Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Mac Studio Storage Not User-Upgradeable Due to Software Block [Updated]
- Thread starter MacRumors
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
Ok, I understand if the secondary slot is for technician-related use only, but the fact that he couldn't even swap the OEM SSD from his other Mac Studio and put it into the OS slot is messed up though. Apple has gone full-retard.
The second slot is for the 8TB configuration which uses two 4TB flash modules. And of course you can upgrade it by yourself. Put another 4TB module in the free slot, run an IPSW restore through DFU and Apple Configurator 2 and boom, you have a 8TB Mac Studio.
@827538 There is nothing inexcusable. Apple is not locking it down. Luke Miani just broke the encryption and didn't bother running an IPSW restore. That simple.
Macrumors
- retracts an article about the power cord of the Apple Studio Display not being detachable because if we’re being pedantic it probably kinda is (a là Homepod), because being accurate is important
- happily spreads probably fake news about the Mac Studio SSD upgradeability based on a clickbaity video by a youtuber that didn’t DFU restore the Mac after installing the new flash modules like anybody with half a brain and the ability to use google search would have tried first thing based on the Mac Pro procedure
Coming up next: an article about what Mark Gurman would like to see Apple doing.
- retracts an article about the power cord of the Apple Studio Display not being detachable because if we’re being pedantic it probably kinda is (a là Homepod), because being accurate is important
- happily spreads probably fake news about the Mac Studio SSD upgradeability based on a clickbaity video by a youtuber that didn’t DFU restore the Mac after installing the new flash modules like anybody with half a brain and the ability to use google search would have tried first thing based on the Mac Pro procedure
Coming up next: an article about what Mark Gurman would like to see Apple doing.
I think the “green” they are referring to is “green American dollar bills”
Jesus Apple
Lock down the included SSD if you must, but add some bloody NVMe slots that are user accessible and put out a list of supported NVMe blades. Hell..sell some yourself for marked up prices in the stores too.
Stop being such jerks
Lock down the included SSD if you must, but add some bloody NVMe slots that are user accessible and put out a list of supported NVMe blades. Hell..sell some yourself for marked up prices in the stores too.
Stop being such jerks
If you define modular as every single component being non-soldered and replaceable, then yes, they did pull a stunt there. But then again, who with that definition of modular would buy Apple branded computers (Mac Pro taken aside)?
They haven't locked it down... The reason the exchange / upgrade procedures in Lukes video failed simply is the hardware encryption. If you change the module, the encryption is broken. Thus, the Mac needs DFU restore using an IPSW file. And that's what Luke didn't do and instead throws the wrong assumption that Apple locked it down by Software. Same thing for the 2019 Mac Pro and Apple even documents that in the manual.
I define the Mac Pro as modular. This machine - the Mac Studio - is not. It’s just a separate device for the sake of more $$$
Disappointing, but not unexpected
I guess it’s cool that if your SSD goes bad you won’t have to pay to replace the whole logic board but just the SSD..? ?
I guess it’s cool that if your SSD goes bad you won’t have to pay to replace the whole logic board but just the SSD..? ?
This is both exciting (it’s not soldered down, that’s progress!) and disappointing (I’m not happy they’re blocking it)
It’s a great time for Apple to improve our ability to improve our own machines that we purchase. I’m tired of the locked down RAM and storage
It’s a great time for Apple to improve our ability to improve our own machines that we purchase. I’m tired of the locked down RAM and storage
Hopefully only a matter of time before Apple realizes they’re wrong for this and they stop trying to control everything
It's been this way for nearly seven years since the 2015 MacBook was released. Is this a surprise to anyone?
It's not a Windows PC. Apple has been doing this for years and they aren't changing course.
My main point remains. (That you omitted when quoting me)
They need to get out of this business of trying to profit so much on overpriced upgrades due to inflexibility by design. It’s consumer hostile, not environmentally friendly and just freaking annoying
So tell us if you plan to keep purchasing and using Apple gear. And if you have left the platform why are you still here?
Please don’t go down this road.
People can be in the ecosystem in various places (or not) and have every right to comment on all the topics here.
Correct, I understand and agree with your first paragraph. I’m just suggesting that Apple probably won’t be selling these kits to end customers like they are doing with the SSD kit for the 2019 Mac Pro. Maybe they’ll sell a kit to a AASP and you can have them do it just like they can change the stand/mount on the Studio Display.
The main lesson here is to forget everything we previously knew about booting up Macs from different drives or from Internet Recovery because it has all changed with Apple Silicon Macs. And some of the changes such as:
1. Dependence on the internal drive for booting up external drives even with boot security turned off
2. Needing to connect a second Mac in order to pair an SSD to the first Mac,
may seem like a step backwards. How much these changes are based on data security vs. profit security (making it more difficult to change components) is open for discussion.
Last edited:
I would hope that Apple had some protection from the main OS drive being installed in another machine. I know the guy wiped the drive first. Until a drive is available to purchase that fits, this test went exactly how id expect.
I’m well aware of that, but if Apple states that the SSD is not upgradeable, the nature of this limitation (software or hardware) is irrelevant. People here are mad about something that Apple is very transparent about and that is not even new. This software limitation is probably a way for Apple to be fair to the people who paid big money to get more internal storage. I’d be very mad if I paid 500$ to upgrade my storage directly with Apple when there’s in fact a way to get the same amount of storage for way less. For sure it’s a greedy move from Apple, but it was 100% expected.
As I said, I still think that Apple should allow more modularity and I’d be pleased if the SSD was user-upgradable. I just don’t see why suddenly we are surprised that apple doesn’t allow us to do so
If Bill Gates had done this, Steve Jobs would have commissioned a TV commercial to mock it and I think he's mocking Tim Cook from the grave as we speak as it stands now.
I would never spend $2000 on anything I couldn't upgrade or do something by myself. PERIOD.
When will Tim Cook, bean counter, learn what it means to be insanely great?
I would never spend $2000 on anything I couldn't upgrade or do something by myself. PERIOD.
When will Tim Cook, bean counter, learn what it means to be insanely great?