Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Congrats on the replacement. If you were going naked before, I'd like to suggest an otterbox case and the squaretrade warranty. :)
 
I bet coming in and just being up-front about what happened went a long way. I am sure the "geniuses" get a whole lot of stories that they can just tell are not true.

Being polite, nice, and honest as a customer can go a long way.

I handed them a plastic baggie filled with glass etc and the Genius said "this is obviously personal damage" LOL. I was truthful and would have paid the $199 in a heartbeat over the $499 the Apple site suggested (when placing a new phone in the cart).

Someone mentioned an Otterbox....it was on there...crushed by an almost 9000lb truck LOL. I must say that it had to have worked well enough to keep the electronics somewhat workable. I did not lose any data being able to sync it. I'm sure the MobilMe also helped.

I am VERY happy with Apple's customer care. I have never had to use them, one of the reasons why I love Apple. even when it was clearly my own fault, Apple came through to help me in a desperate time of need. With my wife leaving that next morning for Israel for work and me not having another phone. I am extremely grateful. :)
 
Just got back from Apple. I went in and explained my story along with the 2.5 hours drive I had. The Apple Genius told me it would be $199 to replace as it was obviously personal damage. He then told my wife that he had to tell her something about the mall when he came back. He came back a few minutes later and handed me my new phone and said it was FREE :) He then proceeded to tell my Wife there is a Tiffany's and a Burberry in the mall and that he was sure I would be happy to take her there LOL. What a great ending to a horrible day. I went to his manager and thanked him for the kindness and told him that the guy was great etc. One more reason why I love Apple.

I'm 100% sure this would never happen to me. Nothing nice ever happen to me at the Apple store. I had to fight them to prove that my iphone 3gs was over heating.
 
Wirelessly posted (Mozilla/5.0 (iPhone; U; CPU iPhone OS 4_2_1 like Mac OS X; en-gb) AppleWebKit/533.17.9 (KHTML, like Gecko) Version/5.0.2 Mobile/8C148 Safari/6533.18.5)

Great story! Happy to hear everything worked out in the end. I bet your iPhone would have been fine if you had a bumper on it, though.
 
wirelessly posted (mozilla/5.0 (iphone; u; cpu iphone os 4_2_1 like mac os x; en-gb) applewebkit/533.17.9 (khtml, like gecko) version/5.0.2 mobile/8c148 safari/6533.18.5)

i bet your iphone would have been fine if you had a bumper on it, though.

lol
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.