I sold an early 2008 15" mbp on ebay 2 weeks ago. I initially purchased the machine as a refurb from Apple and it has applecare through June 2011. Long story short, the new owner says he found 2 dead pixels on the screen that are driving him nuts. I never noticed them in the 2 years I had the computer. I told him to contact Apple and see what they say. I have seen a lot of discussion regarding dead pixels and while I have seen a few situations where people got their screens replaced with 1 dead pixel, it seems as if it takes 5 or more to perk up Apples ears. I have already invested the money I received for selling the mbp in a new Imac. So my question for you is if you were me, what would you do? Would you tell the new buyer that if Apple says you need 5 dead pixels and you only have 2, too bad? Would you offer them a discount -- how much? Would you take a return with the understanding that people will see the deal gone bad and you would now need to disclose 2 dead pixels? I want to be as fair as possible and make him happy, while at the same point, I don't want to try and re-sell it. I don't know how reasonable his concern is as I never noticed it. Thanks!