Sidebar Sidebar
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

New 2.8GHz 15" unibody mbp have the 1.5 GB/s SATA or 3.0?

I just got mine; it has 1.5. I'm keeping it that way until these problems are taken care of.
 
It comes in 1.5GB/s
I'm not messing with the firmware upgrade until the time comes to buy a SSD.
 
I received mine last week. It came shipped with 1.5Gb/s. There is the option to upgrade to 3.0Gb/s under the software update.
 
I upgraded it and enabled it to 3.0 Gb/s. But here's my problem, if I do upgrade my stock hdd to a 3.0 Gb/s hdd it causes problems. Maybe hardware its really a 1.5 Gb/s controller?

But then it is the same MCP79 AHCI and should be 3.0 Gb/s... Maybe an update is in order?!?
 
I think most of the issues are stemming from the use of third party harddrives.

If your stock one fails, exchange it for a new MBP.
 
From what I have gathered it sounds like the controller and the stock hard drives are both limited by firmware to 1.5, but with the 1.7 firmware you can open up the controller to 3.0.

Then if you add a hard drive that is not limited to 1.5 Gb/s you may or may not have problems. Some people are able to run with both the controller and hard drive (or ssd) at 3.0 and some are not, and have to put back in the 1.5 Gb/s stock drive. Some other people seem to be ok when they limit the 3rd party drives to 1.5 with either a jumper or 3rd party hard drive firmware.

My guess is that it could be a problem or variance in the controller chips that made Apple limit all of them to 1.5 for stability. Kind of like when you overclock a CPU and some can handle it and some can't.

So if that is true Apple kind of sidestepped the issue instead of totally fixing it, and that may be why they specifically said that they won't support the 3rd party drives, because they are all running at 3.0, which makes some of the controllers puke.

That is my theory of what is going on.

Hopefully it can be fully fixed because I was planning on getting a new macbook pro and ssd.
 
apothescary said:
From what I have gathered it sounds like the controller and the stock hard drives are both limited by firmware to 1.5, but with the 1.7 firmware you can open up the controller to 3.0.

Then if you add a hard drive that is not limited to 1.5 Gb/s you may or may not have problems. Some people are able to run with both the controller and hard drive (or ssd) at 3.0 and some are not, and have to put back in the 1.5 Gb/s stock drive. Some other people seem to be ok when they limit the 3rd party drives to 1.5 with either a jumper or 3rd party hard drive firmware.

My guess is that it could be a problem or variance in the controller chips that made Apple limit all of them to 1.5 for stability. Kind of like when you overclock a CPU and some can handle it and some can't.

So if that is true Apple kind of sidestepped the issue instead of totally fixing it, and that may be why they specifically said that they won't support the 3rd party drives, because they are all running at 3.0, which makes some of the controllers puke.

That is my theory of what is going on.

Hopefully it can be fully fixed because I was planning on getting a new macbook pro and ssd.
Click to expand...

It seems that apple is trying to just buy some time right now. Enabling the 3.0 Gb/s while making almost all 3rd party 3.0 Gb/s hdds virtually unusable.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.
Top Bottom
Back