Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
I like how Apple solves many problems now using Machine Learning like Intelligent Tracking Prevention.

The first approach was to have build automated prevention, which doesn't work with trackers.

The second approach is make a huge list of trackers and block all of them, but of course requires a team of people that update that list all the time (Ghostery).

And now we have machine learning, combining automation and building lists. How can one ever beat that?
How did you get Ghostery installed?

I checked the site, and it’s very outdated. It’s for Safari 5.4.10, Chrome 7.2.2, and Firefox 7.2.2. On my Mac, I have Safari 10.1.1, Chrome 57.0.2987.133, and Firefox 53.0.3.
 
Apple claims that in its current form Safari is the fastest web browser in macOS when compared with Chrome and Firefox,
I don't think that's correct. Unless I misunderstood, they were talking about the new version of Safari when they compared its speed with the competition.
 
This looks like some amazing updates to my favorite browser. Site-by-site setting are great addition.

Wish they would add a universal cookie crumbles on a timer, e.g. Every day/week/month delete all cookies and site data. This way you know you are getting a clean slate.
 
welcome addition especially for browsing terrible websites such as macworld.com. Those guys became absolute idiots in regards to their website design. well, the content is actually on par thinking about it.
 
This looks like some amazing updates to my favorite browser. Site-by-site setting are great addition.

Wish they would add a universal cookie crumbles on a timer, e.g. Every day/week/month delete all cookies and site data. This way you know you are getting a clean slate.
Yeah, that would be great. It's a pain having to manually clean out cookies every few months. Besides, when you keep cookies for that long, you get pretty used to not having to log into sites, and then all of a sudden, you have to start logging into sites after you dump your browser's cookies. Though, I should probably start using a password manager one of these days.
 
How did you get Ghostery installed?

I checked the site, and it’s very outdated.
Who cares. It works and the tracker list gets updated regularly.

And I seem to remember that they made a change to Ghostery, that wasn't very privacy friendly.
Ah, found this on addons.mozilla.org:

"First, I don't understand why I'm forced to store the settings in the cloud.
Second, it significantly slows down the browser during its start."

So, having the old version on Safari seems to actually be a good thing, ;)
[doublepost=1497281104][/doublepost]
Wish they would add a universal cookie crumbles on a timer, e.g. Every day/week/month delete all cookies and site data. This way you know you are getting a clean slate.
That's what tracking prevention does.

Though only for sites you don't directly interact with; you probably wouldn't want to continually lose settings for sites you actually use.
 
Marketers can get the data they need without needing to track everyone even those who don't opt in. If you are blocked from using a website until you opt into tracking, that's fair game IMO.

I wish I could reliably use Safari for work purposes but it's just not better than Chrome for development. Otherwise I would use it exclusively.
 
Last edited:
What ? Companies, Marketers, Governments, Agencies have been using the Internet to spy on us ? No, no, you are all paranoid. Everything is running fine in this world. Maybe a few Chinese and Russian hackers but we can always increase tax so that we attack them before they do, can't we?
 
  • Like
Reactions: JMacHack
This will continue to be a battle -- the advertisers will not take this sitting down. MarketingLand published "How Apple’s Intelligent Tracking Prevention works & why Google/Facebook could benefit most" two days after the keynote. As noted in this WebKit blog article "Intelligent Tracking Prevention", there is a 24-hour window where cookies will be more widely available. The marketeers will exploit this window -- count on it.

It is just Safari users and only on Macs. Probably most people use other browsers and Safari people can fly under the radar and enjoy a better web experience.
 
Who cares. It works and the tracker list gets updated regularly.

And I seem to remember that they made a change to Ghostery, that wasn't very privacy friendly.
Ah, found this on addons.mozilla.org:

"First, I don't understand why I'm forced to store the settings in the cloud.
Second, it significantly slows down the browser during its start."

So, having the old version on Safari seems to actually be a good thing, ;)
[doublepost=1497281104][/doublepost]
That's what tracking prevention does.

Though only for sites you don't directly interact with; you probably wouldn't want to continually lose settings for sites you actually use.
I was able to get it installed in Chrome, but not in Safari. But that's alright since I'm starting to use Chrome more than Safari, largely because it actually loads pages faster than Safari.
[doublepost=1497282684][/doublepost]
It is just Safari users and only on Macs. Probably most people use other browsers and Safari people can fly under the radar and enjoy a better web experience.
Well, 80% of the market is Windows, and most folks on Windows aren't going to use Safari because the Windows version is horribly out-of-date. Some Windows users use IE just out of habit. Others use Firefox or Chorme. Of those three, I'd say Chrome is the best. But if you want an open-source browser, you can use Chromium, which is Google's open-source version of Chrome.
[doublepost=1497282876][/doublepost]With all this talk about web browsers, I'm starting to think about using a password manager to make my switch from Safari to Chrome a little easier. Are there any cross-platform password managers which don't store passwords in "the cloud"?
 
I concur, especially about the speed. Even on my 2011 MacBook Pro, Chrome is faster than Safari. I thought Apple’s software was supposed to be optimized for Macs, but I guess Google beat them. A couple other great things about Chrome are that it’s available for pretty much any mobile or desktop OS, and there’s an open-source version of it called Chromium which can be easily installed from a Linux repository.
I think it's because Apple's intentionally trying to keep Safari's battery usage low. Chrome is fast, but it's a huge battery hog honestly.
 
If you go to the Security part of Safari’s Preferences, you can specify which sites you want to allow to use plugins and WebGL. You can even just set it so it has to ask every time a site wants to use either WebGL or plugins (i.e. Flash).

WebGL has nothing to do with video autoplay. Furthermore, there is no way to block HTML5 video autoplay.
 
These are nice additions to help with privacy. What we really need is an anti-fingerprinting technology. Ad trackers have moved to just fingerprinting your entire computer and using that to track you. Be great if Safari had a feature that would randomly change values (Fonts reported installed, CPU speed GPU type, even OS) so your fingerprint is constantly changing.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 0008652
All this privacy focused stuff seems good and the more Apple adds to Safari that can tailor it uniquely to how it should work the more users won't need to clutter up their browsers by using extensions/add-ons to do a "second poor" man's job.
 
So happy this auto-play nonsense is about to be blocked.

Haha CNN, Bleacher Report, ESPN, etc...
 
While Intelligent Tracking Protection is a nice idea I wonder how well it works in practice? I suspect it won't take long for advertisers to find ways to circumvent it...
Worse yet is that Apple has put these webpage/websites on notice so they will have 4 months to find a way around this and trust me they will.

It will be interesting once High Sierra rolls out because it would be a major accomplish by Apple if they can make browsing even faster because generally when you put as blockers and other blocking stuff turned on it generally slows down your browsing not speeds it up.
 
Last edited:
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.