Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

LukeAdonis

macrumors newbie
Original poster
Anyone else agree?

anyoneelseagree.jpg
 
Horrible? Horrible? Horrible? Don't you think that's maybe just a tiny exagerration? I mean, it's unibody polycarbonate, it's probably got one of the better builds out there.
 
Only difference is that iPod nano is anodized aluminum and the Lumia is crappy plastic.

I used a Nokia Lumia 800 for a month. Couldn't go back to my iPhone 4. It's really fast and the build quality is on par with HTC One X. You don't know anything about build quality.
 
I made this statement before (about the Lumia 900, but they are essentially the same thing) and got ripped into just like the OP. LOL. Glad to see I am not the only one that sees the similarities. To me they are about as similar as any tablet is to Apple. If this phone is a big hit I am interested to see if there are any ridiculous lawsuites coming from Apple's end.
 
Only difference is that iPod nano is anodized aluminum and the Lumia is crappy plastic.

It's made from a single piece of polycarbonate, the stuff they use to make glass bulletproof. iPhone on the other hand can crack when dropped from standing height.
 
I've played with one for a full day. It feels horrible.

That's funny, I played with a Lumia 900 and was extremely impressed... and I do love my iPhone. Windows Phone is just snappy and silky-smooth. I came away with the same feeling I had when I first used an iPhone years ago. I also realized iOS looks quite dated, and that the Windows Phone Mango GUI is arguably better.

Apple only trumps it with the Retina display.
 
I am posting this from an iPhone, so don't bash me

I've used a Windows just minutes ago, and I was IMPRESSED.
Would I trade my iPhone for the WP7? YES!!
The OS is smooth as butter, and it feels WAY more responsive and connected than the iPhone
 
I once tried WP 6.5 on an HTC, and it sucked hard. Had I known it wouldn't even let me use English as system language without violating the EULA, I would never have bought that phone in the first place.
 
I am posting this from an iPhone, so don't bash me

I've used a Windows just minutes ago, and I was IMPRESSED.
Would I trade my iPhone for the WP7? YES!!
The OS is smooth as butter, and it feels WAY more responsive and connected than the iPhone

I first thought the same but after owning a Titan for 6 months,I came back to iOS.Because as smooth as WP7 looks,it has some big flaws,such as the multitasking system,notifications etc.
 
I first thought the same but after owning a Titan for 6 months,I came back to iOS.Because as smooth as WP7 looks,it has some big flaws,such as the multitasking system,notifications etc.

As someone who is still using a Titan, I don't know why you would move back to iOS because of multitasking. It's literally the exact same multitasking approach as iOS. Notifications are better on iOS, but that's only been around for a few months.

EDIT: Somewhat unrelated to the thread, but this is the sort of build quality Apple should strive for
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jf1fRu9YgfE
 
lol, it's funny how when Nokia make something out of polycarbonate, it's cheap and crappy, but when when apple made MacBooks out of polycarbonate, they were modern, nice and far from cheap 😀
 
I once tried WP 6.5 on an HTC, and it sucked hard. Had I known it wouldn't even let me use English as system language without violating the EULA, I would never have bought that phone in the first place.

WM 6.5 isn't even close to the same as WP7/7.5. Comparing them doesn't work - at all.
 
I once tried WP 6.5 on an HTC, and it sucked hard. Had I known it wouldn't even let me use English as system language without violating the EULA, I would never have bought that phone in the first place.

WM 6.5 isn't even close to the same as WP7/7.5. Comparing them doesn't work - at all.


Good response. Too bad the poster bad mouthing the Windows Phone does not know how to keep up with the newer versions and improvements, but relies on older OS's to make a bad point. Most OS's when they first come out have issues and that includes Apple. 😉
 
As someone who is still using a Titan, I don't know why you would move back to iOS because of multitasking. It's literally the exact same multitasking approach as iOS. Notifications are better on iOS, but that's only been around for a few months.

EDIT: Somewhat unrelated to the thread, but this is the sort of build quality Apple should strive for
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jf1fRu9YgfE
Not really.The task switcher on iOS is much better than WP version IMO.Also I forgot about the apps.The quality of apps on iOS are much better than WP7(I tested facebook,twitter,angry birds,fruit ninja etc.)
Also the call quality was terrible on the Titan(A lot of users have this issue);furthermore,when the battery reach 20% or lower,the capacitive buttons stopped responding(sometimes).
Overall,I prefer iOS but everyone has a different idea.
 
WM 6.5 isn't even close to the same as WP7/7.5. Comparing them doesn't work - at all.
Are you sure? So if I buy a WM7-phone in e.g. France and it comes with French language, I may change the system language to English if I want to? You see, that was one of my major issues with WM 6.5 and I would hate to experience that again.

Good response. Too bad the poster bad mouthing the Windows Phone does not know how to keep up with the newer versions and improvements, but relies on older OS's to make a bad point. Most OS's when they first come out have issues and that includes Apple. 😉
What makes you think I don't know how to keep up with newer versions, and why is it even relevant? WM 6.5 probably had its improvements over WM 6.1, which was better than WM 6, which was even better than WM 5, and so on. WM 7 can't be that much better than 6.5, at least I won't assume it is until I have tried it myself.

When I got my iPhone, it was before WM 7 came out, and I have no reason to even try WM again until my iPhone is worn out and I have to get a new phone anyway.
 
Last edited:
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.