Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
The G5 Dual Core is a really nice computer, and quite fast, if you're using it for the right things with the right software. Using it for HD video editing is NOT the right things. I would, as most other here, recomend to buy an Intel Mac. Otherwise, you're gonna be disappointed.

The main reason i can see to get a PMG5 is if you need the possability to add extra HD, PCI slots and so on (and are fine with G5) and/or already got a good monitor, keyboard and mouse and don't need the power of an Intel Mac.

Then we have this thing with web browsing...
 
Last edited:
AFAIK, there is no 1.8GHz dual-core. Dual cores starts at 2.0, 2.3 and ends up at dual dual core or 2.5 quad.

If it is 1.8GHz, it is either a single or a dual processor.
 
You're using it to keep your house warm? :rolleyes:


(just kidding; I have a G5 2,0 DP and I love that thing)

I use my G5 to heat my workshop (seriously). That building gets free electricity, so why not? The only time it wasn't able to keep up was this past winter when the temperatures got around and below 0F. Then I had to put a little space heater in there to help.
 
I use my G5 to heat my workshop (seriously). That building gets free electricity, so why not? The only time it wasn't able to keep up was this past winter when the temperatures got around and below 0F. Then I had to put a little space heater in there to help.

What do you use Geekbench as a thermostat then?
 
What kind of work do you do with it? I am not saying it cannot be done but I am saying that it is the wrong tool for the job in this day and age.

I don't think you read the entire sentence or took the wrong half of the sentence to focus on. ;)

You're using it to keep your house warm? :rolleyes:

(just kidding; I have a G5 2,0 DP and I love that thing)

I love my G5, and it works well. It also generates some heat, enough for the one room without any kind of heater to be halfway comfortable, especially with some more processor-intensive activities (like video work--set it, forget it, and warm the room).
 
What editing programs do you use?

On the G5? I use iMovie, because the older versions of it were insanely flexible when it came to editing video. The older versions of iMovie are better than you think.

On my Intel mini, my default editor is now Final Cut Pro, because the new iMovie is very inflexible.
 
Last edited:
I don't think you read the entire sentence or took the wrong half of the sentence to focus on. ;)



I love my G5, and it works well. It also generates some heat, enough for the one room without any kind of heater to be halfway comfortable, especially with some more processor-intensive activities (like video work--set it, forget it, and warm the room).

I get it now...
 
That PowerMac would be insufficient in regards to both editing 1080p video (possible tough, but it just doesn't work very well unless you hate when thing flow smoothly) and playing a game such as Half-Life/Gmod (since the former requires Intel and the last time i used Gmod it had to be bootcamped. This is not possible with a PMG5, as even VirtualPC will be terribly sluggish and bad.)

It might not be what everybody else around here thinks, but unless you are either an enthusiast or a collector, it really is too late to get into PPC based Macs, especially with those kinds of demands.

If i were you i would rather look for a Intel machine. Early Mac Pros are running cheap, but they are quite unsupported by now, so it would actually be better to find something smaller or just stick with a PC.


How's that undercover government job doing? Still using tiger are they?
 
About a week ago I saved a 1.8 Dual G5 from certain doom, getting it for free from a corporate liquidation. It didn't come with a hard drive or RAM, and had lots of stickers (interestingly it was used at Toshiba) on it and was rather dusty. I cleaned it up, put in a 120GB 7200RPM hard drive, and added 3GB of RAM I had and it's now running Leopard perfectly.

This is the first PPC Mac I've tinkered with and so far am rather impressed with it, considering that it just hit over 10 years old. The OS is snappy, Internet browsing works fine (though it does get slow on some sites), and apps for that era like Office 2004 and even iWork 2009 work great. It still seems to be a very capable machine for basic tasks. There's even a version of Dropbox that works with PPC!

Now that it's working, I thought about keeping it but considering I have a 2009 mini as a local media server and a 15" rMBP, I don't have much use for it and it does take up a lot of space in my apartment. I'm going to see if I can find someone who needs or can use it and hopefully it'll find a new home.

Anyway, from my brief experience I think they are still good machines for basic tasks and using software of it's time, though I don't think I'd use it as my main computer.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.