Excellent posts by everyone!
I have been with AT&T TV NOW (formerly DirecTV NOW) since the day it came out, and unlike a lot of people, I love it. I am grandfathered on the old "Go Big" package which has more than enough channels for me, and all the channels I watch, and I get free HBO for as long as I am with them. So the free HBO saves me $15 right there, and I only pay $25/month for the service...really cannot beat that! According to AT&T TV's customer service chat, which I have a copy of in case they ever try to screw me, the reason I get free HBO is because I am an AT&T Wireless Customer and get a 25% discount with them because I get a "New York Government Employee" discount because I work at two out the three local hospitals. I am also currently getting free Showtime for a year, so that saves me another $15/month. So $30 saved right up front, plus the 25% discount...I cannot find anything that beats it. Also, the picture on my Samsung OLED TV comes in WAY better than cable ever did, since cable boxes around here at least, are STILL stuck on 720p - which just puzzles me?!?! The sound through my Sony entertainment system is also WAY better than it was when I had cable. I run all of this through my ATV4K in my living room, and my ATVHD in my bedroom.
Though to be fair, when I tried to trial of YouTube TV and Sling, the picture was also excellent on those, along with the sound, but I would have to give the best picture to YouTube TV (even over AT&T TV) since apparently they offer 1080p 60fps on *most* of their channels last I knew. Sports looks amazing in 1080p 60fps! Also, YouTube TV's DVR is better, just because it is unlimited. I get 20 hours with AT&T, and while I do not DVR that much, I can see people who DVR a lot of sports or movies running out rather quickly! I think with AT&T TV, you get two streams with your package, and if you want a third stream you have to pay $5 I believe. That is another thing I get for free for being an AT&T Wireless Customer, a third stream. Now, being a single male who lives alone, the most I ever use is two streams. I might have one going in my living room, and then one going in my bedroom, depending on what I am doing. Or sometimes I have a stream going in my living room and then one on my Mac or iPad in the kitchen when I am cooking. I guess it is nice to know I have the third stream available if I need it...which is very rare.
The issue is that in my area, AT&T TV does not yet have ANY of our local channels. So, I did a chat with AT&T TV customer service, and complained that it has been years and we have zero local channels when the two big cities I am in-between (Syracuse, NY & Albany, NY) have them all. My city, Utica, NY is right on the NYS Thru-Way and only about 40 miles from Syracuse, and about 80-90 miles from Albany. Anyway, I told them I have been extremely patient waiting for them to get local channels, and they tell me that they are working on the contracts now to get the local channels up and running in my area. I am not stupid, I know they are just saying that, as I do not think a customer service rep. would know what contracts are being worked out. Anyway, they ended up crediting my account $7 each month for the cost of CBS All-Access, which does have my local CBS channel, but I do not actually use it.
However, what I do is since I live in a condo building (and am in a unique situation) and the ONLY internet we can get is Spectrum because the building was only wired for cable (and I think they had a deal with Time Warner that carried over with Spectrum to be the only carrier allowed in the building), and they are the only
traditional cable provider around here. I use them for internet (obviously) and I also pay them $20/month (technically $13/month because AT&T TV credits my account for $7 for the cost of CBS All-Access) for their TV Choice Package, which includes ALL my local channels, and then 15 channels that I get to pick, plus you get to pick either HBO or Showtime. At the time I did not have Showtime on my AT&T TV account, so I picked Showtime. I would say it is actually better on Spectrum though because you get all the Showtime channels, whereas on AT&T TV, I only get Showtime East. I use the Spectrum services through their Spectrum TV App on ATV's, WAY better picture and sound than a cable box! However, I will watch movies directly in the HBO GO & Showtime Anytime apps because they appear to have slightly better picture and sound in my opinion.
So my breakdown is like this:
AT&T TV NOW=$25.00
Spectrum Internet-400/20=$90.00
Spectrum TV Choice=$13.00
Total=$128.00/month
Some people may look at that and say wow, that is expensive, but when I had everything through Spectrum, my bill was $213-220.00/month or sometimes more because the damn bill changed EVERY month almost, and I changed nothing. That is why Spectrum got in trouble in New York State, among other shady practices.
I will gladly take that $85-92/month savings! Also, if you think about it, the $30/month I save for getting free HBO and Showtime, I am saving $115-122/month!
I guess my point is, maybe you will find a service that has every cable channel you would like, but not your locals channels. There are workarounds, and it appears with AT&T TV shedding so many customers right now, that they will hook you up so you stay with them. I know the prices have gone up on AT&T TV, and I am not even going to pretend like I know which channels are in which packages now, hell, I do not even know the package names anymore.
Also, I RARELY experience these outages that a lot of other people seem to have. Maybe it is because I do not live in a super huge city or something. I have always had a great experience with their customer service chat, however, I always have the chat emailed to me in case they try to pull a fast one on me, I have the proof of what they said and offered! So far I have never had to use a chat transcript because they have always stuck to their word, but it is nice to know I have the proof - if needed.
I am going to guess that some of you are going to accuse me of being an AT&T TV fanboy, and while I do like the service, I was looking at switching to YouTube TV or Sling (I think) not too long ago because they offer my local channels, however, I just feel like I cannot leave AT&T TV when I am grandfathered on the best plan they ever offered and only pay $25/month, and get free HBO (for life) and Showtime for a year, which does not really matter because I get Showtime with the Spectrum TV Choice package.
Now, once college football season is over, because that is basically the only reason I get it, so I can watch my as of right now #3 Ohio State Buckeyes on ABC or Fox and other good games on CBS (SEC games like the Auburn-LSU game this past Saturday), I have a choice to make. Keep the Spectrum TV Choice w/ Showtime or drop it and just get CBS All-Access to watch my local CBS channel for local news and more importantly college basketball and eventually the NCAA Tournament come March Madness. ABC and Fox do not cover basketball, well...Fox has B1G 10 games on sometimes, but nothing like the big ranked matchups (Duke vs. UNC - GO Tar Heels!!!) that ESPN, and CBS cover, plus the conference championship tournaments. Once the tournament gets here CBS's sister channels like TBS, Freeform (I think?), and TNT etc. cover the tournament as well.
As "vertical smile" said above though, do I really need 400/20 internet? Most likely not. I do have a lot of devices all using the internet at once, but the reason I keep the 400/20 is 1. To drop down to 100/10 it costs $75-80/month, so to me that makes no sense, so I just pay the extra $10-15/month to get 300 extra megs download and 10 megs upload, and 2. Spectrum over provisioned my modem, so using the MAS Ookla Speedtest app, I just got 486.33/23.83, which is basically my average. I figure why let that go?
The OP mentioned something about "Yellowstone." My package on AT&T TV has the Paramount Channel, which I just looked now and I can get Season 1 & 2 On Demand through AT&T TV.
I just checked on AT&T TV's website, you would have to get the "MAX" package which is $70/month to get the Paramount TV channel, but does include HBO and Cinemax. They have four other packages that range from $93/month to $135/month. To me that is a ripoff! I am glad I am grandfathered in or I would definitely be switching to a different service.
Anyway, I am sorry for making this post SUPER long, but people do have options to mix different services and STILL save money vs. those damn cable bundles. You just have to do your research, and sometimes get a little lucky like I did with customer service, haha.
Good luck with your search, I hope everything works out for you!