Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
People are complaining now that their iPhone4 won't support certain features like FaceTime over cellular and turn-by-turn navigation. Wait until the iPhone5 is announced and iPhone4S owners will start complaining of missing out on certain features. That just how Apple operates, if you want all the greatest you gotta keep upgrading your device every year!
 
I'm sure Apple has tested iOS 6 on the aging 2009 iPhone 3GS hardware and decided it would NOT be he best product if they added a bunch of new features.

The best the iPhone 3GS could possibly ever be was in 2009.

So how do you explain the iPad 1 fiasco? It certainly has all the capabilities of the iPhone 3GS, yet there is no iOS 6, even a crippled iOS 6 like the 3GS has. Apple tested it...? I find that one hard to believe, but maybe I'm just not as gullible as others.
 
Well I guess it's good im due for an update come October since my iPhone 4 doesn't get the turn-by-turn, which I actually wanted most.

Why not save yourself a lot of money and purchase a gps app instead, I have the navigon one, works really well.
 
Well according to www.apple.com.au, facetime over 3G will be available for poeple with the iPhone 4

according to this from the apple ios 6 page facetime is not available for the iphone 4. :mad:
"FaceTime over a cellular network requires iPhone 4S or iPad (3rd generation) with cellular data capability. Carrier data charges may apply. FaceTime is not available in all countries."
 
I knew eventually Apple would abandon supporting my device, didn't think they'd downgrade it though.

Maps is now a completely different app, plain and simple. I enjoy Street View myself, but as a platform Maps is moving in a positive direction now. You can't expect them to keep every little feature (with a Google backend). BTW, can anyone comment on whether or not the 3D views are detailed enough to substitute Street View?

If a particular feature is that important, dont upgrade. People act as if their current products will self-destruct when iOS 6 launches.
 
Wow people are still bringing this up? Of course all features aren't supported. Be lucky they're supported at all (look at Android). 3GS is slow as it is, let alone being able to run 3D maps.
 
Welcome to having hardware dictate what you can do with your software. If it doesn't perform really well in testing, Apple won't let it out in the wild or else you'll have X million complainers. [Begin rants on "Apple updates its products too fast!"]

I can assure you that FaceTime over 3G on an iPhone 4 works just fine..

Also, no Siri on iPad 2?? Why?? Now there's just no excuse for that.. (other than "well we want you to upgrade your iPad every year, silly!")
 
I'm going to sign off for the evening, but I appreciate everyone commenting.

I'd just leave with this thought.

Can there be any real doubt that was a decision made by suits? Where is the old Apple where the hackers and designers had the final say and not the bean counters?

I'm not a Jobs fanboy, I know he was looking to make money; however, I think he realized that making the best product is what counted most. I have yet to see the decision by Tim Cook where I can say design was paramount.
 
No FaceTime over 3G and turn-by-turn navigation on an iPhone 4?
I feel ridiculously ripped off.
 
Cool, now Apple gets a bit of the fragmentation that we mock Android for having. And just as they have countless devices to cover, now does iOS, and it's looking a bit murky.
 
Really

Seriously, what in the world is preventing FaceTime from being used over 3G with the iPhone 4? Seriously....what? You smell that, smells like bull. Bullfrog that is.
 
what most iphone 4 owners are failing to realize (yes I own a 4) is that this 6.0 software isn't coming out until the fall which is the same time the new iphone should be released so you won't be missing anything. So you 4 owns gotta relax given that most of us 4 owners got our phones in 2010 your due for an upgrade anyway
 
This is why my relationship with Apple is a love/hate relationship. I mean they have great hardware and software, but every update while I still own my iPhone for I just get more and more bent over and mad. :mad:
That doesn't sound right, how can you be sure it's related to your phone, did you maybe get the update procedures from the wrong website. Have you maybe been following the up yours date guidelines?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
They better have some amazing NEW features for the next iPhone announcement...

it surely does, hence the iP4 peeps are being left out for so many features which it could have had.

Remember how iPhone & iPod touch 2nd gen were not totally updated to multitask & a wallpaper background for the icons? that was done even when those devices mattered but iPhone 4 was launched & the contract for the 2nd gen iPhones was about to expire.
 
No FaceTime over 3G and turn-by-turn navigation on an iPhone 4?
I feel ridiculously ripped off.

Maybe you shouldn't?, your phone still does what it did when you bought it.

Its nice to get the upgrades in functionality, but I can't ignore the fact that my phone still does what its supposed to do when I purchased it. One thing that does annoy me tho is the major slowdowns new iOS versions always seem to bring. That I think is a good reason to feel ridiculously ripped off.
 
The 4S actually has the HSDPA+ which gives it "4G like" capabilities. The same is said for the iPad 3 which also has LTE (and HSDPA+). Therefore, I would imagine that the limitation for the codec that they are using to transmit video over the SS7 network is most likely the reason for them only allowing FaceTime on those 2 devices. They should have just come out and said, FaceTime over 4G. It is quite misleading.

That's only for the AT&T 4S. The Verizon and Sprint 4S models are plain 3G. Unless you think that Facetime over cellular will be an AT&T only feature for the 4S.

Considering I get frequently get as fast or faster speeds on my iPad 2 than my iPhone 4S, I don't think the 4G only theory holds much water. The only reason they won't add FaceTime over cellular to anything but the current iPhone and iPad is to sell more devices. If they had announced the iPhone 5 at WWDC, I'm sure they would have limited Facetime over Cellular to the iPhone 5 only and not added it to the 4S.
 
To have a proper answer please do:

1. Get a degree in the field of science, math and engineering
2. Become an expert in what you do
3. Apply for work at apple
4. Become a leading technical expert at apple
5. be part of the creative team that decides what is good and what is not for ios and apple hardware

Then you'll have the answer to the question that you posed above.


I kindly disagree.. You do not need to have a degree or become an expert in the hardware to know that the decision to not have FaceTime over 3G for the iPhone 4 is being driven by AT&T... All those devices would stress the network (imagine iOS 6 launch day) Also, it seems that in other countries, as posted earlier in the thread, the service is available for the iPhone 4.
 
Last edited:
Maybe Apple is limiting features to get people to upgradem but I doubt it. More likely, there is real reason for each one.

1st, the iphone 4 will still run iOS6 and its a 2 year old phone, 3 years when iOS6 comes out, with a processor that is 2 generations behind assuming the next iphone will debut with iOS6.

No flyover/turn by turn: Its processor intensive. You still get maps, and the same views you always had.

No Siri: Iphone 4 never suppprted Siri.

No 3G facetime: this one sucks, but I imagine its to prevent network overload from giving it to both phones. Might have been part of the deal to allow it. Regardless of how you feel, legal 3G facetime video calling is a big deal and it must have been tricky for Apple to negotiate.

Is it planned obsolensence? Maybe. But I think its silly to think Apple is still going to try and roll features out to 2 year old hardware and push it past its limit. Its a phone, not a computer.

All my apple products have lasted longer and had way more OS updates than any of my non Apple gear did back in the day. I used to be jonesing for a new phone after 1 year and a new computer after 18-24 months (and thats with fastidious care). My phone is 2 years old, I feel no need to upgrade, my laptop is 2 years old, and going strong and will be through Mountain Lion.
Complain all you want about "planned obsolesence"; my experience has not been that; Apple stuff support is pretty consistent as long as you stay somewhat current. And if you have old stuff, the cut offs are clear. There is no mucking about trying to get Airplay on G4 cubes and such.

Explain the Ipad2
 
What on earth is preventing FaceTime over cellular on the iPhone 4?

Exactly! They should enable it considering Facetime was introduced with the iPhone 4 and they said it was only Wifi at the time but that 3G support would come in the future. So iPhone 4 owners have been rightfully waiting for it. Kinda dishonest me thinks... they should reconsider. Other features like turn by turn navigation and flyover, I understand they might need more power. But 3G Facetime... come on.

Will someone write to Tim? :p
 
I hope that Apple or third parties can find ways to bring additional new features of iOS 6 to the iPhone 4.
 
It's just crazy. People are getting things for free without paying a dime, the same day the flagship phone is getting the new OS, and is complaining that it's not good enough...

When it's lucky soemtimes for the Android guys to barely get a patch/fix, let alone a full OS upgrade. And if they are getting it, probably some half year afterwards.

SW development is a very expensive business. There are companies that runs on making $ on SW alone. Apple is giving this out for FREE, to a 3 years old phone called the 3GS. the iPhone 4 is surprise surprise, a 2 years old phone, even older than the GSII.

And all these talk about Android phones being much superior. Spec-wise, probably when it's brand new, especially when pitted against an iPhone that's half years or more in. I have yet to seen anyone carrying around an Android that's over 2 years old and is using the latest Apps. The Android owner probably got sick of it and upgraded already. Don't even mention the resale value and liquididty of an Android phone compared to a used iPhone.

I have a co-worker whose happily using 3GS on iOS5 and the Euro 2012 app. I asked him, heck iOS5 must be slow as hell on the 3GS. And he said, "Nope, it runs faster than when it was on iOS4". Upgrading his phone haven't came across his mind at all. A company that tries to optimize the latest OS against a 3 years old phone which they are barely getting any $$ at all. That's customer satisfaction.

Giving you the newest feature meant for the flagship to your 3 years old phone is called ripping shareholders off.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.