While, I think 75% brightness is far to high. It still appears your battery is faulty. I'd def have em replace it. But I'd also at least keep my brightness on 50%. Or so.
Brightness can effect the battery quite a bit.
Agreed, plus according to OP it seems like they have pushed email enabled. If that if pushing every 15 minutes, there is no wonder why the battery is dropping so quickly. I get a good 8 hours of usage a day, of texting and some web browsing on 3G, but if I turn on push email for the day and use Navigon or even Maps, thats cut down to 4.5-5. Especially with brightness on that high. Mines on 50% max.