD disc roll out with lower quality sound than Dolby Digital.
Audio and video quality is not just determined by the codec.
If you want to spin conspiracy, iTunes rolled out with lots of stuff in SD first, then a limited version of 720p, then 1080p and is still awaiting anything in 4K. Pot meet kettle.
There was no charge for the upgrade from 720p to 1080p. And you aren't able to upgrade your DVDs (SD) to Blu-ray (HD) or UHD-BD (4k) for free either.

On the other hand, iTunes actually has upgraded some of my movies for free, e.g. by adding extras or 7.1 DD+ sound, or making an improved encode.
 
Last edited:
Well, gee, I wonder why. I prefer to buy my digital movies they I've always buy movies = buy the movie, then play it on any device.

Apple doesn't do that because they lock you into their ecosystem. I buy from Google Play/Vudu because those apps are available on everything that's not Apple. Hence why I refuse to buy an Apple TV.
 
It cost $5 USD to rent a movie. That's Blockbuster prices. And we all know what happened to them.
Redbox only charges $1. Usd
Maybe that's why.


I'm not arguing one or the other because it's a matter of preference in my opinion. However....

- In my area RedBox is $1.49.
- RedBox stocks a limited quantity of discs
- I but $200-300 worth of iTunes giftcards at 15-25% off

Therefore, I find it easier to rent on iTunes because I can get any movie at any time for about $4. I don't have to go anywhere to get it or return it.

And not that anyone asked, but I rarely buy because very few movies are worth watching more than once.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mr. Donahue
Wow, excellent! I was always on the lookout for an "appshopper" app for iTunes and iBooks stuff. Thanks for the headsup. :D

Thanks, I didn't know about this app either. Looks good!
[doublepost=1499720922][/doublepost]I looked up an old film in IMDb a few night ago, followed the link to Amazon, where I've rented before, and rented it. I never ever considered looking at iTunes/Apple Music. If Apple made separate apps maybe it would help. For instance, I wanted to buy my guitar teacher's new CD. It actually took me a while to figure out how to do this! Next time, I'll just buy the physical disc.
 
I would guess that Apple has a modern digital video content strategy up its sleeve, to update its approach to compete better with services like Amazon and Netflix. It would be the video version of Apple Music, and perhaps be built right into Apple Music.

It's just complicated to negotiate the terms with studios. And Apple is clearly also in the process of producing their own shows and movies as well.



As long as it's a DVD player...?
a what player?
 
When you buy a DVD movie you own it and can play it on any device. When you buy a movie on iTunes you don't own it and can only play it on two manufacturer's devices, Apple devices and Windows desktop.

Maybe, but who has a DVD player nowadays? I love buying on iTunes as I can view them on my iPhone, MacBook and Apple TV and I can sign in to a friend's ATV over the weekend. Plus DVD is 480p - not nice!
 
Paying extra for HD needs to die. Its freaking 2017.

Also new releases in a BD + DVD + Digital Copy combo pack are usually priced at 14,99€ while the iTunes version alone sells for 19,99€. Nope
 
I only started buying music on iTunes when it became DRM free. The same now applies to video. It simply annoys me that I could spend £100s/£1000s on digital content, only for that to be lost when (if ) I move on. At least I can leave my blu-ray collection to family/friends. It seems stupid that to leave my digital collection I would need to 'will' someone my iTunes user name and password (but no doubt that breaches the T&Cs of iTunes).

I've thought about this but really, who would want a friend's Blu-Ray collection or music? Seriously, live for today. No doubt in 10 years time, we'll all be watching film very differently from what we do now!
 
Maybe, but who has a DVD player nowadays? I love buying on iTunes as I can view them on my iPhone, MacBook and Apple TV and I can sign in to a friend's ATV over the weekend. Plus DVD is 480p - not nice!
I do. Given that I have a lot of trouble streaming movies because of network speed its more or less a necessity if I want to watch a movie not carried on a satellite channel.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ackmondual
I like buying movies from iTunes. They have decent sales, I can play them on all of my devices, and no issues with it. I got Snowden for $4.99, and other deals. They had a sale a while ago that was 20 movies for $10, and they were good classics. Get iTunes gift cards on sale, and makes movies even cheaper. For people who think they own the DVD's, think again, you don't.
 
I would guess that Apple has a modern digital video content strategy up its sleeve, to update its approach to compete better with services like Amazon and Netflix. It would be the video version of Apple Music, and perhaps be built right into Apple Music.

It's just complicated to negotiate the terms with studios. And Apple is clearly also in the process of producing their own shows and movies as well.



As long as it's a DVD player...?

I would much rather have Apple Music be music only. Once it starts to include films and TV shows, it'll start to become bloated in terms of features and interfaces.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JRobinsonJr
why would i buy music or movies from apple and limit myself to apple devices? and windows pc.

just buy on google play and you can watch wherever you want.
I get why customers avoid iTunes movies because DRM, but music has no DRM and can be played on anything. I still prefer to own music collection but most video I rather rent/stream from Netflix or similar service.
 
My Apple TV sits in the RV to Airplay Amazon and Netflix content I download to my iPAD when traveling. PS4 and Amazon Fire TV are my home streaming and DVD devices. Apple will need a significant innovation in their echo system to get me to return.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JosephAW
Hardly anything ever goes on sale? They run weekly specials in a couple of categories with movies under $10. Every weekend they put one for sale for $5 -- it was Dawn of the Planet of the Apes this weekend. Very frequently they'll put out "build your video library" with a plethora of movies for less than $10, often as low as $5.

So about the sales thing, you couldn't be more wrong. I've purchased quite a few on sale.

Everything else, I'd say you're right. Apple stuff only works on Apple products as far as I know. The user experience is pretty good in my opinion and keeps getting better, but it still is limited.

Netflix is a different animal. Sure, it's great to have all those movies and shows for $10/month. But how much on there came out in a theater in the past two years? Netflix ironically has become more of a catalog TV show and original series/movies service.

It's quite a shame the industry hasn't quite evolved to a digital form of purchases that's nearly as portable between services as discs. Or at the very least I would love to see Apple build apps to run on Roku, Android, etc. so you could potentially access your content cross-platform. This would include the ability to loan movies to a friend comparable to the rental strategy with maybe a limit of 5 per month. I buy a lot of these movies knowing my parents can watch them on their Apple TVs since we're in a family plan. But it's quite imperfect since their accounts don't realize I own these movies until you drill down into family purchases.


I agree they drop prices daily, get an app called Cheap Charts to alert you
 
  • Like
Reactions: Primejimbo
Your own link says this:

"The right to an UltraViolet movie is perpetual and remains in your Library unless you delete it. UltraViolet rights never expire. Once you download a movie you can play it as many times as you like."

Read the whole post carefully - I pointed out that what that page said is in direct conflict with the information which came with the actual UV movie I purchased.
[doublepost=1499792596][/doublepost]
Maybe, but who has a DVD player nowadays?

Do you have a PS3, PS4, or an Xbox 360 (or newer)? Then you have a "DVD player".
 
Well, no surprise considering Apple are behind in technology with no 4K, HDR, HEVC, VP9, can't simply play in browser and no cross-platform compatibility without using the bloated old-school iTunes client.
 
You clearly missed the point. Even a chain video rental store was better than red box.
I clearly missed the point too, as I still remember going to the likes of Blockbuster Video, Hollywood Video, local mom & pop video rental stores. I didn't chat much with other customers, nor the store employees. Even then, it wasn't worth the extra cost vs. $1.50 per day per DVD.

One exception was a local pharmacy had a VERY LIMITED selection of VHS videos. They were only 69 cents per day per copy. Cheap way to view all of the Star Trek films :)
[doublepost=1504042092][/doublepost]
Do you have a PS3, PS4, or an Xbox 360 (or newer)? Then you have a "DVD player".

I can't recall if my Wii has a DVD player (probably not), but even then, my PC plays Blu Ray with backwards compatibility with DVDs.

I would like to know if there are a lot of standalone DVD players. Probably not amongst those who stream stuff, but concerning those who are more luddites, or have lousy internet connections, I can seem them still using them.
 
I can't recall if my Wii has a DVD player (probably not), but even then, my PC plays Blu Ray with backwards compatibility with DVDs.

We have a Wii and a WiiU (yeah, we're one of the 10 families that actually bought a WiiU) - neither one plays DVDs, unfortunately.

Actually it doesn't really matter to us, since any DVDs/Blu-Rays we buy get ripped and loaded onto our home streaming box... but it seems like a silly oversight on Nintendo's part, since most other gaming consoles can play DVDs and/or Blu-Ray discs.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.