stcanard said:
Please tell me. How is OSX on intel more prone to viruses than OSX on PPC?
I'd love to figure out the reasoning here.
The argument I've heard is that buffer overflows are more common on Intels, but I don't know enough about hardware to judge whether there's any thread of truth to that claim. Even if the claim were true, the effect would be negligible. The real problem with Windows is 1. the prevalence of administrator-only applications, making it hard for many people to use a restricted user account as their everyday account, 2. the easy accessibility to the scripting host from internet-capable applications like IE and Outlook/Outlook Express, 3. intalling ActiveX applications with system level access without a system-level confirmation. These are all software issues; the buffer overflow exploits are important (worms, worm, worms), but are usually quite patchable.
I just don't like the idea of leaving PPC hardware. I don't like the idea that some software starting in two years won't run on my Mac (sure, existing stuff will come with fat binaries, but the new stuff will no more come with fat binaries than new OS X applications that were released 1.0 after 10.1 came out were released with OS 9 implementations), which I spent $3000 on in part because I figured I could get 6 years out of it; I don't like the idea that Apple is going with a supplier who has a reputation for going for quantity, not quality. Possible changes with lower probability that I really don't like - if the final boxes have much in common with these developer boxes, I don't like the idea of a Mac that can run Windows natively (believe me, that will HURT OS X, not help it; people don't buy an OS because it's a good OS, they buy it because it can run the software they need - the Betamax effect), I don't like the idea of a generic BIOS rather than Open Firmware (I work with generic BIOSes all day long, and they suck; open firmware is much, much easier to deal with), I don't like the idea of Apple loosening control over their hardware platform, which I think may be inevitable with the switch to Intel hardware (even if they do intend the shipping systems to have open firmware, etc.), and which I think will soon enough put us in the same kind of driver hell Windows users have been experiencing. I bought a Mac because I'm SICK of dealing with the problems with Intel boxes - regardless of what OS they're running (yes, some issues are hardware related, not software). Finally, the idea that the developer boxes have integrated video scares me.
If the new Mactel boxes are anything like the developer boxes, which may mean easy OS X hacks to beige box systems or easy install of Windows on Mac systems, I don't see much of a future for Apple as a computer company. Let's hope Steve's much vaunted business acumen doesn't fail him on that score.
Then again, maybe Steve's decided he just wants to sell iPods. \me with disgust.