svenmany
macrumors 68030
Ok, but many of the things being complained about, like round app window corners, have zero to do with accessibility or visibility concerns and are just a preference thing… And the reports of “poor visibility” of UI elements in Tahoe are greatly exaggerated… And nearly every legitimate case of poor visibility I’ve seen is a bug, not proper intended behavior of the system… 🤷🏼♂️. Or they’re cases of things that don’t naturally look bad, but people have very intentionally tried to make look as bad as possible… This is possible to do with lots of great designs if people try hard enough… 🤷🏼♂️
The biggest issue with the rounded window corners is the resizing bug. I hope you're aware of that. The help bring you up to speed:
Why It’s Difficult to Resize Windows on MacOS 26 Dyehoe
https://noheger.at/blog/2026/01/11/the-struggle-of-resizing-windows-on-macos-tahoe/
I will acknowledge that the loss of content space that the rounded corners cause is a sacrifice some don't notice. And some might like the rounded corners and be willing to pay the price.
There is a practical problem with the extremely rounded corners for web browsers. Developers of web pages (I'm one) have to cater for it. When you code your content, you try to make it look good in all browsers on all platforms. The radical changes in macOS is making this challenging.
Chrome recently released a rounded corner version for macOS. They chose to round the windows slightly less than what Safari did. (I don't think you would notice the difference.) But the latest Chrome on Windows has no change to curvature at all. So, in terms of radius of curvature we have
Chrome Windows < Chrome macOS < Safari macOS.
The Fastmail web app I use all day long has their content contained in its own slightly rounded corners - using a traditional curvature. It doesn't look good in Safari - at the bottom right of the window, their border pushes up against the window's edge. Chrome on macOS is not too bad. Chrome on Windows looks great. To be honest, I wouldn't have noticed the degradation in Chrome on macOS. Safari actually bothers me. But, I acknowledge that's a preference thing. People without a strong design sense wouldn't care or notice.
"And nearly every legitimate case of poor visibility I’ve seen is a bug, not proper intended behavior of the system…"
I think there's a chance you are right if you are referring to translucency issues. The fact that I cannot shut off the translucency in Preview with the "Reduce transparency" setting must be a bug. I wish Apple didn't have so many bugs in Liquid Glass. First impressions matter.
I'm not generally a fan of influencers, but John Gruber writes really well and comes across as very intelligent. He writes from a position of indirect knowledge since he interviews a lot of technical people. He also has some technical background as the creator of Markdown. I would suggest you take a look at more of his content than just the article I linked to above. He is very critical of Tahoe from a design/bug/regression perspective. In fact, you should really spend more time reading what professionals think. Strong opinions are best when mixed with knowledge.