Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

What do you think of a move by Apple to go with all built-in iSights?

  • Good move. I've been wanting built-in iSights in the Apple Displays

    Votes: 150 33.6%
  • Bad move... the external version had its uses

    Votes: 146 32.7%
  • Whatever... I'll just get another brand's webcam

    Votes: 11 2.5%
  • Already have an iSight (built-in or external)

    Votes: 139 31.2%

  • Total voters
    446
  • Poll closed .
No more external iSights leaves Mac mini users out in the cold, since they're only option is to buy a relatively-expensive ACD, thus negating the whole cost benefit of buying a Mac mini in the first place. :(

As for new ACDs with built-in iSights, sure why not! Apple can release a nice 53" LCD display at MWSF which can be integrated into the iTV unit and, via Front Row 2.0 w/ integrated iChat, you'll be able to video chat with your friends and family from the comfort of your couch - and all in HD! :D :cool:
 
also curious if the specs will change. i assume the line will be HD. also, will they introduce any more sizes other than the current 20", 23" and 30"?

Weren't there mumblings of a 17" being re-introduced for the budget consumer?
 
Weren't there mumblings of a 17" being re-introduced for the budget consumer?

That was from DigiTimes :rolleyes:

No standard DVI cable (especially dual-link) provides for USB connectivity.

You are correct. However, remember that Apple's current displays use one combined cord that breaks out at the bottom into power, DVI, USB2, and Firewire. So, the connections are already there for an iSight to work.
 
Poor, poor decision by Apple. I'm studying abroad this summer, and I was hoping my girlfriend and I could get iSights for our Powerbooks so we could video chat, but since they're being integrated, and with normal iSights being discontinued, this could be a real hinderance. First bad decision I've seen from Apple in a long time, though.
 
That was from DigiTimes :rolleyes:

Oh, that's right. Nevermind then, my bad :D

Poor, poor decision by Apple. I'm studying abroad this summer, and I was hoping my girlfriend and I could get iSights for our Powerbooks so we could video chat, but since they're being integrated, and with normal iSights being discontinued, this could be a real hinderance. First bad decision I've seen from Apple in a long time, though.

It's only been a year since they've been integrated into laptops, right? You would think Apple would continue to carry them for existing PB and other laptop owners.
 
I hope this isn't true. I have a MacBook Pro but am getting a Mac Pro next year and wanted a camera for that. I know Apple is into a lot of integration of components but as someone else said how about the Mac Mini's as well. If Apple builds it into their displays fine but most people go with non Apple brand monitors. As well, are there any 3rd party cameras that work well with Macs?

Yes. The best quality "iSight" camera I have is my Sony mini DV camera. It's a darned expensive webcam but better then DVD quality. I think anything that works with Quicktime will work.
 
Bad Decision

Adding iSite to HD Displays is OK but discontinuing the stand-alone iSite is a bad idea.

Stand-alone iSite cameras have a lot more functionality when they are not embedded in a display. You can put them on servos and use them for survelliance. You can use them with adapters on telescopes for astro-movies, sun-spot studies, etc. etc. The uses are only limited by the creative mind of the user.

Stuck in a display they are religated to dumb video phone status. Something that really isn't all that valuable.
 
Poor, poor decision by Apple. I'm studying abroad this summer, and I was hoping my girlfriend and I could get iSights for our Powerbooks so we could video chat, but since they're being integrated, and with normal iSights being discontinued, this could be a real hinderance. First bad decision I've seen from Apple in a long time, though.

I head the decision was made for them by the EU's ban on lead. A lot of electronics can no longer be sold in Europe. This is a good thing because all of this stuff ends up in landfills and the metals leach into the water. If the ban takes effect in Jan 07 and Macworld is in Jan 07 that could explain why the new replacement is not announced yet, they are waiting.

Credit goes to Aple managment for running the inventory to zero right at 2006 year end.

If you really need one now just buy some non-Apple brand webcam
 
The standalone iSight that I have seems to do a much better job than any of the builtin's not sure why, but people can always tell on the other end when I'm suing one or the other (my wife's MB or my PB with external iSIght). I think building a camera into a Apple display is a a liitle tacky... I always saw apple's displays as "high end" for pro's. Jaming a little camera into the top of the display just seems like a low end thing to do in my optinion because the quality of the camera can't be that great. Rambling...
 
Guess I got lucky a month ago when I walked into an Apple store and there were about 6 iSight boxes.

My mom falls into the category of macmini owner who wants to vid chat with her grandkids in another state.
 
No more external iSights leaves Mac mini users out in the cold, since they're only option is to buy a relatively-expensive ACD, thus negating the whole cost benefit of buying a Mac mini in the first place. :(

why not get a third-party webcam instead? they do work with the mac, right?
 
why not get a third-party webcam instead? they do work with the mac, right?

Yes, Firewire webcams will work out of the box, whilst USB webcam require a shareware Driver that you can find on macupdate or versiontracker. Such webcams are also often signficiantly cheaper than the iSight.
 
Yes, Firewire webcams will work out of the box, whilst USB webcam require a shareware Driver that you can find on macupdate or versiontracker. Such webcams are also often signficiantly cheaper than the iSight.

I think Logitech also provides drivers for several of their cameras.
 
It's good that Apple's including iSights in its displays (saying that the rumors are true). That way, Mac Minis & Pros can have them. But, having a stand-alone iSight would also be good for those people who don't want/can't have the new Apple display. Hopefully, the built-in iSIght would be better than those shipping now. Higher res, autofocusing w/ hardware, and able to manually shut it off.

Also, I hope the new displays also have an IR port & remote so that Mac Pros can use Frontrow, too, if they wanted. I know, many people who'd buy a Mac Pro might not use Front row, but at least have it there if they do.

I also hope the new displays have higher resolution, too. Just so those who need/want higher resolutions have them.
 
It might actually be smart for Apple to discontinue iSight. They've had cameras in their laptops and iMacs for a year now, and if they go into displays they probably assume that they've already sold as many standalone iSights as they're going to sell, for where its cost effective to make them.

Not to mention that anyone else that wants iSight can just get a third party Firewire webcam. Apple may even begin carrying other ones in their retail stores.

However, I also wouldn't discount the possibility that Apple revives iSight at MacWorld in a refreshed form. Maybe they just ran out too quickly and don't want to make more of them since they're producing the new one.

As for the refreshed displays, here's hoping to they price them competitively.
 
Also, I hope the new displays also have an IR port & remote so that Mac Pros can use Frontrow, too, if they wanted. I know, many people who'd buy a Mac Pro might not use Front row, but at least have it there if they do.

If they do all this, I hope they're fairly clever in how they handle cabling so that this thing doesn't have to plug into six different places on the Mac side....
 
although the built in isight is better for conferences, that is all it is good for...

i have a built in and a regular isight and i find that it is often convenient to switch to the other isight...

i sometimes put it in front of the widescreen tv and videoconference from the couch.
 
i hope they have isight and isight-less versions available if they do. why would you need 2 isights if you have dual displays?

also i hope they intro a 17" model with 1440x900 resolution at a price point of $250-300.
 
Float the rumor ...

I'll float the rumor that there will be a holder/charger built into future displays for the "iPhone" and ITS camera will serve as an iSight for Apple displays and for dektops.
 
This is unfortunate for Mac Mini users on a budget. The Mac mini + CinemaDisplay combo is hardly a bargain for budget hunters. That means that Mac mini users will be left without an economically viable iChat A/V solution.

That strikes me as rather unfair.
While you may rightly be disappointed, calling it "unfair" is a wrong. This is not a matter of fairness.

Check out this $60 webcam.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.