Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Telling the public why the products are great is much different from spinning why the products need to be thought of as great. The iPhone 4 leak may have taken the "wow factor" away from Steve Jobs' keynote debut, but I don't think it had any kind of harmful effect on perception or sales of one of the greatest devices ever to come out of Cupertino.

On the other hand, revealing Animoji as the prime feature of the iPhone X with iOS 11 gave enough of a head start for the public to realize it was a letdown and collectively ask "is that it?" even before the reveal.

I understand wanting to keep as far ahead of competitors as possible, but it seems like Apple is more concerned about suppressing negative perceptions rather than protecting the secrecy of genuinely revolutionary new products.

It comes down to stark differences. Jobs was more of a visionary than Cook. Cook is more about maximizing returns.
 
Loose lips sink ships... While I like a good rumor as much as the next person, I totally respect Apple’s position and wish them success. It’s reprehensible behavior for employees to purposely leak internal information for gain (of one form or another). I like the detective work of real rumors more than the leaks we’ve gotten lately.
 
  • Like
Reactions: jace88 and 5105973
RE: "We want the chance to tell our customers why the product is great, and not have that done poorly by someone else," Apple's Greg Joswiak said in the memo

If Tim Cook & the rest of Apple's Strategic Marketing group had done their job, NONE OF IT would matter !

Apple simply sucks at Strategic Product Planning, AND there is more evidence of that to the general public, day by day.

Most in the know (outside of Apple), can figure it out right at product launch ... the so-called Pro Stock Analysts ALL appear to require many, many extra months to do so, however.

It's NOT Rocket Science, Apple keeps over-playing their hand, as well ... e.g., trying to sell 2 GB iPhones for $699+ ! ... seriously ??? ... a well-trained Monkey could do a much better job at Strategic Product Planning, than Apple's top brass has done the past 3+ years !

The A7 in the 5s was Apple's last BIG mobile industry surprise ... exactly what year was that ??? ... the answer to that is ALL you need to know !

Apple is cooked ... most don't yet know it ... as soon as Tim is replaced, the company could see a BIG turnaround, NOT one that's just a propped-up by Share buy-backs & the promise of a BIG dividend payout !!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Marekul and 9081094
Hopefully they’ll be discovered. And canned. Maybe even sued.
 
Last edited:
I've always had the idea that some of the leaks inside Apple came from upper management. Even worse, I think good ol' Think Secrets' source must have almost been Phil Schiller. Can't prove that ofc. :)
 
I totally agree with Apple. The information pertaining to product roadmap or any other internal initiative does not belong to the leaker. It belongs to the company. It's their intellectual property.

These people are not whistleblowers exposing corruption or wrong doing. They are *******s who are either doing this for attention or to make money. Either way it's wrong.

I don't see this memo as "scare tactics." It's Apple reminding employees of their duty and responsibility. It's a company policy they have every right to enforce.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 5105973
It’s interesting that you know that those leakers were feeding a blogger in 9to5mac, which btw I hate with every single cell in my body, but you still invite them to every single keynote you hold?!
 
If you know that Apple is going to release a new iPhone in 6 months, will you possibly buy a competing phone that releases before the new iPhone comes out? I am sorry, but this is an ancient way of thinking for an industry leading company. To add to the irony, Apple has been last on everything except for in the category of unneeded and unwanted, like a freaking Touch Bar on a laptop and not a touchscreen.
If you want a touchscreen the go and buy one. However there is a reason that Apple have not done it. I wonder why the could be? Hmm let me use some intelligence to think about it. Oh yes that's right..could it be that it soon becomes a pain in the bottom when stretching your hand out to use it constantly.
 
  • Like
Reactions: martyjmclean
If I recall this iOS 12 roadmap leak they speak of is that Apple is going to try to make it a quality product?

Maybe for Apple these days that is newsworthy. For most companies, that they are trying to make a quality product wouldn't be considered news.

As for the iOS 11 leak, those were publicly accessible URLs. So one person leaked the URLs, but why weren't they behind a VPN?

If I got this memo, it would just make me a bit sadder to be working at Apple. It's not in its hey-day at the moment, and it's obviously worried about the wrong things if this is given so much emphasis.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Val-kyrie
Well, now we know for certain that iOS 12 will only be small feature upgrades and performance improvements. I'm fine with that as long as someone is working on improving Siri beyond new jokes. Otherwise it's not like iOS is really lacking—except in refinement.

One thing that still pisses me off is how difficult it is to select text sometimes. Why is this such an issue? I'll go to select something and let go and it only selects everything above what I had selected. I'll try again and it will cut what I selected in half. I try again and it will select the word after what I selected. I try again and flys out to select the entire block of text. I try to deselect and it won't. A few tries later it deselects. Finally I get a decent selection but it's missing the end word. I slowly try to expand the selection and it flys out and selects the whole chunk of text again. Eventually I get about 80% of the text selected and that's good enough, I just remember the last few words and type the rest. It's not like it happens every day but when it does happen it's annoying as hell! Not sure why something so simple can be a problem in 2018. If iOS 12 fixed this, a few instabilities issues and had a dark mode, that's all I want.
 
Hopefully they’ll be discovered. And canned. Maybe even sued.

Depending the severity of the case and the information leaked, they should be sued. If I had an employee that violated the rights of my company, trust and leaked confidential information that breached their agreement as part of their employment with the company, I can guarantee you I would sue them. They made a conscious decision to violate the company and now they have to face the consequences, both legally and termination.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 5105973
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.