Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

mahmud

macrumors newbie
Original poster
Greetings !!

I have MacBook Pro 4,1, 17-Inch, Early 2008. I have been using this mac since 2010 and it was perfect, never had any serious problem. 🙂

Recently, it has started this strange problem. It works fine for shutdown and stops working if i restart/sleep/close the lid. It goes straight to sleep mode and doesn't start. 😕

And once it goes to sleep mode, there is no way of waking up. The same problem happens if i click "Restart" the computer, or close the lid. It doesn't turn on, it shows black screen, no chime sound, no keyboard light. Only fan and DVD get the power i suppose. Every time i will have to "shutdown" the computer properly, otherwise it won't start next time. So, now the question is how do turn the mac on next time ??

Well, i leave it for 2/3 hours, then it heats up like hell and then i press the power button, and it turns on again. Again it works until i click "restart" or it goes to sleep mode. I know it could be the well-known nVidia problem that early mac 2008 has. But Apple Store said it doesn't have any nVidia problem, also it doesn't have that warranty period to change the logic board.
🙁

What kind of problem is this, that works fine for shutdown and stops working if i restart/sleep/close the lid ??? 🙁

And every time it has this problem i need to fry my laptop !!!


Anybody, any help will be appreciated.
 
Seems like a logic board issue. At this point repairing it might cost a little since parts for this specific Mac are well, no readily available.

I rarely give out the following advice, but have you:

  • Reset pRAM
  • Checked disk permissions
  • Reset SMC settings
  • Run Apple Hardware Diagnostic tests

Any of those might help figure your issue for certain.
 
Seems like a logic board issue. At this point repairing it might cost a little since parts for this specific Mac are well, no readily available.

I rarely give out the following advice, but have you:

  • Reset pRAM
  • Checked disk permissions
  • Reset SMC settings
  • Run Apple Hardware Diagnostic tests

Any of those might help figure your issue for certain.


Thank you so much for your prompt reply.. feeling rescued already. 🙂

1. But i tried this resetting PRAM stuff, didn't work. 🙁
2. I am not sure about disk permissions, but how to do this ??
3. Already ran SMC settings, didn't work. 🙁
4. It's MBP 4,1 Early 2008, I don't think it has this Hardware Testing. I tried CMD + D, F2, didn't work.

Thank you again for your reply..
 
Seems like a logic board issue. At this point repairing it might cost a little since parts for this specific Mac are well, no readily available.

I rarely give out the following advice, but have you:

  • Reset pRAM
  • Checked disk permissions
  • Reset SMC settings
  • Run Apple Hardware Diagnostic tests

Any of those might help figure your issue for certain.


I repaired the disk permissions. 😱

I don't know what to say.. but i think it worked 😀
I mean I clicked on restart and sleep, and then i closed the lid.. and still my MBP powered on without frying it, which was not possible for more than 6 months. 😉

It's too early to say but i think it worked, let's see... what do you think ?? 😕
 
It most likely was some software glitch within the OS. Try the wait and see approach at this point. If the issue is resolved, then problem fixed.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.