Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Yes, you are missing something. When you say, "With apple pay, vendors can then explicitly choose to accept visa, mastercard AND applepay" is incorrect. That statement makes Apple sound to be a type of credit card, when it is not.

The store just needs to accept NFC payments, the credit card module that has a symbol that looks like a sideways wifi bar signal. If they have this, they accept apple pay (as well as google wallet and whatever else uses NFC). They can't exclude Apple Pay without excluding ALL of the NFC payments out there.

I don't know where you're located, but McDonalds, for example, has these modules in probably every store in the USA. Therefore it was easy for them to say they accept apple pay. they've had these machines in their restaurants for a long time. Because they accept NFC payments, that's all that matters. They can't accept NFC while excluding Apple. It's all or nothing.

It comes down to this... These stores aren't explicitly saying no to Apple Pay. Instead, they are saying no to accepting NFC. By them calling it apple pay just goes to show how powerful apple is in entering an industry, already using their coined term for the technology.
So when Costco says no to apple pay, they're really saying no to NFC machines altogether.

In a way, Google Wallet has helped put these machines in a lot of stores. The difference for us is that Apple Pay is a more secure way of doing it. Google will keep track of where you buy to keep profiling and making advertising dollars off of you, Apple won't. Google will be using and sharing your credit card number with the store, Apple won't (since it's a one time use card number they use each time).

You almost got it right. Google doesn't share you CC number as you're given a virtual Master Card number and each time you make a payment a token is generated for that sale.
 
Actually, a few restaurants where I live have NFC payment systems attached to the table, you can even re order drinks through it and it has games on it for kids, actually pretty cool.

While that does sound cool, it's definitely not the norm here in the states. And I definitely don't see it becoming standard any time soon. Maybe in the next few years or so.
 
Thats too bad, I really wanted more places where I could use Apple Pay so that every transaction I make, complete with even more tracking information, could have a faster route directly to the NSA via Apples servers...
 
Last edited:
Really? Do you all actually think Apple went to all the thousands of retailers and let them in on Apple Pay prior to the announcement? That's probably a good reason why a lot aren't on board yet. And, they have to review their technologies prior to implementing.
 
I didn't read all comments so forgive me if this has already been said, but isn't their saying they won't support Apple Pay just them saying they won't support NFC payments? Or possibly not understanding what Apple Pay is? Sort of analogous to a business saying they won't take credit cards but the headline reading "Acme will not accept Visa."
 
... All I know is, if :apple:Pay/NFC takes off, it's going to put a real dent in the bottom line of the 'panhandling' industry.

Does this mean they're going to have to come up with portable NFC systems? ;)

Just my inquiring mind wanting to know.
 
While that does sound cool, it's definitely not the norm here in the states. And I definitely don't see it becoming standard any time soon. Maybe in the next few years or so.

It happened here pretty quick, I live in a smaller town in Utah so maybe were adapting fast. But in the end it is cool and I hope restaurants and businesses move more towards this type of payment system.
 
Chip cards are not hackable; the chip on the card does a handshake with the payment network:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EMV#Transaction_flow

The chip cards are difficult to hack, but can still be stolen and used at retailers who use chip and sign.

And even chip-and-pin is vulnerable to that whole Target/Home Depot/DQ/Kmart/Sears thing where the back end transactions get hacked in bulk.

Just sayin'...
 
Your icons are annoying.




Only if the UK terminal supports tokenization... which it may not.

You're annoying. It is one click instead of typing Apple every time.

The POS terminal doesn't know it is receiving a token, it "thinks" it is getting a regular CC number. The tokenization is between the secure element in the phone and the CC issuer. If you have a card from a CC issuer that supports :apple:Pay (a prerequisite for being able to set up your CC with :apple:Pay on your iPhone in the first place) then it is exactly the same as carrying around a contactless payment enabled CC, except way better and more secure.

What do you mean when you say local network?

----------

I didn't read all comments so forgive me if this has already been said, but isn't their saying they won't support Apple Pay just them saying they won't support NFC payments? Or possibly not understanding what Apple Pay is? Sort of analogous to a business saying they won't take credit cards but the headline reading "Acme will not accept Visa."

Yes.
 
Apple's 1.5% is coming from the banks and payment networks, NOT the retailer. Here's the link to MacRumors own news post about it.

Oh, really. So that 1.5% is coming out of the bank's profit?

The banks are in a line of business where they will pay out more in expenses to operate a service than they make from operating the service?

Of course the retailer is going to pay it. The bank isn't going to give up any money to Apple just because their customer (the retailer) chooses to play nice with Apple.
 
Having been part of both Home Depot and Target breaches, I will not shop anywhere that doesn't take Apple Pay for significant purchases. I'm going back to checks and cash, I don't care how long it takes to write a check. Best Buy just doesn't want to upset Samsung.

Ummm, no. NFC and ApplePay are the same thing to a retailer. If Best Buy supported ApplePay, it would mean they support NFC - that includes Google Wallet, ISIS, and anything else available on Samsung/Android phones.
 
Speaking from experience of working in the retail marketing space, the single biggest reason why it'll be quite a long time before NFC/Apple Pay is ubiquitous, is because of cost. People seem to think it's as easy as flipping a switch to support a new payment format. It's not. It requires an upending of the point-of-sale infrastructure. Not that they shouldn't invest in the future, but it's an EXTREMELY expensive endeavor. It's tough enough for some retailers to even change the way their receipts print out. Changing the kinds of technologies they accept for payment...

We've got a long road ahead of us.
QFT

It's not these retailers are resisting. They just are not ready.
 
Oh, really. So that 1.5% is coming out of the bank's profit?

The banks are in a line of business where they will pay out more in expenses to operate a service than they make from operating the service?

Of course the retailer is going to pay it. The bank isn't going to give up any money to Apple just because their customer (the retailer) chooses to play nice with Apple.

It's 0.15%, not 1.5%. Big difference when you're talking about millions of dollars in transactions.
 
I didn't read all comments so forgive me if this has already been said, but isn't their saying they won't support Apple Pay just them saying they won't support NFC payments? Or possibly not understanding what Apple Pay is? Sort of analogous to a business saying they won't take credit cards but the headline reading "Acme will not accept Visa."

You got it. But this makes for many more page views and click throughs.

A bit irresponsible I think, because half the comments are asking for clarification, or giving incorrect information.
 
In a word. "Yes."

What happens if you decide to take a vacation outside a major city, your car needs gas, and the only gas station around only takes plastic?

Are you going to buy gas, or will you sit in your car and play with your iPhone until the gas station decides to get a NFC terminal? :D
 
By the end of this year, hacking events like Target/HD/DQ/Sears will be a daily occurrence. Retailers will have no choice but to purchase new equipment. Banks will have no choice but to issue secure cards. Those that cannot afford it will not survive in their current form.

A new wave of bank consolidations is coming and this is the catalyst.

It is not an Apple thing. They just brought the water when we were all thirsty.
 
Everyone should call the business of the list that says that they will not accept  Pay, ask them if they will accept it, and, if they say that they will not, say, "That's okay. I will shop elsewhere from now on.

This might get them to change their minds.
 
By the end of this year, hacking events like Target/HD/DQ/Sears will be a daily occurrence. Retailers will have no choice but to purchase new equipment. Banks will have no choice but to issue secure cards. Those that cannot afford it will not survive in their current form.

A new wave of bank consolidations is coming and this is the catalyst.

It is not an Apple thing. They just brought the water when we were all thirsty.

Yes, Kmart just announced that they were hacked, today, October 11.

EDIT: I meant, today October 10. :eek: Oops.
 
Last edited:
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.