Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
So planned obsolescence...
Just a proof that Apple loves to apply senseless limitations solely because of business benefits by planned obsolescence.
Absolutely. And, for a user that doesn’t like planned obsolescence, they can choose a different platform. I’ve helped folks do this in the past and they’re all happier about having done it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: peanuts_of_pathos
I wonder what’s John Grubers excuse now. I remember him saying, Live Text was only possible because the M1 chip. When it was obvious Apple was just being stubborn about adding support. It would be ridiculous a feature like this would really require the M1 chip. Worse, they are still selling Intel MacBook Pros for the foreseeable future.

He will come up with some silly excuse to cover for Apple - as always.
Why anyone listens to him about anything anymore is beyond me.

I used to love him many moons ago, but he’s just so biased that it’s largely a waste of time.
He is basically Apple PR
 
Yeah this has been bizarre to me. This feature was explicitly said to NOT be coming to intel Macs, and Apple added it anyway and people are mad about it. I don't get it.
People who are mad at Apple for any one of a number of past crimes (canceling FCP 7 or iWeb, ending Airport, not creating a cheaper tower, not creating a cheaper monitor, being successful) will always be mad at Apple. Whether or not it’s rational doesn’t factor into it :)
 
  • Sad
Reactions: peanuts_of_pathos
Good. Now bring the Monterey features of Maps (3D globe) to Intel Macs. there is no technical reason the new Maps globe feature be limited to M1 Macs either.
 
  • Love
Reactions: turbineseaplane
It's worth noting that as of the time of this posting, the official macOS Monterey features list still indicates that the M1 chip is required to use Live Text.

Whether they will update that list or not likely depends on whether the beta testers can successfully use Live Text on their Intel Macs.
 
It's kind of making me wonder if the pandemic may be delaying their timeline for a full ASi switch a bit and forcing them to perhaps do the work to bring things to Intel.

Given how aggressive Apple felt about going all in on ASi, it honestly feels like the full rollout has been a bit slower than I would have thought.

Don't get me wrong - it's not "slow" objectively -- it just feels like a bit slower of a roll than I maybe was expecting.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ASentientBot
Sure they are in charge, that’s why they are responsible for the planned obsolescence. They changed their mind because too many users got pissed off, but as i said it was primarily a planned obsolescence to prioritize their business benefits, which got reconsidered. Simply as that, and proves how they generally tic. As soon they can, they drive their users against the wall, this feature wasn’t simply important enough to continue to piss off their users. Breaking iCloud Notes Sync builds a much stronger longer lever.
Your logic doesn’t make a whole lot of sense here. Apple initially didn’t include the text feature for Intel Macs. During the beta process, Apple realized it was technically feasible without compromising the experience, so added in the feature. And yet, this proved planned obsolescence?

Would you have rather do Apple just not include the text feature?

I guess you’re the prod that Apple is damned if they don’t/damned if they do.
 
  • Like
Reactions: sintra1
It says that it's available on M1 systems. It doesn't say that you need one. It's possible that it was always the plan to make it available on Intel if there was sufficient time to develop it.
Thanks for the comment. The text currently reads:

2. Available on Mac computers with the M1 chip.

This could be interpreted either way, as I see it. As @cmChimera pointed out, if this was an inclusive feature (in other words, if the feature worked on Macs with either Intel or M1 chips), there wouldn't be a need for the footnote.

Anyway, the whole point of the article we're commenting on was that the feature seems to be enabled for Intel users in the latest beta, so Apple may have changed their mind for Intel Mac users.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.