Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
I bet from a practical standpoint, the Leaf is a brilliant choice, and I was tempted too, but man, for me the auto industry simply hasn't come up with a way to make an EV anything but ugly. It's like all EVs are designed by the high-end sneaker industry. They must be seen, and so look as weird as possible. I'd love to see a leaf with the clean lines of a 2019 VW Golf or something. It's the main reason I was excited to see what Apple came up with the Apple Car was still a hope. I spend too much time in my car to look at something that looks like it came out of early 80s bad Japanese animation.
My Leaf looks just like most small SUVs on the road. Really don’t understand your statement
50BBEE48-AE70-4DB1-8C86-1A5851F3E3F9.jpeg
 
I bet from a practical standpoint, the Leaf is a brilliant choice, and I was tempted too, but man, for me the auto industry simply hasn't come up with a way to make an EV anything but ugly. It's like all EVs are designed by the high-end sneaker industry. They must be seen, and so look as weird as possible.

Maybe you are only noticing the weird looking EVs. Many EVs look quite normal and just like their gasoline counterparts, except perhaps missing a tailpipe or having a smooth front panel up front in place of a grill.

I'd love to see a leaf with the clean lines of a 2019 VW Golf or something.

Like the 2019 VW E-Golf?


144882-cars-review-volkswagen-egolf-lead-image1-x8gmldrj4v.jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: laurim
Don’t. I have the top of the line non-Plus Leaf and I love it. It’s the most luxurious car I’ve ever owned. Heated leather seats and steering wheel I can remotely turn on in the winter. I keep accidentally speeding because it’s so peppy. Love the eco-pedal so I rarely have to use the brake. All the mile range I need and I just plug it in when it’s in the garage. CarPlay works great and the Bose sound system sounds great. No complaints whatsoever. And my solar panels supply the fuel. Don’t have to go to the gas station or care about the price going up and down. No oil changes anymore.

I’m not into the whole ‘electric era’ of cars quite yet, but that’s actually a pretty sharp looking vehicle. The Leaf has come along way from where it started.
 
  • Like
Reactions: laurim
Not every EV looks like a Cybertruck. There are plenty of normal looking EVs. Here are some examples. There are more, but you get the point.

2020 Audi E-Tron SUV
audi-e-tron-sportback-104-1574208187.jpg


Audi E-Tron GT
052_e-tron-gt.jpg


Volvo XC40 Recharge
Volvo_XC40_Recharge_P8_AWD.jpg


2018 VW E-Golf
2015-volkswagen-e-golf-2_700.jpg


2021 VW ID.4
09dcda3c-2021-vw-id4-carscoops-3.jpg


Hyundai Kona
Large-34418-2019KonaElectric-e1548685064145.jpg


2019 Jaguar I-Pace
1-4.jpg


Ford Mustang Mach-E
mustang_mach-e_66.jpg


2019 Mercedes EQC
eq-c-053.jpg
 
Last edited:
All EV's have that, Nissan just tries to brand it like a feature. I love it in my Volt, people really won't understand what it's like to have an EV until they get one.


Even cheap EVs are anything but slow, bub. Seriously, go test drive a leaf or a bolt, you'll be surprised!

the original leaf did not have this feature... it seems to have been popularized by GM with the volt and the bolt. tesla only recently added one-pedal driving. honestly i think i like the way it works in the bolt the best but tesla's works OK as well.
[automerge]1576798611[/automerge]
The problem with the Leaf is that it has no battery thermo management, so the battery degrades very fast compared to other EV's. I know Nissan wanted to control the cost of the Leaf but you have to manage the temperature of the battery or else the degradation will significantly lower the range.

100% true - i destroyed the battery in my 2011 leaf charging with ChaDeMO (which was free, ironically, due to a class action lawsuit regarding the original battery pack failing almost instantly in hot weather.)

despite only ever charging it to 80% either by AC or ChaDeMO, by year 4 the battery capacity was so low that we had to start charging it to 100% to get decent range and by the time i sold it (for next to nothing) a fully-charged battery would report 60 miles of range. had i understood this at the outset i would have leased the car.

my almost 3-year old bolt has active battery cooling, but due to the 60kwh capacity i've never once had to quick charge it.

anyway i liked the leaf and the new leaf looks interesting but i'd never get one unless it was a $100 per month lease or something.
 
the original leaf did not have this feature... it seems to have been popularized by GM with the volt and the bolt. tesla only recently added one-pedal driving. honestly i think i like the way it works in the bolt the best but tesla's works OK as well.
and I only said I liked using it. Not into the whole “my device had this feature first/my device does it better” BS.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I bought a non plus Leaf 2019 SV recently. Price was a major reason. Selling price was $31,200. My electric provider gave me $3500 discount that was immediately taken off price at dealership. My state is giving me $2500 back and the fed tax credit is still $7500 for Nissan. Dealerships really wanted me to lease since they told me nobody ever buys it. But to own for $17,700 was too good of a deal imo to pass up.
 
  • Like
Reactions: HappyIntro and CIA
I bought a non plus Leaf 2019 SV recently. Price was a major reason. Selling price was $31,200. My electric provider gave me $3500 discount that was immediately taken off price at dealership. My state is giving me $2500 back and the fed tax credit is still $7500 for Nissan. Dealerships really wanted me to lease since they told me nobody ever buys it. But to own for $17,700 was too good of a deal imo to pass up.
Wow! Great deal! Pays to research the rebates and credits. I was bummed when I found out my electric/gas company only gave rebates for gas on-demand water heaters, not electric. Between their rebate and buying it on Amazon in the “Used but excellent” discount area it would have been very cheap. Don’t know why they only do gas since electric ones are more efficient.
 
Wow! Great deal!
Nissan has a promotion these days with EVGO/ChargePoint that gave me $250 charging credits for year 1.
Apparently the 30% refund on the installation of a home ev charger in back in play too. Actually looking forward to filing my 2019 taxes next year. Haha
 
  • Like
Reactions: laurim
Not every EV is a Cybertruck. There are plenty of normal looking EVs. Here are some examples. There are more, but you get the point.

2020 Audi E-Tron SUV
audi-e-tron-sportback-104-1574208187.jpg


Audi E-Tron GT
052_e-tron-gt.jpg


Volvo XC40 Recharge
Volvo_XC40_Recharge_P8_AWD.jpg


2018 VW E-Golf
2015-volkswagen-e-golf-2_700.jpg


2021 VW ID.4
09dcda3c-2021-vw-id4-carscoops-3.jpg


Hyundai Kona
Large-34418-2019KonaElectric-e1548685064145.jpg


2019 Jaguar I-Pace
1-4.jpg


Ford Mustang Mach-E
mustang_mach-e_66.jpg


2019 Mercedes EQC
eq-c-053.jpg

The cars without a grill are so off putting to me. I hate the duck lips of the Model 3.

My problem with EVs is mainly that you can’t get a performance model inexpensively. The higher end Leaf’s top out at a mediocre 6.5s 0-60. A base Model 3 at $40k will do it in a respectable 5.3s. But if you spend $35-40k on something like a Charger, Mustang, or Camaro, you’ll get to join the low to mid 4 second club. When you have a car that quick, it’s like riding a roller coaster whenever you want.
 
Last edited:
The cars without a grill are so off putting to me. I hate the duck lips of the Model 3.

My problem with EVs are mainly that you can’t get a performance model inexpensively. The higher end Leaf’s top out at a mediocre 6.5s. A base Model 3 at $40k will do it in a respectable 5.3s. But if you spend $40k on something like a Charger, Mustang, or Camaro, you’ll get to join the low to mid 4 second club.
I look at it like I did with my solar installation. Yes it cost me a ton to put panels on my roof, but I no longer have a power bill, so I'm saving $200 a month on electricity. That adds up over the years. In 6 more years I'll have paid it off, and then it's pure profit.

Could I have invested that money and made a better return? Maybe yes, maybe no. But I know for sure I will pay off those panels, and then I will be making money every month.

So yea, my EV cost a little more, but I'm saving a few thousand a year not paying for gas, oil, and maintenance. I know my car won't be profitable like my solar, but in the end it will still cost less then a gas car. Also EV's (modern ones at least) hold value pretty well compared to gas cars.
 
  • Like
Reactions: laurim
Nissan has a promotion these days with EVGO/ChargePoint that gave me $250 charging credits for year 1.
Apparently the 30% refund on the installation of a home ev charger in back in play too. Actually looking forward to filing my 2019 taxes next year. Haha
I got a credit for charging back in June, don’t think it was that much. But it may have expired IDK because I haven’t needed to charge away from home yet. I had bought a charger from amazon but sent it back when I realized my model included the fast charger cord so I just needed to have a 240v outlet installed in the garage. My accountant is trying to figure out how to juggle my car and solar panels tax credits. The car one HAS to be taken in the purchase year but my panels can be spread out. Already took about half that credit last year.
[automerge]1576800480[/automerge]
I look at it like I did with my solar installation. Yes it cost me a ton to put panels on my roof, but I no longer have a power bill, so I'm saving $200 a month on electricity. That adds up over the years. In 6 more years I'll have paid it off, and then it's pure profit.

Could I have invested that money and made a better return? Maybe yes, maybe no. But I know for sure I will pay off those panels, and then I will be making money every month.

So yea, my EV cost a little more, but I'm saving a few thousand a year not paying for gas, oil, and maintenance. I know my car won't be profitable like my solar, but in the end it will still cost less then a gas car. Also EV's (modern ones at least) hold value pretty well compared to gas cars.
Ditto. I didn’t buy those things to save money. I did it to live a greener lifestyle first. When they eventually pay for themselves and more, that’ll be my cherry on top.
[automerge]1576800783[/automerge]
The cars without a grill are so off putting to me. I hate the duck lips of the Model 3.

My problem with EVs is mainly that you can’t get a performance model inexpensively. The higher end Leaf’s top out at a mediocre 6.5s 0-60. A base Model 3 at $40k will do it in a respectable 5.3s. But if you spend $35-40k on something like a Charger, Mustang, or Camaro, you’ll get to join the low to mid 4 second club. When you have a car that quick, it’s like riding a roller coaster whenever you want.
Why in the world do you care about jackrabbit starts? I’ve never understood this. Means NOTHING in real life, bad for the car and wasteful in energy.
 
Last edited:
Why in the world do you care about jackrabbit starts? I’ve never understood this. Means NOTHING in real life, bad for the car and wasteful in energy.

The 0-60 is indicative of the amount of power a car has. Just because someone isn’t aiming to minimize their 0-60 every time they hit the pedal, doesn’t mean it isn’t fun when they do put the power down. I love flooring it down freeway on-ramps or being able to pass someone without issue on two lane roads. Nothing worse than being stuck behind someone going under the speed limit and not being able to pass because it’s going take too long to get around them because of a weak powertrain. And the ‘bad for your car’ argument doesn’t add up if all the components are engineered to suitable specs for its given application. Yeah, if you put a transmission or differential meant for a Corolla into a Corvette, it’s probably going to explode. If you don’t do something that stupid though, everything will be fine. It’s all about the materials and engineering used in the drivetrain.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Breezygirl
The cars without a grill are so off putting to me. I hate the duck lips of the Model 3.

I know exactly what you mean and I agree.

However, there are a LOT of gas cars without big grills up there, so I think it's possible to make normal looking cars without grills that don't end up like duck lips. For example my favorite looking car of all time, the Ferrari 308.

Another example, the Viper GTS (saw your username) has variants with that low, slim, split-intake instead of a big central grill, and it looks great.
 
you guys should drive the P3D+ or P3D- (performance/stealth performance model 3). i
and I only said I liked using it. Not into the whole “my device had this feature first/my device does it better” BS.


you said all EVs have one pedal driving and that's not quite true. nissan is making a big deal about it because it's a new feature for their cars, which was my point. not necessarily who did it first.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
That's a good point, but the context of the post I was replying to said Tesla had a huge lead and others had to "catch up". If you count that adapter for the totals, there's no way to "catch up" because the Tesla total will always include proprietary chargers that others cannot use. Also I don't think there are CCS adapters for Teslas.

In any case, I hate that this is even a contest. I think what would be best for EV community as a whole is to collectively pick a year in the future and have every EV maker switch to one connector at that point. Then provide adapters for legacy cars made prior to that year. CHAdeMO is just for Japanese cars, Tesla charging stations are just for Teslas, and there's SAE and CCS too. I don't think it is good for the community to have this kind of mess.


Those are all fair points, and true that tesla's have adaptors that can charge anywhere, meanwhile no one else can charge at a supercharger.
 
I know exactly what you mean and I agree.

However, there are a LOT of gas cars without big grills up there, so I think it's possible to make normal looking cars without grills that don't end up like duck lips. For example my favorite looking car of all time, the Ferrari 308.

Another example, the Viper GTS (saw your username) has variants with that low, slim, split-intake instead of a big central grill, and it looks great.
you guys should drive the P3D+ or P3D- (performance/stealth performance model 3). i

you said all EVs have one pedal driving and that's not quite true. nissan is making a big deal about it because it's a new feature for their cars, which was my point. not necessarily who did it first.
no, I didn’t. I merely included the e-pedal in my list of things I like. Someone else said all ev’s have it.
Those are all fair points, and true that tesla's have adaptors that can charge anywhere, meanwhile no one else can charge at a supercharger.
not true. There are adapters.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Until they put a thermal management system on the battery I would steer clear of this vehicle. The replacement price of the battery for current Leafs is over $10,000.
 
  • Like
Reactions: joeblough
Just buy a Tesla and forget about CarPlay. The only people on the Tesla forums that are stressing about whether it has CarPlay (it doesn't) are the people who haven't bought one yet. The only superior maps experience to the 15" map on Model 3 is the 17" map on the S and X (and that's debatable, given the S and X's awkward screen orientation.)

Really, if we're going to get some tighter Apple integration, I want to be able to AirPlay some videos to my Model 3's screen.
odd, Ive seen the complaints on the Tesla forums about lack of CarPlay so I don’t think its a non issue. As far as i know, if you have Apple Music, all you can do is hook it up to bluetooth and control it like that but theres no dedicated Siri button. So browsing music or even calling it up isn’t really possible. I talked to someone awhile back about this and asked what they do and they said “i have to pick up my phone while driving and choose the song and hit play. It’s kind of a pain”. Unless they’ve changed that and I’m just not up to date on it?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mac Fly (film)
Highly recommend to test drive a Tesla Model 3 if you're looking to purchase an EV. Not the car for you if you're make or break reason is CarPlay although they can just OTA and add them like how they will be doing on the next major update adding apps like Hulu, HBO, Crunchyroll. Wonders of OTA updates that Tesla currently only has. If you actually do care about Carplay that much to ward off a purchase and don't mind a little DIY then a cheap Android Fire 7 Tablet + CarPlay Adapter gets you CarPlay just put in phone holder compartment under screen; audio works just by connecting to Bluetooth as long as you on iOS 13.
 
Last edited:
Until they put a thermal management system on the battery I would steer clear of this vehicle. The replacement price of the battery for current Leafs is over $10,000.

Don’t worry, the car falls apart in 10 years, well before you’ll have to worry about the battery. It’s a feature apparently.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Breezygirl
Have they added battery cooling?
[automerge]1576850048[/automerge]
Don’t worry, the car falls apart in 10 years, well before you’ll have to worry about the battery. It’s a feature apparently.
In the spirit of making things up.
[automerge]1576850315[/automerge]
Until they put a thermal management system on the battery I would steer clear of this vehicle. The replacement price of the battery for current Leafs is over $10,000.
This is important. Though less crucial depending on local climate per driver. Also can’t the user have replaced just the depleted cells and get a reconditioned battery cells fitted for much less than a new one?

But thermal management would be great.
 
Last edited:
Those are all fair points, and true that tesla's have adaptors that can charge anywhere, meanwhile no one else can charge at a supercharger.

Not quite true. There is a Chademo to Tesla adapter for $450. But is very bulky and Chademo is limited to 50 kW.

Tesla Supercharges are commonly 150kW and some are 250 kW. The 250 kW can add up to 1000 miles of range per hour.

In the Europe some Tesla superchargers have European CCS2 connectors and many Teslas have European CCS2 connectors (mostly model 3s?). But some (Model S and X?) still have proprietary Tesla connector.

In the US (Americas?) Teslas have the proprietary Tesla connector. There is no US CCS 2 to Tesla adapter so here in the US a Tesla cannot use a CCS2 charger.

So the fast DC charging space is kind of a mess if you look at from a distance, but on the ground it is not quite as bad.

The other thing to remember is that for many EV owners they charge at home 99% of the time using home AC current. You come home, spend 5 seconds plug in. And at some later when the rates are low, the car starts charging. In the morning you spend 5 seconds to unplug and leave with "full" tank and have full range. It is as difficult as charging you phone at home.

For me the bottom line is that the only time you charge anywhere but home is on a trip. So you seldom need to stop a charging station, and potential deal charger conflicts. As a result, for many, a lot these charger incompatibilities are small annoyance, more than a daily hassle.
 
Maybe you are only noticing the weird looking EVs. Many EVs look quite normal and just like their gasoline counterparts, except perhaps missing a tailpipe or having a smooth front panel up front in place of a grill.

It's gotten way better, I'll give you that. The first Prius I saw was horrendous, and we've come a long way from there, but there's still something about the design that could use a refinement. I imagine it'll come.

Like the 2019 VW E-Golf?


144882-cars-review-volkswagen-egolf-lead-image1-x8gmldrj4v.jpg

Yes, *exactly* like that. But I defy you to actually find one to buy. I was going to get exactly this, and they told me that I'd be waiting at least a couple years, as every one of the cars shipped to Canada was gone before they even hit the shores. The waiting list is brutal, and the supply is simply not keeping up with demand. I needed a car, so I couldn't go this way.

But VW is honest the only car maker that seems to be doing this in a way that says, "here's a car. Here's our design. You choose how to power it." There's no specific design for it just because it's an EV.
[automerge]1576853226[/automerge]
My Leaf looks just like most small SUVs on the road. Really don’t understand your statementView attachment 883824

It's more the interior for me. I care less what the car looks like from the outside than inside as that's what I'm looking at most of the time. But since I've posted, I looked at the dashboards of recent gas-powered cars from Toyota, and they look no better, so maybe I'm misinformed and that's just how things coming from Asia look these days. Aesthetics are subjective, so I guess I'll just say I prefer the German offerings, and leave it at that. *shrug*
 
Last edited:
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.