Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
I think it's fairly certain, at this point, that the TS rumor is a hoax. But that doesn't mean we can't discuss what we'd like/dislike about such a keyboard.

The issue of the iPod blocking the screen, is a serious issue. Also, people who put keyboards in drawers (like me) may end up unable to close the drawer with the iPod attached - a substantial inconvenience. Maybe put the dock-well on a hinge so the iPod can be angled down (or even parallel to the desk.)

OdduWan's concept is a possibility. The only problem with it is that ipods come in many sizes. You'd need some kind of variable-size well that could hold full-size iPods of various generations, minis and nanos. Maybe if the well was on the side (left or right) instead of in the middle, then some kind of sliding/expanding shelf could be used.

In terms of convenience, if the above problem could be solved nicely, I'd love it. It would eliminate some cable clutter without putting yet another box on my desktop.

Another interesting idea is the possibility of using an iPod as a secondary display for Mac applications. It would be really cool if you could use a docked iPod's screen to show the kind of information you'd like to always have visible without taking screen real-estate from apps (iChat buddy list? system stats? last few lines of the system log? The Weather Dashboard widget? etc.) Perhaps also for application-specific stuff (like your health/armor/ammo status in Doom-like games?)

A tiny screen like the nano's wouldn't be too useful for this sort of thing, but the huge display of the video iPod would be great. And secondary-display information would certainly be more useful than the generic "do not disconnect" icon.
 
i too doubt this to be true.

i imagine a new keyboard would have usb2.0 (which to me is better than an ipod dock) and an IR receiver.

the second would be mainly for mac pro / older mac owners to allow for front row support.

since apple said front row will be part of leopard's "full package" it'd make sense!

why not just have a keyboard sized touch panel with IR and ipod dock built in?. that way apple can create a new form for the standard keyboard with no worry for loss of space. This would be great. though the only thing i really want is a space bar with two contact points! i can't tellyou howmany times the damn spacebar feels like it's beenpushed but i doesnt register. arrrrrrrg

but seriously thought if we get a new keyboard with "dock" and there is rumor of touch screens and 17" monitors, could we be looking at a dockable tablet.... like the first power books, only 100lbs lighter.


I expect apple to take the keyboerd the way of ipod. so fluid and fast and simple. it would fit in great with all the shortcuts other goodies apple provides us.
 
why not just have a keyboard sized touch panel with IR and ipod dock built in?.
As long as there are mechanical keys above that touch panel.

As a touch-typist, I can tell you that I would hate typing on a completely flat surface. (Cringing as I remember the Atari 400....) I find today's soft-touch keyboards to be annoying enough. (I like the old IBM-style buckling-spring keyboards - the ones where the keys travel a lot and have positive audible and tactile feedback.)
 
If an Apple keyboard came with an iPod dock I would buy in a second.

The keyboard I really want is that Russian designed Optimus Keyboard that thing is sweet.

I am having a flash back to the "Mac Mini with a Dock" and we still haven't seen that .....
 
The keyboard I really want is that Russian designed Optimus Keyboard that thing is sweet.
Keep waiting. According to posts from the Optimus blog, that artist-concept keyboard is still a long way coming.

In a year, they will have a stripped-down version (no function keys on the left side, displays not on every key, B&W LCD instead of color OLED, etc.) And it seems it will be very expensive (pre-orders on December 12 for $1200. A sub-$1000 price when it ships around September-ish.)

They've got a great concept, but I don't think we'll ever see the product depicted by their artist's conception, and if it ever does ship, it looks like it will end up costing more than a Mac Pro.
 
having my 4G ipod sticking out of my keyboard is a bad thing. looks stupid, blocks the view to the monitor and when you move the keyboard your ipod falls out. i don't think this rumor is true.

Yeah, I like to move my keyboard around...put it in my lap, e.g. Putting an ipod in there?? Makes no sense at all to me either.
 
Keep waiting. According to posts from the Optimus blog, that artist-concept keyboard is still a long way coming.

In a year, they will have a stripped-down version (no function keys on the left side, displays not on every key, B&W LCD instead of color OLED, etc.) And it seems it will be very expensive (pre-orders on December 12 for $1200. A sub-$1000 price when it ships around September-ish.)

They've got a great concept, but I don't think we'll ever see the product depicted by their artist's conception, and if it ever does ship, it looks like it will end up costing more than a Mac Pro.

Yeah I've heard that it's along way off either way it's a totally killer concept and I hope they licence it for other companies to produce like Logitech, Apple, etc for them to make. If it's ever released I will buy one.
 
There is that pesky NDA Apple supposedly made them sign. When there are only ten (or fewer) of you, you'd best not break that. (Of course, they do seem to have told their friends, but that may have been in the milliseconds before Apple contacted them and before they could get a pic sent off.)

Apple can't make anyone sign an NDA. There is one thing that makes you lose a trade secret: If you mess up and don't keep it secret, then it is no trade secret anymore.

Obviously Apple can offer you some money (or offer a free upgrade from a G4 tower to a quad Xeon Mac Pro or similar) to convince you to sign an NDA, but they can't force you.
 
Keep waiting. According to posts from the Optimus blog, that artist-concept keyboard is still a long way coming.

In a year, they will have a stripped-down version (no function keys on the left side, displays not on every key, B&W LCD instead of color OLED, etc.) And it seems it will be very expensive (pre-orders on December 12 for $1200. A sub-$1000 price when it ships around September-ish.)

They've got a great concept, but I don't think we'll ever see the product depicted by their artist's conception, and if it ever does ship, it looks like it will end up costing more than a Mac Pro.

ouch. i remember reading an interview somewhere with one of the guys saying they hoped that full keyboard for $250. but now a cut down version with fewer OLED keys? cop out! :eek: ;)

i'd love that concept one. it'll not happen any time soon, but i want one. :rolleyes:
 
maybe...

maybe it is just apple trying to cover up hence anonmys source. I think that it is usually apple trying to cover up...

just my opinion
 
Yeah, I don't think Apple would make something like this... an iPod sticking out of your keyboard is a terrible idea... would constantly get in the way... eg: when reaching for the mouse, etc...

Maybe it's a ploy by Apple to get an idea of what consumers (like those eager enough to read Apple rumors day in and day out) might think about a keyboard with an ipod dock built into it. Let's think:

Apple "accidentally" sends out 10 dock+keyboards out to customers who need keyboard replacements. Not really alot of people that got issued the "mistaken" keyboard. But enough for word to get around, but yet not enough to lose count/control of who has the keyboard, and trying to get them back. Apple execs (or who-have-you) tune in to sites like macrumors.com and see what people think about having an ipod dock+keyboard combo and see if there might be market for such a thing and if they think so, taking comments like the one above and using it to improve on their unreleased product...

either that or I'm just really paranoid :confused:
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.