Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Cod3rror

macrumors 68000
Original poster
Apr 18, 2010
1,834
192
I noticed something from the iOS 5 beta videos, unless you pull the Notification Center down completely widgets and notifications don't show up.

If you pull it down a quarter or half way, it's blank, there's just the linen background.

It shouldn't be like that IMO, we should be able to pull it down a little to say look at the weather and then let it go and it folds up on the it's own.

That would be nice in full screen apps and games too, got some notification, pull it down a little(Peek), it's nothing important, let it go, continue playing.
 
I noticed something from the iOS 5 beta videos, unless you pull the Notification Center down completely widgets and notifications don't show up.

If you pull it down a quarter or half way, it's blank, there's just the linen background.

It shouldn't be like that IMO, we should be able to pull it down a little to say look at the weather and then let it go and it folds up on the it's own.

That would be nice in full screen apps and games too, got some notification, pull it down a little(Peek), it's nothing important, let it go, continue playing.

can you arrange the order they are in? if so what if you put the weather at the bottom
 
can you arrange the order they are in? if so what if you put the weather at the bottom

The point is that you have to complete the full gesture, pull it all the way down for things to show up.

In Android you can pull the menu down a bit and everything that should be visible is displayed.

If Apple was going to copy Android, I wish they had at least done it well.
 
the list still starts at the top of the panel

i totally agree with the OP and have already pointed this out in another thread
https://forums.macrumors.com/showthread.php?p=12723938#post12723938

I'm glad that I'm not the only one that noticed that.

Notification menu is a total bolt on in iOS, it feels like they implemented it as the last second.

You don't actually move any UI element, it appears out of nowhere "like magic" in Android you actually pull down the status bar. Also notice how Android's status bar itself changes to display date and time when you tap on it.

At 0:08.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_7DmxcXHVEY




Then nothing is visible till you pull it all the way down.

In Android you don't need to do that.

20973-android_notification_super.jpg


Can some dev please submit this to Apple?



EDIT: Here's an easy explanation/analogy for those that don't get it: When you want to quickly take look out the window do you move to the drapes all the way from one end to the other? No, you move one side a little bit take a small peek. It's the same thing here.
 
Last edited:
i see where this implementation would be beneficial. hopefully apple will add this to the notification center
 
Gotta throw my two cents in:

In iOS 5, you can pull the notification center down partially to peak at your notifications but widgets (Weather and Stocks) will not load unless you complete the gesture.

One of the reasons widgets don't load until you complete the gesture is because they update every time you view the "full" notifications center and peaking into the notifications center would cause them to update every single time, putting strain on your battery life and data usage.

I don't understand where you are getting the idea that nothing shows up unless you pull the menu down all of the way... I do it all of the time.
 
One of the reasons widgets don't load until you complete the gesture is because they update every time you view the "full" notifications center and peaking into the notifications center would cause them to update every single time, putting strain on your battery life and data usage

I don't get the logic behind this, if you are peeking that means you are interested and requesting information. What difference does it make whether you just peek or pull it down fully?
 
I don't get the logic behind this, if you are peeking that means you are interested and requesting information. What difference does it make whether you just peek or pull it down fully?

In my situation, I peek into the notifications center to check for notifications and only release it if I want to check the weather (because it is at the top of my list) or if I want to make an action on on one of the notifications.

I don't know if it's just because I've been trained to do that from using it or if it is just a natural habit. But, I have not had a single problem (or thought) with the fact that the widgets load only after the notification center is pulled down fully (both then and now); I think you may be making a mountain out of an ant hill.

Or maybe I'm just weird.
 
I don't get the logic behind this, if you are peeking that means you are interested and requesting information. What difference does it make whether you just peek or pull it down fully?

He just said, bro. If the widgets were to update every time you "peeked" then the widgets would have to update every 5 or 10 minutes. That would severely cut down on your battery life. Then you would probably complain that the battery life on the iPhone sucks.
 
i don't get what you're trying to say

even if you set weather to be last, unless you have a lot of other notifications, weather will still appear towards the top. It is only placed on the bottom (and thus, able to be peeked at) if there are enough other notifications to push weather all the way down
 
even if you set weather to be last, unless you have a lot of other notifications, weather will still appear towards the top. It is only placed on the bottom (and thus, able to be peeked at) if there are enough other notifications to push weather all the way down

thanks, that's what i was trying to say, exactly, thank you :)

This is part of the reason that Apple people have a bad rap. You guys will find the silliest inconsequential stuff to bitch about. :rolleyes:

people were complaining the original notifications were too obtrusive, because they covered the _middle_ of the screen
now we have a notification panel where, should we have 2 notifications or a widget that we want to check quickly, we have to cover the _entire screen_ with an _empty black canvas_.

Of course the new notifications are far superior than the old ones. But downplaying this to some kind of non-issue is equally ridiculous, as it would be easily fixable and pretty much renders the widgets on the panel slightly less useful.
 
Last edited:
...should we have 2 notifications or a widget that we want to check quickly ...
You keep talking about things being "quick" ...

... swiping down and then swiping back up takes a REALLY long time, amirite?

people were complaining the original notifications were too obtrusive, because they covered the _middle_ of the screen
now we have a notification panel where [...] we have to cover the _entire screen_ with an _empty black canvas_.
These are two completely seperate things. People complained about the notifications because they were jarring and obtrusive. Last I checked, the notification center is on-demand - it's doesn't jump out at you in the middle of Angry Birds shouting "SURPRISE NOTIFICATION!" and throwing confetti.
 
it's not (only) about the 'incredibly long time', but also about the fact that it's ugly, in a very inefficient way.

photooe.png


i find this ugly.

would you not mind if folders instead of only 'sliding open' as much as actually is required, would cover the entire screen, regardless of actual content?
calling it 'nitpicky', saying 'it doesn't take that long to open and close a folder'?

folderhn.png



but we get it, you don't care, that's fine with me. I didn't care about the size of the snooze button, but i wouldn't run around trolling, calling people 'nitpicky' who want their OS to be even more visually appealing and functional (android implements this 'peeking into the notification center' perfectly, it's really easy to implement)
so, thank you for your input, we get it, you don't care. we do
 
Last edited:
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.