Well, just got the seidio today in the mail. I got the black one. The kickstand can really come in handy. It does show some finger printing, but I expected this as I have used their soft touch cases in the past. It does not really bother me that much as it wipes off easily. If you want one of these cases, but don't want the fingerprints to show, the blue one is really good for that. (I have had that one in the past)
The one that I have been using daily prior to this is the Apple leather case in midnight blue. Very nice case. Fits great. Wearing well. Provides some decent protection for bumps and scratches. Feels really good in the hand too, adding some decent grip, without collecting dust/lint like the Apple silicone case did (which is why I returned that one after a week.) FWIW, this is actually my third Apple leather case. At first I got black, but after almost 2 weeks the buttons were still hard to press through the case a bit so I returned it for the red leather. Same thing with that one and so I returned it after about a week, plus I was concerned about the red leather showing too much dirt over time. The midnight blue one works great. Buttons are responsive and clicky. Hides any dirt well too. Looks grey in some lighting, black in other lighting, and of course dark blue. Kind of a cool effect.
I think the Seidio will be a really nice one if I can get one that fits a bit better. It looks like the OP got a "revised version" sent to him from Seidio which he reported fit better, so I am hoping for the same.