Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Naked iPhone 4? Safe?
- Thread starter TapHappy
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
When I first got my iPhone 4 I was very paranoid. My old Razor phone looked pretty beat up after carrying it around in my pocket for a few years - along with keys, pocket change and whatever else.
I got the invisible shield and a bumper and thought it was pretty good - not nearly as problematic with using the screen as some had reported but after a little time the invisible shield seemed very hard to keep clean.
I took it off last August and have had the screen naked since then with not even a scratch. It works and feels much nicer and just about keeps itself clean - just amazing!
I still have the bumper as I like the grip it gives the phone and it really isn't too obtrusive and mine fits nice. I also have a back skin - I don't think it needs the protection any more but I have a custom printed one with a photograph of a scenic view I really like on it.
But as far as the front screen - I'm not very comfortable about using it naked even though it gets crammed in my pocket with lots of potentially scratching products a good part of every day.
I got the invisible shield and a bumper and thought it was pretty good - not nearly as problematic with using the screen as some had reported but after a little time the invisible shield seemed very hard to keep clean.
I took it off last August and have had the screen naked since then with not even a scratch. It works and feels much nicer and just about keeps itself clean - just amazing!
I still have the bumper as I like the grip it gives the phone and it really isn't too obtrusive and mine fits nice. I also have a back skin - I don't think it needs the protection any more but I have a custom printed one with a photograph of a scenic view I really like on it.
But as far as the front screen - I'm not very comfortable about using it naked even though it gets crammed in my pocket with lots of potentially scratching products a good part of every day.
Look at it this way....
If you have a naked person and drop them, they might break something.
If you put clothes on them, it'll cushion the fall a little.
If you have a naked person and drop them, they might break something.
If you put clothes on them, it'll cushion the fall a little.
Wirelessly posted (Mozilla/5.0 (iPhone; U; CPU iPhone OS 4_2_1 like Mac OS X; en-gb) AppleWebKit/533.17.9 (KHTML, like Gecko) Version/5.0.2 Mobile/8C148 Safari/6533.18.5)
Keep it naked unless you're really concerned about accidentally destroying it. If you do use the phone without a case, keep your keys and such in another pocket to avoid damage to the screen. Perhaps also invest in insurance either way.
Keep it naked unless you're really concerned about accidentally destroying it. If you do use the phone without a case, keep your keys and such in another pocket to avoid damage to the screen. Perhaps also invest in insurance either way.
I would suggest using some sort of protector for it, especially if you happen to be drunk and forget that it's on your lap while you're getting out of the car. I can assure you the iPhone 4 will not survive a drop onto a concrete parking lot.
Wirelessly posted (Mozilla/5.0 (iPhone; U; CPU iPhone OS 4_2_1 like Mac OS X; en-gb) AppleWebKit/533.17.9 (KHTML, like Gecko) Version/5.0.2 Mobile/8C148 Safari/6533.18.5)
White bumper on black iPhone looks great, but the retail price is horrendous.
White bumper on black iPhone looks great, but the retail price is horrendous.
sena ultraslim pouch. put it in the pouch when in your pocket, or on a desk. pop it out and use it naked. had mine since launch (canada) no scratches, dents, or scuffs and I don't have a beautiful phone in some ****** plastic or silicone case.
all cases are ugly, some are just less ugly than others.
all cases are ugly, some are just less ugly than others.
I don't think they suck. I had some problems the first time I installed a invisible shield, but if you take your time and do exactly as the instructions you shouldn't have any problems. The invisible shield on my 3gs stayed on for well over a year without peeling. I've tried static films on my iPod and iPhone 3gs but they didn't stay on for long...
I've installed Zagg on my iPads back and both front and back on my iPhone 4. No bubbles or trapped dust. The "orange peel" effect doesn't bother me on the small iPhone screen, but I guess it would be irritating on the iPad.
I still think Zagg offers the best type of protection if you don't want a full blown case. YMMV
for people that are really careful, caseless is fine. For those who are a little reckless ... always nice to be wearing protection
could not agree more
also you have to be careful + understand the fact that it might get a few light scratches here and there and its not the end of the world
It's definitely not dangerous. Use it how you want. If you are afraid you will drop it and damage it bad, case it. If your worried about minor scratches and fingerprints do a full body shield or just a screen protector will do with a thin case like an incase snap. Thin cases still keep the iPhones form factor.
I have a case I like, but it is spot on for what I wanted. All the other ones are ugly though, that I've seen compared to the Naked i4's. The case or protector I have on my i3G is cool, but it's just a rubber case and pulls the edge's of the screen protector's up. I use to have a snap together case that worked great, for keeping screen protector on.
Once I get my i4 though I'm going with this protector for the back, just because it looks awesome...
for people that are really careful, caseless is fine. For those who are a little reckless ... always nice to be wearing protection
Well said. Knock on wood, I'm very careful with all my iPhone. Thus, I don't have the need for a case. But a person who is prone to dropping their phone, it would probably serve their best interest to invest in a case for piece of mind.
I thought the same thing... the 'gorilla glass' will hold up to basic everyday use, as long as I don't put it in a pocket with keys, change, or anything else.
Day 3 of having my iP4, two hairline scratches on the front glass. Honestly...
Sure, the glass is stiff and hard (heh), but rigidity and hardness doesn't mean scratch resistance.
I picked up an invisibleshield full body. Looks perfect, and even hid the existing scratches, but it certainly won't protect it from a fall, which is why I opted for the free bumper.
Day 3 of having my iP4, two hairline scratches on the front glass. Honestly...
Sure, the glass is stiff and hard (heh), but rigidity and hardness doesn't mean scratch resistance.
I picked up an invisibleshield full body. Looks perfect, and even hid the existing scratches, but it certainly won't protect it from a fall, which is why I opted for the free bumper.
To me, the naked iPhone seems rather slippery and I use a case, currently a black Apple bumper, to help prevent me from dropping it.
Last edited:
