Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
I never knew how many people apparently care about their phone's speakers until the Air came along. I've honestly never known anyone to listen to much of anything through their phone's actual speakers as opposed to headphones, earbuds/airpods, or bluetooth speakers.

It's the convenience of having them, you may only use them occasionally to show someone a video, or to go on the speaker phone with someone, and when you do they will be loud. But with the Air you might struggle to hear it, and that’s annoying. Why compromise?

Dave2D did a video on exactly this

 
Last edited:
All in all, it is probably too expensive. In a lot of the world, people feel like they have less discretionary income compared to a few years ago, I imagine many people, much as they like the look of the air, are probably going for the standard 17 to save some money.

I honestly think it's price, not the specs, that's lowering demand. On forums like this, people focus on the specs, but I don't think that's indicative of the market overall.
That very well could be, but then why is the Pro/Max flying off the shelves? It’s even more expensive. I think Apple underestimated the compromises and will not make the same mistakes next time (if there is one).
 
  • Like
Reactions: decypher44
I did on day one in the Apple Store in Zurich.

I never disliked the design and concept of any iPhone like this since 2007.

Huge phablet, too bright, too tall — and the thin edge feels completely awkward in hand due to the massive dimensions of this phone.

And that idiotic, absurd, brainless, degenerated, distorted, tasteless, grotesque, misshapen, pathetic, clumsy, ugly, embarrassing, ridiculous, unaesthetic, incoherent, disfiguring, repulsive, atrocious, meaningless, primitive, miserable, dumb, overblown, design-wise bankrupt, illogical, disturbingly intrusive, unbearable, annoying, misengineered, insanely stupid, cheap-looking and visually offensive camera bump is a crime against customers who like asthethics.
Drama and caffeine, just say no...
 
I never knew how many people apparently care about their phone's speakers until the Air came along. I've honestly never known anyone to listen to much of anything through their phone's actual speakers as opposed to headphones, earbuds/airpods, or bluetooth speakers.
FaceTime, speaker phone, and Zoom are times people use speakers. There are also a lot of people who watch shows or whatever on their phones using the speaker(s).

The whole issue is likely hugely overblown though -- some people just really like to complain.
 
This is not the first time that people dont want a small and thin iPhone with SE and mini. Why Apple keep making same mistakes over and over again? Do they really think making iPhone Air with premium looking would solve the problem? Ha, nope.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: iPAU
I never knew how many people apparently care about their phone's speakers until the Air came along. I've honestly never known anyone to listen to much of anything through their phone's actual speakers as opposed to headphones, earbuds/airpods, or bluetooth speakers.
The single speaker on my Air actually works great, the sound is loud and clear for speaker phone calls and videos. I guess if someone uses their phone speakers as the only way they listen to music then it might be a deal breaker but how many people really fall into that category anyways. I think people are just looking for excuses to make up.
 
Compromises:
1. Single speaker
2. Single camera
3. Extremely poor battery life (due to thinness)
4. Inferior C1X 5G modem compared to SD X80 in Pro series
5. Too thin to hold.
6. Busted Wifi 7 that is incapable of 320 Mhz channel width on 6Ghz.
7. No mmWave which is in Pro models.
8. No display output via USB-C to an external monitor or TV.
9. Still USB 2.0 speeds for a premium device in 2025.
10. Slower binned SOC (again due to thinness and heat concerns)

Did I miss anything?
11. Not thin enough
 
  • Haha
Reactions: iPAU
Love my iPhone Air. Often forget it's in my pocket. Battery lasts plenty long for those of us who don't live on our phones all day. Performance is better than my 14 pro. The additional RAM helps with multi-tasking business apps.
1761137778625.png
 
  • Like
Reactions: Martyimac and ab2c4
I ended up returning my as well. It's about the value, it's a hard sell. I loved the way it felt, screen was beautiful, one of the best screens I've had on a portable device but what you give up for $100 more on a pro is just to much and lets get real, is a Pro really that much heavier, 41 grams.

Battery was not an issue now but something that just makes it a day, what will the life be in a year after some degradation.

What I really want to see is a Pro with a titanium frame like the Air and an aluminum back like the pros for heat, combine the two.
 
  • Like
Reactions: decypher44
Compromises:
1. Single speaker
2. Single camera
3. Extremely poor battery life (due to thinness)
4. Inferior C1X 5G modem compared to SD X80 in Pro series
5. Too thin to hold.
6. Busted Wifi 7 that is incapable of 320 Mhz channel width on 6Ghz.
7. No mmWave which is in Pro models.
8. No display output via USB-C to an external monitor or TV.
9. Still USB 2.0 speeds for a premium device in 2025.
10. Slower binned SOC (again due to thinness and heat concerns)

Did I miss anything?
Your first 2 points have merit, the rest are either irrelevant for the average consumer, incorrect or exaggerated.

All chips are binned - let's not rehash this nonsense.
 
That very well could be, but then why is the Pro/Max flying off the shelves? It’s even more expensive. I think Apple underestimated the compromises and will not make the same mistakes next time (if there is one).
Whilst in the past making a phone that was all about design would have been enough, it appears that consumer tastes have changed enough to see their tech, particularly their phones as just a utility. The Pro wins out just because it does more.
 
  • Like
Reactions: decypher44
People would definitely make these arguments for the MacBook Air if it were less powerful than a (non existent) MacBook and yet more expensive. The air series in other categories is either cheaper than the pro (but also less specced, see MacBooks) or cheaper than the pro and less performing but also more expensive and more performing than the base model (see iPads). iPhone air doesn’t make sense because it’s more expensive than the base iPhone and yet it has less (battery, camera, thermal management… ).

Though it also has a nicer design and larger screen than the base iPhone.

Maybe what is weird about this is we're used to good / better / best type of lineup. But with these phones it feels a bit mixed: base has the best value, Air the most premium feel/design, and Pro the best specs. I do feel like the Air could have been lower in price.
 
It's the convenience of having them, you may only use them occasionally to show someone a video, or to go on the speaker phone with someone, and when you do they will be loud. But with the Air you might struggle to hear it, and that’s annoying. Why compromise?

Dave2D did a video on exactly this

To each their own. For me I value the features I am using every day on my phone as the most important things I look for when buying a phone, not things I might or might use once every few months. The thin design and light weight of the Air makes the phone sooooooo much better and more comfortable to use every single time I hold my phone. I would rather have that feature with the air than another model phone that has dual speakers but that I hate using due to how uncomfortable it is to hold. I was so glad to get rid of my 16 Pro as it was a miserable phone to hold and use. It was a powerhouse of a phone for sure but I couldn't stand holding it. As for the single speaker in the Air, I have never struggled to hear it, its loud and clear sounding.
 
Makes sense, it’s a change in direction from the past decade or so to now pay a premium for design and smaller size. I’ll expect the other iPhones to outsell the Foldable once that is released as well.

Only a small part of the population are open to changes, the majority wants to carry on as they have until others have tested the waters. In that sense it was probably smart by Apple to leave a lot of improvements for the next version.
 
Compromises:
1. Single speaker
2. Single camera
3. Extremely poor battery life (due to thinness)
4. Inferior C1X 5G modem compared to SD X80 in Pro series
5. Too thin to hold.
6. Busted Wifi 7 that is incapable of 320 Mhz channel width on 6Ghz.
7. No mmWave which is in Pro models.
8. No display output via USB-C to an external monitor or TV.
9. Still USB 2.0 speeds for a premium device in 2025.
10. Slower binned SOC (again due to thinness and heat concerns)

Did I miss anything?
i don't like the iPhone air concept and don't own such iphone. but:

usb2.0 is no issue as you most probably just use the port to charge your phone, so this is not a real limitation.
320mhz support on wifi7 is also less of a real concern, as you cannot essentially do much with the extra bandwidth and it is unlikely that you can find 16x20MHz spectrum without interference
the same goes for mmWave, as the use case is even more limited compared to wifi7 and it requires line of sight and a pretty expensive MNO side support which limits where you can possibly use the technology.

whether the apple made c1 modem is inferior to SD x80 depends on your usage patterns. unless you're fixated on running download speed tests on your phone, the most actual throughput you'll likely get is when streaming high res video to it, which is 4-8Mbps for 1080p and ~20Mbps for 2160p. whether the rest of the spectrum is available to you for virtually doing nothing can be justified as a meaningful benefit i leave to you evaluate.

but i am wholeheartedly agree with the rest of the listed compromises, hence i wrote "i don't like the air concept". i see no real benefits with the device and form factor that would warrant a higher price for me, even if i put all the listed compromises aside.
 
I’ve been experiencing ear clogs, pain, and sensitivity to certain sounds. The doctor noticed this trend over the past decade, especially with frequent in-ear headphone use. He suggested stopping headphones or switching to over-ear ones. However, over-ear headphones can be uncomfortable. I’ve limited headphone use and stick to iPhone speakers, which resolved my ear issues. I hope that answers the question of why some people prefer the iPhone speakers.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: iPAU
Can't say I'm hugely surprised by this. Granted I only have a mild view of European markets, but no one I know actually bought an Air. Lots of Pro and Pro Max - but equally many people either sticking or shifting to the standard iPhone 17. It's quite interesting to me as I'd spoken to a lot of people about the Air but none of them actually bought one - seemingly all worrying about battery life and longevity.

On a separate but somewhat related note I moved from 13 Pro to 17 Pro and honestly I'm surprised by how little difference there is - stunned more like. Not a single feature truly stood out other than screen brightness being much improved. I wasn't even terribly impressed by the camera improvement - my main motivation for doing so. It's genuinely a bit disappointing and I'm not sure how it'll impact my future purchases - I'd never expected the 13 Pro to last me as long as it did (even with a battery replacement) and I find it concerning it could have lasted me a fair bit longer. I'd love to see more innovation.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mescagnus
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.