I think the cutouts on the one I got are a bit better, but time will tell if its going to be as painless as the Apple cases.
The leather Apple used this year is much different than previous years, it feels harder and turns black instead of gradually darkening. I tried both the saddle brown and baltic blue for three months and they both ended up looking very bad. Maybe the black one will blend better since its a dark gray.
Here are pictures taken about two weeks ago, case looks much worse now. Never dropped or got it wet either.