Melissa deserves crap for that butthead comment - maybe she thinks all the old iPads should be destroyed because they aren't worth having any more.
My 76 year old dad uses his iPad 1 - 32GB every day. He gets through 4 long hours of dialysis three day a week by listening to music on Pandora, reading books, watching movies, online banking, and keeping up with the news/weather on the internet.
I showed him my new iPad with retina display before returning it to Apple because I thought he might benefit from the better screen and he couldn't see enough difference to care. He is still too impressed with the original iPad - he has a 10 year old Escalade he is still in love with as well.
If we had waited to for Apple to put a Retina display in the iPad before getting him one then he would have been missing out on a awesome device that he has been using and enjoying for the last year and 1/2.
The iPad 1 and 2 have been thoroughly enjoyed by millions of folks young and old and will continue to be enjoyed and appreciated by anyone fortunate enough to have one - The OP gave his Mom something she will surely love.