Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
This, so much this! Most of the reviews vomited exactly what we saw in the keynote a week ago. What’s the point of waiting for this. Also why I’m Going to start my own channel. There just needs to be more critical feedback. I’m not suggesting we should look for issues. But Apple has reached the pinnacle of essentially creating their own reviews. I love seeing people who have bought with their own money. And I will be one of those who will be doing that as I think this is really just needed in this day and age.

The more critical and compressive videos tend to drop another couple of weeks from today. It’s simply not possible to test the devices adequately and hope to still be able to churn out a review video during this short period of time.

I typically watch Dave2D and iJustine first. The only takeaway I got from the latter is that it churns through 8k raw footage like butter, but I couldn’t really make out what they were doing with the editing process. It was just a lot of “oohs and aahs”.

I do agree that with these videos so far, it seems like a lot of filler and very little actual useful content.
 
The more critical and compressive videos tend to drop another couple of weeks from today. It’s simply not possible to test the devices adequately and hope to still be able to churn out a review video during this short period of time.

I typically watch Dave2D and iJustine first. The only takeaway I got from the latter is that it churns through 8k raw footage like butter, but I couldn’t really make out what they were doing with the editing process. It was just a lot of “oohs and aahs”.

I do agree that with these videos so far, it seems like a lot of filler and very little actual useful content.
I have a 8TB M1 Max 16” with 64 GB ram Coming maxed out and that will be connected to 2 XDR displays That I have on my desk. So I will throughly be putting this through it’s paces. Just now getting the stuff I need for a channel, so it’ll be rough, but the content is what matters the most…
 
I have a 8TB M1 Max 16” with 64 GB ram Coming maxed out and that will be connected to 2 XDR displays That I have on my desk. So I will throughly be putting this through it’s paces. Just now getting the stuff I need for a channel, so it’ll be rough, but the content is what matters the most…

All the best. I know created tech practically built up his channel by covering M1 macs exclusively for months, so it definitely can work.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BarrettF77
iJustine is the biggest Apple shill on the planet.

Welcome to the high caste of internet Influencer's you get 5 start preferential treatment, first to get new devices before release so they have time to drop the Unboxing & First Impressions the second the embargo lifts, first name terms with the CEO, comped travel and accommodation to product reveals..

Also top marks to ijustine for the irritating open mouth fake surprised derp face thumbnail which every reviewer needs to flood your recommended video list as the SEO social scientists worked out that's the best eye catching clickbait thumbnail to use(!)

TL;DR​

I'm more interested in Max Tech's review and benchmarks rather than a gloried advert disguised as an unboxing, maybe Timmy should prioritize actual tech pros allocation of early units rather than corporate friendly powerful Influencer's with high seo reach..​

 
Welcome to the high caste of internet Influencer's you get 5 start preferential treatment, first to get new devices before release so they have time to drop the Unboxing & First Impressions the second the embargo lifts, first name terms with the CEO, comped travel and accommodation to product reveals..

Also top marks to ijustine for the irritating open mouth fake surprised derp face thumbnail which every reviewer needs to flood your recommended video list as the SEO social scientists worked out that's the best eye catching clickbait thumbnail to use(!)

TL;DR​

I'm more interested in Max Tech's review and benchmarks rather than a gloried advert disguised as an unboxing, maybe Timmy should prioritize actual tech pros allocation of early units rather than corporate friendly powerful Influencer's with high seo reach..​

Anyone “influenced” by these “influencers” must be on the low-end of the IQ spectrum.

And yes, the iJustine “oh my god, wow, it’s so shiny” and hair-flicking does my head in

As I said before, she’s the kind of person who rings up for car insurance, and when they ask what car it is, replies “it’s a blue one”
 
Where’s MKBHD?
Probably too busy shilling for lord musk whilst getting his 1000 mph plaid model s repaired(!)

But seriously its surprising that gatekeeper tech god hasn't dropped the embargo video yet.
Maybe he wants to avoid the typical tech embargo lift inbox explosion?

I guess bias Linus techtips who jumped the shark in 2018 will review the laptop next year as he is a massive apple cynic (remember when he said the M1 would be a complete flop?) and only shills for the highest bidder.

I miss the old days of tech review channels before fame and $40m+ wealth corrupted them :(
 
  • Like
Reactions: amartinez1660
Justine's was good, considering most reviewers apparently don't want to show us their Final Cut Pro workflow, or just use the competition. Genuinely she has a good barometer of what performance is.
 
If Apple are happy with the review, they may not request the testing unit to be shipped back. It is usual practice across the industry.
In my opinion, a respectable journalist should send the review unit back.
 
Not wanting to be that guy, but after seeing a couple of reviews ... Dave2D is still the most down-to-earth guy in all of these. Rene, which I used to follow and quite like, was massively fanboying on this review IMHO.

In the end ... great laptops, super powerful, CPUs are killer ... the notch is still the stupidest thing ever!
 
The reviews suck. They're all mostly the same, listing specs, talking about the notch, blah, blah. Show us you importing 500 RAW photos. Tons of video. Open resourse hungry apps, how fast does it load? Etc, etc. iJustine did the best job, a long video of her editor running 8K video and comparing it to other experiences.
 
Is it a requirement to review an Apple product early to be as insufferable as humanly possible?
 
I like Rene's stuff generally. This was OK as well but yeah he's clearly like the lot of them been told what to disclose and what not to at this early stage. All in all the video ends up being pretty short and not nearly enough in-depth.

I expect this to change. Oh so many MBP-reviews I'll be watching in the coming weeks. It'll be insane. And I won't even be getting one!
 
I like Rene's stuff generally. This was OK as well but yeah he's clearly like the lot of them been told what to disclose and what not to at this early stage. All in all the video ends up being pretty short and not nearly enough in-depth.

I expect this to change. Oh so many MBP-reviews I'll be watching in the coming weeks. It'll be insane. And I won't even be getting one!
haha . the last apple i bough .. boya.. i prefer dave2d only . other seem bias ..
** https://www.youtube.com/c/CreatedTechOfficial new on the block but not me . I'm only do code tutorial
 
When Justine said it looks strange without the Touch Bar I thought that why not have both? Move the Touch Bar to be above the number keys and have it do more niche things. Would've made it more expensive for sure but the space between key top keys and the edge is pretty big. Big enough for a Touch Bar...
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.