Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
I love Apple Pencil but I feel like this is a category they could stand to retire a model or two. The incompatibility of models across disparate iPads is not like the Apple I know, and the latest Apple Pencil model with USB-C seems like a step backward to me without pressure sensitivity. It may have more features but I can't help but feel like it's muddying the water.
 
I wonder if the shorter pencil is perhaps because things are bring reorientated in some way, eg. a landscape camera, with the pencil on the side... probably not... but would be nice
 
I'm only interested in a new generation Apple Pencil if it can do everything my Wacom Bamboo stylus can do i.e act as a mouse substitute by being able to e.g swipe up from the bottom of my iPad Pro.
 
This is actually an interesting rumor. Not just because a new Pencil3, meh. But rather to see what tech and form factor Apple puts in a new pencil. If it was smaller and iPhone Pro Max length it would be very interesting. iPhone badly needs to support a pencil, and making an iPhone-size pencil would fire me up for iPhone 16 Pro Max possibilities: "one more thing..."

Some wag usually chimes in with a quote of Steve dissing on styli, but that is just silly, a different era; iPhone 15 Pro is not your grandfather's PDA. 2024 iPhones are entirely different devices, with users like me marking up 45 MP RAW captures on an iPhone in almost real time. Calloused XL hands do not make very good smartphone input devices.

As others have mentioned, potential usage with AVP is also very interesting.
The worst part about people parroting the Steve Jobs line is they don’t even understand it

Jobs’ argument was you shouldn’t NEED a stylus, not that you shouldn’t have one

Nobody in their right mind would argue artists should stick to finger painting, certain use cases are obviously more fit for a stylus, general usage is just not one of them

Everyone is just taking that whole thing out of context because they’re either desperate to prove the man wrong or prove that Apple has lost their way 🤷‍♂️
 
I'd like it to be double-ended, so I can flip it over to use as a rubber/eraser.

Apple Pencil holds way more potential than Apple has exploited.

Personally, I’d like it to be shorter and fatter. More like a sketch pencil than a drafting pen:

IMG_1407.png


Hexagonal body, grippy surface (not gloss.)

It should also have an “eraser” on one end for instant flipping and erasing.

Other additions could include swappable tips (already rumored) that give a more natural feel to things like markers and brushes.

Either a clicky switch or a Taptic Engine for tactile feedback.

Find My functionality with a little speaker so that it can make a sound when lost.

Some after market companies make screen protectors that make the pencil actually feel like a pencil when you use it. I doubt Apple would release a textured screen, but they may be able to make the pencil tip react more naturally or even use a Taptic Engine to make it rumble a little to replicate paper feel. (Yes, I know this would use too much battery to be practical. I’m just spitballing.)

Different color choices.

The pencil can and should be a lot more than it is right now.
 
From this, I gather Apple has penciled in some new ideas, most of which will erase what we think of digital art. Yes, details are sketchy, but this is the conclusion I've drawn, based on details. Hopefully, they can ink a deal with disturbers and get this thing out quickly.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: HandsomeDanNZ
The worst part about people parroting the Steve Jobs line is they don’t even understand it

Jobs’ argument was you shouldn’t NEED a stylus, not that you shouldn’t have one

Nobody in their right mind would argue artists should stick to finger painting, certain use cases are obviously more fit for a stylus, general usage is just not one of them

Everyone is just taking that whole thing out of context because they’re either desperate to prove the man wrong or prove that Apple has lost their way 🤷‍♂️
Jobs was referring to the ability to use and navigate the phone using a finger, and he was correct. you don't need a stylus for that, unless you design crap interfaces like MS did prior to the iPhone launch.
Its odd how some people don't seem able to comprehend this.

Anyway on the pencil, I have been using gen2 since launch without issues. Great accessory and look forward to seeing what they have [hopefully not glossy......].
 
  • Like
Reactions: Surf Monkey
Jobs was referring to the ability to use and navigate the phone using a finger, and he was correct. you don't need a stylus for that, unless you design crap interfaces like MS did prior to the iPhone launch.
Its odd how some people don't seem able to comprehend this.

Anyway on the pencil, I have been using gen2 since launch without issues. Great accessory and look forward to seeing what they have [hopefully not glossy......].

The original stylus solutions that Jobs was talking about existed so that people could poke at itty bitty interface elements that were originally designed for bigger screens. Using a “stylus” to do things like sketch? Totally different situation. Sketching with your finger is a very poor experience. Sketching with a pencil is a great experience.
 
I guess we still have to wait a few weeks for the iPad launch press release. This anticipation is killing me I just want updated mini 7.
I was hoping this would be like that time where Apple fired off a press release a day a few days in a row. Unless iOS 17.4 counts, I guess not.
 
Wonder if a “smaller size” points toward potential iPhone Pro functionality?
Would make a nice differentiator between the iPhone and iPhone Pro lines. iPhone screens are large enough to justify Pencil comparability. It’s a digital version of a pen/pencil + Fields Notes.
 
The Apple Pencil 3 will work with the top half of the 12.9" iPad Pro, while the Apple Pencil 2.5 works with the bottom half and the green, black and blue iPad Airs. Yellow, pink and starburst colored iPads will need the Apple Pencil 2, unless you have the models with 256 Gigs of storage, in which case you need the Apple Pencil 4. The Apple Pencil 4 is also what you will need for the iPad mini 5 and the smaller iPad Pro Model.

Got it?
Come on, the pencil will not have 256 Gigs or storage for quite a few years yet!
 
Apple Pencil holds way more potential than Apple has exploited.

Personally, I’d like it to be shorter and fatter. More like a sketch pencil than a drafting pen:

View attachment 2355809

Hexagonal body, grippy surface (not gloss.)

It should also have an “eraser” on one end for instant flipping and erasing.

Other additions could include swappable tips (already rumored) that give a more natural feel to things like markers and brushes.

Either a clicky switch or a Taptic Engine for tactile feedback.

Find My functionality with a little speaker so that it can make a sound when lost.

Some after market companies make screen protectors that make the pencil actually feel like a pencil when you use it. I doubt Apple would release a textured screen, but they may be able to make the pencil tip react more naturally or even use a Taptic Engine to make it rumble a little to replicate paper feel. (Yes, I know this would use too much battery to be practical. I’m just spitballing.)

Different color choices.

The pencil can and should be a lot more than it is right now.
You will be surprised how much adding haptic feedback to the pencil can make a difference. On my Surface Laptop Studio I get haptic feedback while using my Slim Pen 2 and at first I thought it would be a gimmick, but it really does add the feel of friction and makes it feel like you are writing on paper.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Surf Monkey
You will be surprised how much adding haptic feedback to the pencil can make a difference. On my Surface Laptop Studio I get haptic feedback while using my Slim Pen 2 and at first I thought it would be a gimmick, but it really does add the feel of friction and makes it feel like you are writing on paper.

I’d love that for Apple Pencil. It’s way too sterile feeling in its current iteration.
 
  • Like
Reactions: derekamoss
Eagerly waiting to see the capabilities of the new Pencil. Hope Apple won't increase the prices.
 
Eagerly waiting to see the capabilities of the new Pencil. Hope Apple won't increase the prices.
Of course they won't! That's insane... Apple would NEVER do that.... =)

But my guess is instead of raising prices on pen the just tac it onto the iPad
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.