Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

MacRumors

macrumors bot
Original poster


Accessory company Alogic has been releasing an increasing number of displays, and the latest model arrives as a 40-inch 5K2K ultrawide model that joins existing 34-inch and 40-inch 4K models in the Edge family. I've been testing out the new 40-inch 5K2K model for the past few months, and I've found it to be a solid display offering major screen real estate for productivity users.

alogic-edge-5k-front.jpg

As a 40-inch ultrawide display, the Edge 5K is big, and it arrives in a fairly large box, although it is packaged efficiently with styrofoam padding, stand parts, and other accessories nestled around the massive display. The Edge 5K is available in either silver or space gray, and setup is simple, with a large metal foot that's attractively thin paired with a solid arm that features a cable passthrough for organization. The two stand pieces attach easily to each other with a single screw that can be tightened by hand or with a screwdriver, and the whole stand snaps easily into the back of the display.

Alternatively, you can use any sturdy 100×100mm VESA mount if you prefer a different method of supporting the display. A separate 180-watt power brick powers the display and attached accessories, and it can push up to 90 watts upstream to a connected computer.

I will say that there is a bit of wobble in the display, due partly to the sheer size of the display panel and also the range of adjustments supported by the stand, which includes height, tilt, swivel, and rotation. It remains stable enough on my desk amid vibrations from typing and other movement, but it can definitely wobble if you bump it or have it on surface that is anything less than rock solid. Alogic tells me the bit of wobble is a tradeoff it elected to make in order to maximize adjustability. It's certainly not a deal-breaker for me, but something to be aware of.

alogic-edge-5k-side.jpg

This display looks sleek, with thin black bezels around the top and sides and then a thicker silver aluminum chin with some subtle Alogic branding and a power status light (that does unfortunately pulse rather brightly while the display is sleeping, so be aware if you're using it in a bedroom). The panel housing itself has a very thin profile on the upper two-thirds, and then a thicker portion bulging out of the back on the lower third where the stand attachment, ports, and electronics are housed.

The upper two thirds is actually glass on the rear, which brings a bit of class if you position your display such that the rear of it is visible. The design also takes advantage of the display backlight to provide a lighted Alogic logo on the rear of the display, which could be a positive or a negative depending on your preference. Alogic tells me it put extra focus on the design of the display's backside, based on feedback from users who like to use these monitors in offices where the rear is frequently visible to others sitting across a desk, for example.

alogic-edge-5k-rear.jpg

I was impressed with the display quality out of the box. I really didn't need to make any adjustments in either macOS or the through on-screen menus of the display, though I did ultimately play around with them to understand the range of adjustments that are available. As a 40-inch 5K2K display, it measures in at 5,120 by 2,160 pixels at 138 pixels per inch. That doesn't match true Retina pixel density of an iMac or a smaller 4K or 5K display, but I was pleasantly surprised at how sharp everything looked, even coming from my usual setup of as pair of high-density LG UltraFine 5K displays.

The Edge 5K offers 100% coverage of the sRGB spectrum, 99% of DCI-P3, and 94% of Adobe RGB. It also supports refresh rates up to 100Hz, and while that's not as high as some gaming-specific displays on the market, the bandwidth demands of the display's high resolution limits the ability to push a super-high refresh rate. Still, 100Hz is great for a productivity-focused setup and will even work fine for many games.

This is a matte display, so definitely be aware of that if it's a concern for you. I'm doing productivity work near a window and can get a bit of glare at certain times of day, so I prefer matte displays and this one looks great to my eye. It's an IPS panel with up to 400 nits of typical brightness, which is fine for my workspace although there are brighter displays on the market.

While you can certainly run the display at full 5,120 × 2,160 resolution, I found that it made on-screen content too small given the viewing distance I am typically at. On the other end, running at 2,560 × 1,080 as a true Retina display made content too large, so I found the 3,840 × 1,620 scaled option to be the perfect resolution for this display in my setup. It provides a large canvas for putting multiple apps and windows side-by-side, with everything appearing at a legible size, and macOS handles scaled resolutions quite well so I had no issues with display quality.

Coming from a pair of 27-inch 5K displays, I did have to figure out a new layout for my desktop with the slightly smaller amount of screen real estate, but having it all on one display made it easier to adjust my window sizes and tile them on my desktop.

alogic-edge-5k-ports.jpg

The Edge 5K features a number of handy connectivity options on the rear, with display connectivity options of USB-C (supports both data and power delivery), DisplayPort 1.4, and HDMI 2.0 (refresh rate limited to 30Hz at 5K resolution). When connected over USB-C, the display also acts as a hub with two additional downstream USB-C ports running at USB 2.0 speeds, a Gigabit Ethernet port, and a 3.5mm audio jack for connecting headphones or externally-powered speakers (does not support microphone input).

Two 3-watt speakers are built into the display, but as is typical in most displays, they don't sound great. The speakers also don't integrate with Mac keyboard shortcut keys for volume (the same is true for display brightness), but Alogic tells me it's planning a firmware update for around the middle of the year to add this functionality.

alogic-edge-5k-joystick-ports.jpg

The rear of the Edge 5K features a joystick button to access and navigate through the on-screen menus. It provides quick access to volume, brightness, display presets, and cycling through connected video sources, and then you can dive deeper into an array of adjustments for the backlight, contrast,... Click here to read rest of article

Article Link: Review: Alogic's Edge 5K Display Offers an Ultrawide Big-Screen Experience
 
  • Like
  • Wow
Reactions: Z-4195 and drrich2
I'm down with the ultra wide aspect ratio, but 133 PPI is trash and macOS scaling algorithm is not optimized for non integer scaling. PC gamers have stunted the monitor market with their insatiable thirst for high refresh rates above all other specs.

Don't put it on gamers, put on Apple for not fixing their scaling issues. Windows has no problem with it.

It's easily fixed with BetterDisplay, so it's possible.
 
I'm down with the ultra wide aspect ratio, but 133 PPI is trash and macOS scaling algorithm is not optimized for non integer scaling. PC gamers have stunted the monitor market with their insatiable thirst for high refresh rates above all oter specs.
Any suggestions for looking at?
 
Don't put it on gamers, put on Apple for not fixing their scaling issues. Windows has no problem with it.

It's easily fixed with BetterDisplay, so it's possible.

I have Better Display. It's not a fix. It just gives you more resolution options. And there's nothing broken for Apple to fix. They just have a different philosophical approach to that of Microsoft. Windows uses resolution independence to recalculate UI elements at any specific scale you choose, ensuring crisp lines at fractional settings like 150% by aligning them to the physical pixel grid. But the burden is on each app developer to support it. By contrast, MacOS renders a massive virtual canvas and scales the entire image to fit the screen, which guaranteees consistent app sizes without needing developer support but can result in slight softness when the math isn't a perfect integer.

And the low-dpi panel situation is 100% down to the monitor market pandering to gamers. The vast majority of 3rd party monitors are sold to PC users, and refresh rate is an easy spec to juice up and market to gamers who make up a large chunk of the non-business market. It's harder and more expensive to make higher density panels. We're only now just seeing affordable 6K panels on the market.
 
So worse specs and a higher price than the Studio Display, from a no-name company that didn't start making displays until four years ago? Got it.

I'm not even sure why this display that doesn't offer any macOS support or features is being reviewed here.
 
Last edited:
I have Better Display. It's not a fix. It just gives you more resolution options. And there's nothing broken for Apple to fix. They just have a different philosophical approach to that of Microsoft. Windows uses resolution independence to recalculate UI elements at any specific scale you choose, ensuring crisp lines at fractional settings like 150% by aligning them to the physical pixel grid. But the burden is on each app developer to support it. By contrast, MacOS renders a massive virtual canvas and scales the entire image to fit the screen, which guaranteees consistent app sizes without needing developer support but can result in slight softness when the math isn't a perfect integer.

And the low-dpi panel situation is 100% down to the monitor market pandering to gamers. The vast majority of 3rd party monitors are sold to PC users, and refresh rate is an easy spec to juice up and market to gamers who make up a large chunk of the non-business market. It's harder and more expensive to make higher density panels. We're only now just seeing affordable 6K panels on the market.

BetteryDisplay gives you HiDPI scaling at more resolutions than macOS. I'm running some odd resolution on my Dell 27" 4k, and it looks like a blurry mess without BetterDisplay, but perfect with it. I don't like Apple's monitor offerings for a multitude of reasons, but lack of multiple inputs and virtually no cross-platform compatibility are the main ones, so I'm glad to have it.

Whatever Apple's reason, it makes the monitor choices awfully limited if you don't know what is going on, or you just deal with fuzzy text.

4k is enough for me, personally. I don't care about Retina at my desk.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: drrich2
I'm down with the ultra wide aspect ratio, but 133 PPI is trash and macOS scaling algorithm is not optimized for non integer scaling. PC gamers have stunted the monitor market with their insatiable thirst for high refresh rates above all other specs.
60hz is terrible
 
My Linux machine has a 165hz display whereas my M5 Air only has 60. I barely notice a difference. I don't play games these days (except Stardew Valley and Project Zomboid) so I don't notice much of a difference. Scrolling is smoother, but that's about it.
 
When this monitor is at $1,699.99, the LG UltraFine 5K2K is a much better purchase. Same size and resolution, but the LG has:
  • 120Hz refresh
  • Nano IPS Black panel (Alogic’s is just regular IPS according to their spec page)
  • A built-in KVM thunderbolt 5 hub with:
    • 1 upstream TB5
    • 1 downstream TB5
    • 1 upstream USB-C for a second computer
    • 4x 10Gbps USB-C
    • 2x 10Gbps USB-A
  • HDMI 2.1 and DP 2.1 where as the Alogic has HDMI 2.0 and DP 1.4
The LG monitor is only $100 more
 
Please stop calling 5K2K displays as 5K. They are cheap low pixel-density screens with about half the pixel count of a 5K display. Uninformed people end up buying these things just because websites like Macrumors make them seem better than they are.
You are trying to mislead people with your claim. The actual pixel counts are:
5K: 14,745,600
5K2K: 11,059,200

Your claim about "half the pixel count" is outright false.
 
When this monitor is at $1,699.99, the LG UltraFine 5K2K is a much better purchase. Same size and resolution, but the LG has:
  • 120Hz refresh
  • Nano IPS Black panel (Alogic’s is just regular IPS according to their spec page)
  • A built-in KVM thunderbolt 5 hub with:
    • 1 upstream TB5
    • 1 downstream TB5
    • 1 upstream USB-C for a second computer
    • 4x 10Gbps USB-C
    • 2x 10Gbps USB-A
  • HDMI 2.1 and DP 2.1 where as the Alogic has HDMI 2.0 and DP 1.4
The LG monitor is only $100 more
I keep wanting to buy this 40" LG for the reasons you list, but it has noisy internal fans. That's a dealbreaker.
 
I have the LG. I honestly can’t hear the fan much at all, but I know everyone has different sensitivities.
So rare to be able to talk to an actual owner of this monitor. Can you give any more detail on the fan noise? Does it rise or fall with heavy or longer sessions?

And what do you think of the display otherwise? What resolution are you running? Does text look crisp? Are the brightness and black levels noticeably better than standard LCDs?

Thanks in advance.
 
  • Like
Reactions: akidd
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.