Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Good for Google, this make me happy. Jobs, step up to the plate now, give the iphone 4g built in turn by turn navigation. Hire one of the companies to get this on the next OS. Wtf 4 generations of iphones, and we are still waiting for built in Navigation. gg:rolleyes:
 
I kind of love/hate Google. Is that weird? Anyway, I`d like to see their free GPS navigation on iPhone.
 
Now that Google and Apple are in a hardware and software war, I doubt Google will release it to the iPhone. Why drive customers away from their hardware offerings?
Because iPhone users wouldn't get ads served from Google? Remember, that's where Google really makes their money:



It would be foolish of Google to let that revenue stream go elsewhere just to make points for their Android phone platform. Note that I'm not saying Google won't do just that, only that it wouldn't be their smartest move.
 
They've made some great services, I love Google Analytics and Google Maps but I find their general attitude about privacy to be very alarming and it's a bit disturbing that people are throwing away their privacy in the name of free services. Of course people will only care once they feel they've been burned.

I don’t find it alarming at all really. This is how Google makes their money. From their perspective, they don’t want any of your online life to be private. Otherwise they couldn’t mine it for data and solicit advertisers.

What’s alarming is the sheer amount of people that think Google is God’s gift to the Internet. It’s a corporation folks that’s primary objective is to make money for shareholders.

At least with Apple and Microsoft, you’re not confused. Everyone understands that Apple sells Macs and iPhones and Microsoft sells Windows and Office.

I don’t think the average person understands what Google actually does.
 
What I love about Google Maps is that it can SEARCH for stuff, VERY easily - with any other nav app, I need to KNOW the address - frack that! With google I can just search for what I want, click on the right thing, and select "directions". Easy-peasy. Can Mapquest do that? Or any other GPS app??
 
I would love free turn-by-turn for the iPhone. That's one of the things that concerns me the most about leaving Sprint for AT&T this summer - the lack of free GPS. Sprint Navigation comes free with the data plan and it has worked like a champ and has been more accurate than both Garmin and TomTom in my travels. I will truly miss that app.

The thing about moving to ATT that should bother you the most is JOINING ATT. Worst network ever. Apple tying themselves to that piece of garbage company was one of many mistakes they keep making.
 
Meh. The Mapquest is free and does a far better job already. In comparison, the Google map apps is functionally broken. I don't know how many times it hasn't been able to pinpoint an address correctly (I've lost count).

+1

I invested the $30.00 in Navigon MyRegion because I got tired of the Google Maps app not finding addresses, directing me to exits that don't exist, etc.
 
Bit of a double edged sword for Apple here. A free GPS navigation on their device would surely promote sales. Of course it was have an adverse effect on App store sales.

Be interesting to see what happens.
 
As much as I love my Macbook, Macbook Pro, iPhones, iPods, and iPad in my house... I hope Google starts playing hardball with Apple.

Google is a company that we should admire, going up against Chinese censorship and really haven't done anything "evil". They seem to have found a way to make money and still look out for the general good.

Steve Jobs has the audacity to call Google evil for bringing some competition in the mobile phone industry. I don't even think Google wants to dominate the industry, they just want to make sure a system like Apple does not become the end all be all. They just want to make sure people have choices.

If Google somehow blocks Gmail and Google Maps from the iPhone, the phone would just be a brick for a lot of people.

Google is also continually hitting privacy problems....basically its failure to respect privacy until it is forced to do so by governmental agencies. Whilst I admire a lot of what google has done, I also value my privacy.
 
I agree 100%

Been Mac user for number of years and converted plenty of people from Windows to OS X...

But am not doing this anymore since few months ago simply because Apple has turn (or still turning) into bigger arseholes than what MS used to be!

I will be buying new MacBook Pro again when my current model dies and that is only because of OS X!

Rest of Apple products together with their draconian attitude can go and f.o. as far as I am concerned...

:)

LOL ... you can't even go all in.
 
Hurm. The big question is will Apple approve it? They wouldn’t let Latitude in the App Store because it “duplicates functionality.”

A turn by turn direction app doesn't duplicate any functionality of the iPhone OS or any Apple made app. Unfortunately. I would like to see Apple throw in a native turn by turn GPS app in the next iPhone. :)
 
I agree 100%

Been Mac user for number of years and converted plenty of people from Windows to OS X...

But am not doing this anymore since few months ago simply because Apple has turn (or still turning) into bigger arseholes than what MS used to be!

I will be buying new MacBook Pro again when my current model dies and that is only because of OS X!

Rest of Apple products together with their draconian attitude can go and f.o. as far as I am concerned...

:)

Agree..Same here..
 
do you really not see a problem with the type of information Google is compiling on you? They have your email, your house on satellite, they document every internet search you make, and video you watch, and when you buy their phone, they literally can track you & listen in on every phone call... all ONE company. Not to mention the fact that they sat on the Board for Apple, and then after the iphone came out, had the brilliant idea to make their own smartphone using iphone features they were privy too from being on Apple's board.... whether or not you like Apple, that is a problem. And no matter how egotistical or arsehole-like Steve Jobs may possibly be, he isn't the one driving photo cars in front of your house, peering into your windows, showing complete satellite layouts of your community to any would be terrorists. Google IS evil, and can kiss my @$$.

i just found this comment using BING :D

but the man has a point...
 
+1

I invested the $30.00 in Navigon MyRegion because I got tired of the Google Maps app not finding addresses, directing me to exits that don't exist, etc.

It's just a $30 one time fee for the app, right? No monthly subscription or anything like that?
 
I don’t find it alarming at all really. This is how Google makes their money. From their perspective, they don’t want any of your online life to be private. Otherwise they couldn’t mine it for data and solicit advertisers.

I find it alarming because it you sign up for one service they start mining your data in other areas. Like you make an Analytics account and they start logging your web search history. I brought it up to a friend and he told me to just turn it off, but I'd like to think the default procedure should be that you are asked first.
 
There´s a war

There is a war now, and strategic positions are crucial. I believe Google will hesitate a bit too long and in the meantime there will be other and hungrier players diving into and using Apples ecosystem to it´s fullest. Because, it is not the single device which has the highest value, it is the combination of them - including the cloud, which will be improved systematically. For some reason, the competition does not seem to see the master plan; building a complete digital ecosystem. Some parts are in place in their earliest versions, others will follow.
 
Google has backpedaled on those claims and in fact seems to be distancing itself from the possibility of bringing the service to the iPhone.

How is it Google backpedaling if they haven't stated that in the first place? The reporter reported what he wanted to hear ("google navigation on iphone") and not what he was told ("other platfroms have not been ruled out, yet"), without using common sense to think if that makes any sense and without checking if he had interpreted correctly what was said. That is just bad journalism, unfortunately increasingly common in the internet as publications (and journalists) try to maximize impression counts of their articles. Because that's what pays the bills...
 
Jobs, step up to the plate now, give the iphone 4g built in turn by turn navigation. Hire one of the companies to get this on the next OS. Wtf 4 generations of iphones, and we are still waiting for built in Navigation. gg:rolleyes:

I agree. Built in turn by turn navigation would be a big plus for iPhone 4G.
Here's hoping that Apple had plans in that direction when they bought PlaceBase, and not just plans for location aware iAdds :(
 
I have never understood the fascination with turn by turn navigation. If I need to look something up i Just use the Maps app on the phone and follow the directions. Amazing to me that people wont buy a phone because it doesnt have turn by turn.
 
As much as I love my Macbook, Macbook Pro, iPhones, iPods, and iPad in my house... I hope Google starts playing hardball with Apple.

Google is a company that we should admire, going up against Chinese censorship and really haven't done anything "evil". They seem to have found a way to make money and still look out for the general good.

Steve Jobs has the audacity to call Google evil for bringing some competition in the mobile phone industry. I don't even think Google wants to dominate the industry, they just want to make sure a system like Apple does not become the end all be all. They just want to make sure people have choices.

If Google somehow blocks Gmail and Google Maps from the iPhone, the phone would just be a brick for a lot of people.

That whole rant was just silly and weirdly naive.

Go look around on the Internet for some of the less admirable things Google is doing. And don't focus solely on China. They're not as altruistic as you think. Here's a site that will get you started, but there's more out there.

BTW, Jobs didn't call Google evil. He reportedly said their mantra of "don't be evil" is BS. I agree. It's a feel-good, marketing thing they put out there.

Also, I think you vastly overestimate the value of Google to the iPhone. I've weaned myself off most of Google's services out of concern for their incessant info collecting on users and recent privacy gaffes (yeah, thanks for opting me back into Buzz after I opted out) and guess what? There is life after Google. There are other map and search and email providers and many of them are just as good, if not better.
 
Now that Google and Apple are in a hardware and software war, I doubt Google will release it to the iPhone. Why drive customers away from their hardware offerings?

You misunderstand Google's strategy. Google's entire reason d'etre is to have their products EVERYWHERE. They can only continue to build their monolith as long as they have a free alternative in every user's hands. As soon as they start leaving out major players, they open the door for competitors. They most certainly can't afford to miss 100 million iDevice users.

Google is a company that we should admire, going up against Chinese censorship and really haven't done anything "evil". They seem to have found a way to make money and still look out for the general good.

You're entitled to your opinion - no matter how wrong it may be.

Just a few examples:
- Google started in around 2004 to copy every published work they could find for distribution on the Internet - without the authors' permission. That is about as blatant a copyright violation as you can imagine. Apparently, Google's desires overrule Authors' rights.

- Google collects and enormous amount of private information about you - often without telling you - and then sell it to the highest bidder.

- Google changes terms of service, adds new 'features' and then automatically enrolls you in another new 'service' which collects more of your information for their own use - again without telling you.

- Google has had several very well-known privacy violations and loss of private information.

Sorry, no thanks.

OH NOES! THE TERRORISTS KNOW WHERE BUILDINGS ARE! :eek:

Couldn't they just drive down the street and do the same? :confused:

Not always. For example, chemical and nuclear plants are typically not accessible without appropriate access documents. A terrorist would know the general location of the plant from driving down the street, but they wouldn't know the exact location of vulnerable points.

But that's not my concern. I'm more concerned about all the little nibbling away of rights and privacy that Google does. Just one example - I have a swimming pool in my back yard, but it's not visible from the street. Now, anyone can look at the neighborhood and see who has swimming pools - which makes me more subject to vandalism or trespassing by teenagers. Just as important, no one has any right to know that I have a pool in my yard. Now, let's say I did a Google search for 'nude sunbathing'. Think about the problems that creates. That's my business.

Multiply that by 300 million Americans and you see a lot of privacy problems.
 
I have never understood the fascination with turn by turn navigation. If I need to look something up i Just use the Maps app on the phone and follow the directions. Amazing to me that people wont buy a phone because it doesnt have turn by turn.

It's a lot safer than looking down at a map while driving in a city you're unfamiliar with.
 
IMHO (from an aesthetics standpoint) Google Maps is far superior to any other free mapping technology available hands down. Graphically it's very strong without being over the top. Turn x turn voice nav added to the already impressive feature set = ball out of the park. It's been known that :apple: wants to compete in this space as well with their own take on mapping technology - perhaps it'll be ready for prime time at iPhone 4.0 launch. I'll take any of the above - I just hope they don't give us Microsoft's maps. Visually, it looks too choppy. Here's to turn x turn with Google or "iMaps"/whatever :apple: decides to call it.
 
CNET: "Google is working with Apple on bringing it to the iPhone, and it's not ruling out licensing the software to makers of portable navigation devices used in cars throughout the world," said Gundotra, vice president of engineering at Google for mobile and developers. "The process involving Apple is slightly different from the usual App Store submission process, because Maps is a built-in iPhone application," he said.

PCWorld: "We did not say we would bring it to iPhone, we said to date we've had it on Android and that in the future it may come to other platforms but did not confirm this will be coming to iPhone at all," a Google spokesperson told PCWorld.

So who's likely the liar; CNET, PCWorld, or Google?

I'm believing the VP of Engineering (CNET). I assume he knows what he and his people are working on and was pretty specific. Spokespeople are marketers and lie lie lie. He probably needed to cover for the slip made by the engineer. Hopefully because Jobs is announcing it with the new iphone in June!
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.