Sorry, not wrong according to ATT's upgrade policy.
http://www.wireless.att.com/learn/why/upgrade-advantage.jsp To get a subsidized phone you have to be in at least in the 18th month of your contract, which would be impossible for 3G owners. How you qualified early I can't say.
To respond to this. I purchased the 1st Gen iPhone September 2008(Full price from Apples Website). When the new 3G iPhone arose I was able to stand in line and get the subsidized price ($299.99 16GB). Upon calling ATT and Apple(Although Apple Told me that I should be able to , I would still need to contact ATT about the matter) about the upgrade/update process I will still be eligible to upgrade/update AS LONG as I sign for a new 2 year agreement.
This includes purchasing the new iPhone at a subsidized price or paying full price (The choice is mine , but we already know what that would be)
Thats the catch for the situation.
And after reading your page that is the upgrade Advantage page which ensures that you as a customer can receive a credit/discount
Monthly charges per line 18-23 months since
activation/upgrade 24+ months since
activation/upgrade
Greater than $99 Additional $50 off our standard 2-year service agreement discount Additional $100 off our standard 2-year service agreement discount
Between $69 and $98.99 Standard 2-year service agreement discount* Additional $50 off our standard 2-year service agreement discount*
Less than $68.99 Standard 2-year service agreement discount begins after 20 months
As I have stated , you can call yourself and explain when you purchased your 3G iphone and you will be told what I was told. I stood in line with some other mac-a-holics and recently converted souls to purchase mine.I asked about subsidy for the new version and was told that I would still be able to get the discount of subsidy.