Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

MacRumors

macrumors bot
Original poster


Following last month's coverage of an unofficial Mac port of Notepad++ that the original developer called out for trademark violation, the dispute has now been resolved with a rebrand.

notepad-plus-plus-scaled.jpg

The macOS port was previously released by Andrey Letov under the Notepad++ name without authorization. Don Ho created the original Windows code editor in 2003, and had publicly objected to the unofficial app's use of his trademark and the inclusion of his name and biography on its author page. After settling the dispute, the app has subsequently been renamed Nextpad++.

The site for Nextpad++ has been thoroughly updated and clearly states that the app is an "open-source and independent community port of Notepad++ to macOS." Elsewhere, Letov's About page describes the project as a Mac port of the Notepad++ GPL codebase, built on Objective-C++, Scintilla, and Cocoa, and shipped as a universal binary for Apple silicon and Intel Macs. The app also has a new icon.

Names aside, it seems Daring Fireball's John Gruber is less than charmed by the result, describing the app as feeling "unholy" and suggesting the rapid port could only have been built with AI vibe-coding tools. The site states development began on March 10.

Have you tried out Nextpad++ for Mac? Let us know what you think in the comments.

Article Link: Notepad++ Mac Port Renamed Nextpad++ After Trademark Row
 
Gruber makes some excellent points. He doesn't call it this, but the application is what amounts to a transliteration of Notepad++. That comes from an inexperienced developer using LLM coding tools. It's a start.

Everything Gruber criticizes it for can be fixed, however. It's open source so interested people can help make it better. There are already some people doing that.

Edit: I'll stick with VS Code. It's not lightweight, but it's solid.
 
  • Like
Reactions: centauratlas
Gruber makes some excellent points. He doesn't call it this, but the application is what amounts to a transliteration of Notepad++. That comes from an inexperienced developer using LLM coding tools. It's a start.

Everything Gruber criticizes it for can be fixed, however. It's open source so interested people can help make it better.
Yea, fix vibecoder masterpiece 😅
 
This is just DF-regurgitation. I love Gruber but MR doesn’t need to write a copycat story for everything he posts. There’s no way this would’ve been covered here if it weren’t for his post about it
 
  • Like
Reactions: CombatCaptured
describing the app as feeling "unholy" and suggesting the rapid port could only have been built with AI vibe-coding tools.

I mean it doesn't take a genius to see that all of the commits were done by Claude Code, since you know it literally says that is the author
 
So, the name change is just 1 letter and then rearranged the rest? 🧐
N o t e vs N e x t
They cannot even come up with a more original name? 🤣
I mean, what is the need of keeping the ++ part?

Did they learn anything from this?
 
This is just DF-regurgitation. I love Gruber but MR doesn’t need to write a copycat story for everything he posts. There’s no way this would’ve been covered here if it weren’t for his post about it

They've been covering it well before Gruber's post:



They had to update their first article since originally it suggested this was an official Notepad++ release.
 
So, the name change is just 1 letter and then rearranged the rest? 🧐
N o t e vs N e x t
They cannot even come up with a more original name? 🤣
I mean, what is the need of keeping the ++ part?

Did they learn anything from this?

Apple is the world’s largest and most valuable brand. Everyone knows the name.
Notepad++… the average user wonders why someone put two plus signs after the Windows app name. „What does that mean?“

So yes, it was a trademark infringement. But there is a certain difference between Notepad++ and Apple.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.