The more I look at this new UI, the more I think Microsoft fanatics are going to wake up tomorrow with a bad hangover and realize this is not the Windows Mobile they were hoping for. And prominent bloggers who are prematurely gushing about it, like Jesus Diaz at Gizmodo, are going to wish they had let things simmer in their brains a little longer before rushing those early "reviews" and proclamations of greatness out the door. Just compare the two UIs below:
From that single screen on the iPhone, I can launch
20 different applications, see my number of new emails, text messages, voicemail messages/missed calls, and application updates awaiting me. I can see my signal strength, battery life, and if Bluetooth is on.
From that single screen on the Windows phone, I can launch
6 different applications (you can't see what the 7th is in the bottom right corner) and see my new emails, text messages, and voicemail messages/missed calls.
If I flick to the next screen on the iPhone, I have another 16 applications to choose from (plus access to the primary 4 apps in the bottom bar).
If you hit the arrow on the Windows phone to see the next screen, you get 9 visible applications in a one-per-line list. Wanna see more? You gotta scroll.
And what's up with the gratuitous/superfluous animations on the Windows phone? It seems everything you do is accompanied by page and tile flip effects. Bleh.
I see nothing more than (questionable) style over substance in what looks far more conceptual than marketable. MS is essentially dumping their current WinMo user base with they hope they'll attract the tween set with a bunch of special effects and Xbox Live integration, and even this is almost a year away - as if Apple, Google and Palm will be sitting around waiting.
Sorry WinMo fans, I don't see a serious contender here - no matter how much $$$ Microsoft has to throw into the mix.