Also I find it funny that he comes back here defending the crap out of himself for some reason. If it was a truthful story, i'm sure he would let it be and let people talk all the crap he wants. It's like he likes getting a rise out of people...
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Otterbox fail.. phone shattered (pics)
- Thread starter SaMaster14
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
- Status
relax people
the op was just looking for some answers....why don't you guys read all the posts before posting? the OP said it may have been bent but they didn't know it cuz the case was on it all the time....
All i have to say is it sucks, but it happens to the best of em. nothing is indestructable....
hope they can fix it, but it looks like a new phone is in order with the bent casing and all...don't think apple will replace the glass since the casing is bent too...
the op was just looking for some answers....why don't you guys read all the posts before posting? the OP said it may have been bent but they didn't know it cuz the case was on it all the time....
All i have to say is it sucks, but it happens to the best of em. nothing is indestructable....
hope they can fix it, but it looks like a new phone is in order with the bent casing and all...don't think apple will replace the glass since the casing is bent too...
Anybody that owns or handles an iPhone 4\4s knows this isn't possible by dropping one from only 4' onto a flat surface. They're not made of some flimsy plastic! it's a metal casting that runs through the entire body of the unit, and it'll take a lot more force to bend it like that than a 4' drop. It looks more like somebody slammed it into the edge of a table [or tile] for some unknown reason. I'll even bet the Otterbox is damaged in a straight line that correlates with the bent frame. There's nothing Weird about it when you know the truth.
Here's the Help you ask for:
Your story sucks and won't convince even the slowest genius to replace it! It will more likely cause them to refuse a replacement because it's so obviously untrue. Think of a new story.
Edit: Maybe your 'Friend' didn't post because he knew he'd be ridiculed if he tried that line on anyone with an ounce of intelligence.
Last edited:
My kids have the otter box defender and lifeproof cases on 4S iPhones. They are 14 and 17 yrs old and they are kids and rough on thir phones. So far the phones are safe and sound. I would say that this damage did not happen as you discribed somply becasue I have dropped my 4S in an otter box defender and been saved many times. You friend is not being straight with us assuming you are. He packed a beat phone into an otter box and cryed wolf.
No way apple will stand behind that nore should they. I think it goes in the catagory of cruel and unusual punishment for any smart phone. I would go in be straight and hope you get a good guy.
I dropped my iPad2 3 months after release with just a smart cover. Dented the corner and damaged the screen. I told the truth and got a refurb. Next purchase was a defender case for that. it aint sexy, but it works!
No way apple will stand behind that nore should they. I think it goes in the catagory of cruel and unusual punishment for any smart phone. I would go in be straight and hope you get a good guy.
I dropped my iPad2 3 months after release with just a smart cover. Dented the corner and damaged the screen. I told the truth and got a refurb. Next purchase was a defender case for that. it aint sexy, but it works!
He said in the very first post:
Here are pics of the device, if you want pics of the Otterbox I can get those too.
So it is weird how he says he can get pics of the Otterbox, then later on says he won't bother.
Funny story but not true. I sell the otterbox case. If your friend had the defender. There is no way that could of happened to the iPhone. We test the cases all the time to sell them at my store and we throw out real live phones around the store to prove how good the case is.. And yes, we test real iPhone's.
If your friend had the otterbox.. This is what happened. He tripped w/e, dropped the iPhone w/ the case and then by accident stepped on it as well. He or you probably doesn't want to admit it. But that's the truth. What you're saying does not apply into scientific terms.
The thread should be changed to "Fail.. Phone shattered (pics)"
If your friend had the otterbox.. This is what happened. He tripped w/e, dropped the iPhone w/ the case and then by accident stepped on it as well. He or you probably doesn't want to admit it. But that's the truth. What you're saying does not apply into scientific terms.
The thread should be changed to "Fail.. Phone shattered (pics)"
My friend was in a motorcycle accident in the fall that put him in the hospital for nearly a month. His iPhone in an otter box survived the accident and being thrown from my friends pocket during the crash. I hate how thick the otter box is (not my preference) but I have to give it credit.
I don't know if I believe this one, lol. Four foot drop?
Must of been a hard fall, and he smashed it to the ground.
Thats what my iPhone4 looked like after I crashed on my mountain bike and my buddy ran it over before I could grab it lol. And that phone was naked… The only way I could see that happening with a defender on is if it was curb stomped!
And yes apple did replace without charge. Even replaced the one my gf dropped in toilet. All I told the genius was the truth and also that the toilet>iPhone.
And yes apple did replace without charge. Even replaced the one my gf dropped in toilet. All I told the genius was the truth and also that the toilet>iPhone.
Last edited:
I believe what the OP said was that the case was in good condition before the fall and ended up getting damage after the fall.
I read this thread earlier this morning with a healthy dose of disbelief and skepticism. Just an hour ago, I was at the gym running on the treadmill when somehow my earphones fell off, got tangled around my leg, yanked my iPhone off the treadmill "magazine stand" and kerplunk pretty damn hard onto the tread. And before I could even react, the phone ended up under my foot and my entire body weight! Needless to say I had a minor heart attack, and immediately I remembered the pics from this thread. Thankfully, not a bit of damage to the phone! Just a little bruising and some scratches to my SwitchEasy CapsuleRebel case.
This is actually my third incident with my phone in 2 weeks! First, I dropped my phone (no case this time) off the kitchen counter onto the tile floor. Not a single scratch or dent. A few days later, my entire bowl of tomato soup spilled onto the front of my phone. luckily I was able to dry it off really fast before any liquid went into the ports. And now this. My poor phone has been thru hell lately!
This is actually my third incident with my phone in 2 weeks! First, I dropped my phone (no case this time) off the kitchen counter onto the tile floor. Not a single scratch or dent. A few days later, my entire bowl of tomato soup spilled onto the front of my phone. luckily I was able to dry it off really fast before any liquid went into the ports. And now this. My poor phone has been thru hell lately!
The commuter case is sufficient for most people. This phone instead looks like it got ran over by a commuter train instead.
Anyone else notice how the home button is perfectly intact and not even damaged in the slightest?? LOL
Oh! And BS.
Oh! And BS.
- Status