Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

New 3G/Edge Icons

  • Yay

    Votes: 95 60.1%
  • Nay

    Votes: 63 39.9%

  • Total voters
    158

slicecom

macrumors 68020
Original poster
Aug 29, 2003
2,065
98
Toronto, Canada
Yay or Nay?

Yes, I realize this is the most pointless poll ever, but I don't care. :D

Old:

edge_in_china.jpg


iphone3gGPSMap.jpg


New:

IMG_0001.png


attachment.php
 
how about a comparison screenshot?
my backup before update is taking ages, guess i need 2.1... however it normally happens in minutes. hmm i wonder if this is bad news.
 
It was the first thing i noticed. The 3g icon that is. It also stays blue like the signal strength bars when texting. Neato
 
Definitely uglier. Since the space around the characters is now empty but the icon still has the same width, it now looks like a freak kerning accident. The idiot who did this should wear the dunce cap for a year.
 
I wish they'd kept the old one for Edge so it would be easier to discern the difference at the quickest glance. Overall, though, I don't really care as long as reception is better than it was. After two calls in areas that were previously trouble spots for me: so far, so good.
 
So? Why do you care what it looks like? Does it interfere with your "iPhone Experience"? God you guys are all so ridiculous. It's just a phone.
It was hyped and marketed as God's gift to mankind, but when anyone complains, it's suddenly "just a phone". Apple can't have the cake and eat it. If they want everyone to believe that it's the best thing ever, then it will also have to be subjected to intense scrutiny of epic proportions. No misaligned pixel, no 4 millisecond delay is too small to complain about.
 
I don't like just the letters.
3G or E is supposed to be an icon...
now it just combines with AT&T.

I mean, maybe Apple wants us to read it as AT&T 3G... but I personally don't like it.
 
Anybody seen the new GPRS icon?
It's just a small dot.
I'm not sure WHY my phone switched to GPRS for a little bit being that I live in downtown NYC... but whatever.

gprs.jpg
 
I quite like the look of the new 3G and EDGE icons, always thought the blue boxes stood out too much.
However the GPRS icon looks a bit odd. At least before it was in a blue box similar to the other icons so it was obviously for data. Whereas now it's just a dot which doesn't mean anything.
 
Yay or Nay?

Yes, I realize this is the most pointless poll ever, but I don't care. :D

New:
attachment.php

You posted my image without my consent. I will see you in court. Honestly. This is a violation of website T.O.S. to post copyrighted material that is not yours. I'm currently on the phone with MacRumors to get your info. I'm not letting this one go. This is serious!





just kidding.:)
 
I didn't even know there was a GPRS icon, when does that show up?
All I ever see is WiFi, EDGE or 3G.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.