Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Happy to provide some insight. Not all podcasters publish on those platforms. And even if they do, I enjoy the benefits of a podcast feed to download brand new episodes as they are released and keep track of the ones I've already watched. For Downcast, there's an iOS and a Mac app that keeps all of my settings and episodes in sync (I can listen on one and pick up right where I left off on the other). I can listen to one podcast and decide to switch to another for a bit and just pick right up where I left off when I'm ready to go back to the other. I also have every podcast automatically set to start at a faster speed (you become quite accustomed to it and finishing an hour long podcast in 45 minutes many times a day/week really adds up in saving time). I can stream the content or download it for offline viewing/listening. Having all of these features (and more) in a single app regardless of who is creating the content is very convenient. And (unlike YouTube) if I need to switch away to a different app, I can continue to have the audio playing in the background. Hope that helps. And to put it more in perspective I'm subscribed to over 30 different podcast feeds (some daily, many weekly or monthly) from about 10 different creators.

Overcast does allow for a lot of this: such as syncing settings, episodes, playback location, per podcast speed settings, etc between a phone, tablet, web browser (but as you pointed out only for audio). I listen to A LOT of audio podcasts, but honestly aren't aware of any that have a video element (probably partially due to the fact that I exclusively use Overcast, which obviously wouldn't promote any video elements). Thanks for the insight!
 
Last edited:
I can believe it. How often do we rotate phone screens, except for video / games?

Also, note the iPhone X needlessly complicating things gets called out.
If placed in landscape orientation, my phone fits almost perfectly on my car's LCD display, and it's angled such that the it rarely falls off.

I thought about getting a phone mount, but I haven't found one that does not have some downsides.
 
is that only for downloaded and not streamed? i tried marking as unplayed and theres no badge. i really don't want a notification, just a badge.

I just checked and it works for both streamed and downloaded episodes (make sure "Badge App Icon" is turned on for Overcast in your iOS Notification settings). As far as I'm aware, overcast doesn't have a "mark as unplayed" feature. You have to click play to begin streaming or download the epsidoe; once of those happens, your badge app icon should be updated. Also, you don't have to have any push notifications on at all if you don't want. The badge icon number represents any unfinished episodes. To turn on/off the Icon Badge Number look in Overcasts settings, under Nitpicky Details, Icon Badge Number.
 
I currently use Overcast, but I've been eyeing Pocket Casts too. Then again, the ads aren't intrusive at all on Overcast so...

Has anyone used both? Any reason for a preference one way or the other?
Pocket Casts is a good stable app. It doesn’t have playlists which I didn’t like at first but it’s so smooth and reliable that I am fine with with the Up Next playlist option it provides. It has a filter feature that I don’t use that you can organize your podcasts according to your taste but it only allows playback in chronological order. It’s not a power user player but you can customize the ff/rw speeds, sleep timer and playback speed. I tried Over Cast a while back and didn’t care for the UI. Maybe it’s better now. I might give it a try.
 
  • Like
Reactions: oneMadRssn
It’s a shame support is so bad for this product. Over 5 months, sent numerous emails and tweets about a podcast not pulling the correct feed. I manually add one of my podcasts, and it pulls an expired feed and won’t pull new episodes. No other podcast app has this issue.

Developer has yet to comment or fix the issue. Nice support.

I've sent messages and received a response via twitter maybe try that?
[doublepost=1521051452][/doublepost]I wish the dev for OverCast would make a OS X version. I find using iTunes for podcasts absolutely painful. Its bad enough that I just keep on AirPods in and use my iphone, I mean that's a clear sign we need our own podcast app.
 
I've sent messages and received a response via twitter maybe try that?
[doublepost=1521051452][/doublepost]I wish the dev for OverCast would make a OS X version. I find using iTunes for podcasts absolutely painful. Its bad enough that I just keep on AirPods in and use my iphone, I mean that's a clear sign we need our own podcast app.

Go to www.overcast.fm on your Mac browser and sign in
 
  • Like
Reactions: ignatius345
Thanks. You lost me at premium and subscription.
If all the free app does is slightly improve the free Apple Podcast one, then I'll keep looking.
Not sure why adding my own content would necessitate a premium feature.

Well Overcast pays to run the servers that host and serve up content that you add, and sync it across all your devices.

Of course, if you create your own RSS feed in a text editor you can manually add entries that point to mp3 files you've uploaded somewhere publicly accessible, then subscribe to that feed as a podcast. All for free. Your call!
 
Not sure why adding my own content would necessitate a premium feature.

Because the developer has to host the files that you upload on their own servers, and that costs them money. Plus it's a relatively pro-level feature, which makes it a good candidate for being a paid feature.
 
This is probably my most used third party app.
The top row of my home screen: Overcast, Music, Maps, Camera. Always listening to one of those first two.

The smart-resume is something I've recently been wishing for (both Apple Maps and Google Maps will pause the audio before talking, but sometimes it can throw you off when it resumes - especially through runs of "in 1000 feet, take XYZ exit" "take XYZ exit now" "keep left to stay right" "merge onto..." (sometimes I really want maps to have a "just announce the exit once" feature).
[doublepost=1521062386][/doublepost]
Thanks. You lost me at premium and subscription.
If all the free app does is slightly improve the free Apple Podcast one, then I'll keep looking.
Not sure why adding my own content would necessitate a premium feature.
Overcast is one of a tiny handful of apps for which I pay a subscription. It's $10 a year. I have no problem paying for good software (and the alternative pricing scheme of yearly "Overcast 2.0! $10... Overcast 3.0! $10..." purchases isn't any real improvement over just giving Marco $10 a year with the expectation that he'll keep improving the app). It's not so much that particular features necessitate a cost, as simply making a few top features only available to those who pay. And he does run some back-end servers to cataloging everything and sending out notifications, etc., so there are ongoing costs to him.

The app improves substantially on Apple's Podcast app. If you can't/don't appreciate the difference, you're not the target market for it. If you're doubtful but curious, you can run it ad-supported (his own non-screaming ad network, not the 3rd party ad network crap seen in most ad-supported apps) to see how it works. If you just want to complain about any software that costs money... I'm not really looking to have that debate.
 
Overcast is one of a tiny handful of apps for which I pay a subscription. It's $10 a year. I have no problem paying for good software (and the alternative pricing scheme of yearly "Overcast 2.0! $10... Overcast 3.0! $10..." purchases isn't any real improvement over just giving Marco $10 a year with the expectation that he'll keep improving the app). It's not so much that particular features necessitate a cost, as simply making a few top features only available to those who pay. And he does run some back-end servers to cataloging everything and sending out notifications, etc., so there are ongoing costs to him.

The app improves substantially on Apple's Podcast app. If you can't/don't appreciate the difference, you're not the target market for it. If you're doubtful but curious, you can run it ad-supported (his own non-screaming ad network, not the 3rd party ad network crap seen in most ad-supported apps) to see how it works. If you just want to complain about any software that costs money... I'm not really looking to have that debate.

There is a reason that the upload feature is premium, the added file is uploaded to AWS S3 cloud servers with ongoing storage costs. The benefit for the user is that the file is available for download or streaming anywhere you have an internet connection.
 
Alas, although Overcast is one of my favorite apps, I'm out of the upgrade loop, stuck at 3.1.8 due to the fact that my iPhone 5 won't run iOS 11. Maybe next fall I will be able to catch up. That said, the features it does have make it well worth having.
[doublepost=1521067655][/doublepost]
Apple should just buy overcast, slap their logo on it and call it a day
No, I wouldn't want Apple to buy it. But I'd be delighted if they acquired the right to add SmartSpeed and Voice Boost to iOS and macOS. Once you use those, the inadequacies of what Apple ships becomes all too obvious.
 
The one thing that I'd really like to see Marco add at this point is a Apple TV port. I'd be okay with it dropping any features that were hard to translate to the Apple TV UI and frameworks, if it just gave a better UI than Apple's Podcasts app, and sync'd my list of podcast subscriptions and played/new/play-progress from recent episodes, from my phone. So if I'm in the living room, I could play podcasts on the TV, through the home theater speakers, without having to choose between airplaying Overcast from my phone or futzing around with the Apple TV's Podcast app and its inferior interface.
[doublepost=1521102045][/doublepost]
There is a reason that the upload feature is premium, the added file is uploaded to AWS S3 cloud servers with ongoing storage costs. The benefit for the user is that the file is available for download or streaming anywhere you have an internet connection.
I'm well aware the upload feature stores files on S3 (I did not say it didn't cost him anything to operate), but it isn't being offered as "Overcast is free and you can pay for uploads", it's being offered as "Overcast is free and and you can pay for Premium". Premium supports further development and covers the ongoing costs for the servers he uses to keep track of available podcasts and episodes, as well as the S3 storage cost. I stand by my original statement, you're not paying for a particular feature (he's not charging an amount that closely tracks your particular part of the S3 storage costs), you're paying to support the ongoing development, maintenance, and operational costs, and in turn you gain access to all the features, including those that affect operational costs.
 
Last edited:
If you mean the main list of subscribed podcasts, the answer is you can’t. It’s sorted automatically in alphabetical order.
That’s a shame and I can’t understand how such a basic feature is omitted. I’m glad you confirmed it for me. I really thought I was missing something and felt kind of dumb for not being able to find it.

I guess I’ll stick to Pocket Casts and Downcast unless Marco decides to get with it and add this feature in.
 
  • Like
Reactions: robantonelli
Because the developer has to host the files that you upload on their own servers, and that costs them money. Plus it's a relatively pro-level feature, which makes it a good candidate for being a paid feature.
But I don't need them to host anything, I want to send a mp3 file from my PC to my phone. If they need all the files on their servers to do the magic, well then, that is not what I need the app for. I would think my iPhone can do the heavy lifting.

Another strange thing, if you go to the website, he says the subscription is to remove ads, I don't see anything about the hosting benefit.
 
I’ve given Overcast another shot and it’s really good. I don’t find the ads obtrusive, but may pay for it as I appreciate good apps and don’t mind paying for them. I probably listen to over 100 hours of podcasts per week. I think it’s resonable to pay 84 cents a month for it considering the use I would get from it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kpeex
I’ve given Overcast another shot and it’s really good. I don’t find the ads obtrusive, but may pay for it as I appreciate good apps and don’t mind paying for them. I probably listen to over 100 hours of podcasts per week. I think it’s resonable to pay 84 cents a month for it considering the use I would get from it.
Agreed on paying. An interesting tidbit on usage is this note from the bottom of the settings screen in Overcast on my iPhone: "Smart Speed has saved you an extra 38 hours beyond speed adjustments alone."
 
I’ve given Overcast another shot and it’s really good. I don’t find the ads obtrusive, but may pay for it as I appreciate good apps and don’t mind paying for them. I probably listen to over 100 hours of podcasts per week. I think it’s resonable to pay 84 cents a month for it considering the use I would get from it.
Lol I meant 100 hours a month.
 
But I don't need them to host anything, I want to send a mp3 file from my PC to my phone. If they need all the files on their servers to do the magic, well then, that is not what I need the app for. I would think my iPhone can do the heavy lifting.

Another strange thing, if you go to the website, he says the subscription is to remove ads, I don't see anything about the hosting benefit.

I'm not the developer and so I don't want to put words in his mouth, but I believe the hosting setup is to allow you to upload a file from any computer via the web and then be able to have that file available to play on any device on which you have Overcast (iPhone, iPad, etc.) or via the Overcast.fm website.

The hosting itself isn't a selling point, the selling point is this system of being able to upload your own files and have them play back anywhere you have access to Overcast. They aren't selling online storage.
 
If you pay for the Premium subscription, you can use the Uploads feature: use your browser to upload MP3/AAC files to your account on overcast.fm, and they show up in the app. I use it for some of my favorite audiobooks.
I wonder if there's a way to automate this. I use Audio Hijack Pro's built-in scheduler to record the morning news off my local NPR station's stream every morning and then listen to it later. Right now I do it through iTunes but getting it into Overcast would be just great.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.