After having owned the MacBook Air and two MacBook Pros (my current machine) I would have to say I definitely prefer the MacBook Pro keyboard layout. That being said, I don't hate the new layout Apple is using. Whatever the decision is, I'm sure it was well thought out. If I had my way it would stay the same, but I'm only one person so it's not a huge deal I suppose. 🙂
I like the look of my MB keyboard, but most of the time I prefer the feel of my MBP. But I just upgraded so hopefully this MBP will last me for at least a few more years to come... and who knows what they'll look like by then.
after using the chiclet keys on the white macbook, i definitely prefer the old MBP/powerbook-styled keyboard WAY BETTER....the tactile response is much better, and it's also way quieter overall for touch typists....the MB keyboard was way too noisy and plastic-y in my opinion...
Well, if Sony is any indication, the market is adapting MBA-style keyboards. They plan to incorporate the Sony TZ-style keyboard in more models set to launch soon. The new Z model is going to be the centerpiece of the line, so I suspect Apple will follow suit.